Saregamapa

35 Comments

• At 2008.10.03 19:19, dockaul said:

  Dears Pradeep , NYCOOL J , Observer, Senty , Rajdeep & Mehfil..
  Do hope you read my concluding comment on the 27th Sept episode..

  @ Harjeet - Maa’m , have noticed a perceptible drop in your contributions.. Hope it’s just writer’s fatigue..

  [Reply]
• At 2008.10.03 20:20, AgentX said:

  Nice show.. too much drama.. but i enjoyed the performances..

  Cheers!

  [Reply]
• At 2008.10.03 20:22, chupa said:

  Faraz is out!!
  there was Sara, Shujat n Faraz in the bottom line!! Obviously 3 pakistanis!!
  they said LAGTA HAIN AAPKAY LIYAY PAKISTAN VOTE NAHI KAR RAHA!! wht the hell! everything is planned!!!

  [Reply]
• At 2008.10.03 21:20, parveen said:

  too true, sa re is always planned just like last time Amaanat was the best but favouritism beat talent.

  [Reply]
• At 2008.10.03 21:54, Tsering said:

  Go Yashita You Rock…. for sure man she’s going to win this thing

  [Reply]
• At 2008.10.03 23:13, Music lover said:

  Yashita was definitely awesome.
  But I think yashita got more votes because she called imran khan on stage and stuff. And once befoer she had danced with Arshad Warsi. I feel that definitely helped her.

  Not everyone votes only based on singing ability.

  [Reply]
• At 2008.10.03 23:51, feminist (the original one) said:

  i don’t understand why so many people dislike yashita. her attitude is great - she’s very confident and that’s what helps her performance so much.

  [Reply]
• At 2008.10.04 00:14, Jamshid said:

  Tarun, Asma and Sara still IN and Faraz OUT … yeh kahan ka insaaf hai bhai … Just like last year when Mauli was in and good singers were getting out …

  Aaj, as usual, kafi drama tha … Debojit wala bhi aik maha-drama tha … yaar the guy is singing just fine bcoz he CAN SING … why highlight his special child status …

  IMHO, kafi fazool performance dee thi yashita nay … and all the judges were going history shistory … or may be the original in male voice was much more energetic and spicy … yashita is capable of much more … anyway …

  Tonight’s best performance was no doubt Vaishali’s … bohot hi acha … bohot hi sur mein gaya … her voice didn’t turn into a scream in this song … kuch ‘jaghhein’ bohot achi li thi vaishali nay … superb job …

  Debo ki performance waqai mein halki thi … especially the starting in lower tones ‘uss ke siwa koi yaad nahi’ … sur kafi hil rahe the … and that crispiness when singing ‘huwa huwa huwa mein MAST’ was missing … he could have sung the song a notch higher …

  and oh God … koi Himesh to urdu/hindi sikhaye … ‘Auratein’ is a very ODD kinda word to be used in formal conversation … he could use .. ‘ladies’ ‘larkian’ ‘khawateen’ ‘female singer’ but ‘AURATEIN’??? …

  AND .. the second best performance was of Shujaat … and wht the hell were judges saying about sur hilay huay the … except for one place when he goes ‘ masti mein rahe dooba dooba …’ he sorta slipped on going to the higher note on the word dooba and didnt catch the sur … but the rest was bang on … anyway …

  Sara performance was pretty ordinary … i keep on saying that she uses her ‘head voice’ and has to learn to use her ‘gut voice’ but you see ‘woh apni mama ki pali see baby hay naa’ …

  I am really really disappointed in Faraz leaving … he was far far better than all the negative comments he was given … Aadesh was right in saying that ‘channo ki aankh’ didn’t have that ‘gunjaish’ where he can show his singing abilities … oh well … one less good singer in the show in my opnion …

  I guess Zee needs more SMS revenue from Pakistan hence the bottom 3 being pakistani and that provocation regarding the votes … yaar seriously … does anyone in this forum do actually ‘vote’??? I just see the program for music and votes shotes are just a revenue grabbing scheme by the corporation … better to discourage it …

  And Prathiba ki kitna lammmmmmmmmmbi gardan hai … more enhanced bcoz of her droopy shoulders … the classic ’suraahi-daar gardan’
  waiting for tomorrow’s episode … ciao …

  Jamshid

  [Reply]
  • At 2008.10.04 09:42, AgentX said:

    @Jamshid

    BANG ON dear.. cudn’t have said it better.. keep up the good work..

    Cheers!

    [Reply]
  • At 2008.10.04 09:44, AgentX said:

    Oh btw, i would certainly differ with your comments about Yashita, it was a pretty darn good performance..

    [Reply]
    • At 2008.10.04 17:47, Jamshid said:

      I am watching the performance again and you are right AgentX … Yashita’s performance wasn’t THAT ordinary … in fact it was not bad at all … BUT the thing is when your expectations from a person are high and she/he gives an OK performance, you still get disappointed … same is the case here … yashita is capable of much more … my 2 cents … Thanks …
      Jamshid

      [Reply]
  • At 2008.10.05 11:12, Iqra said:

    keep it up jam-shit, your comments r awesome ordinary about the contestants. Faraz wasnt showing any performance except show off of his dress and cap and ‘futt a futt. He has no basic training of classical songs nor of pop songs. On the other hand other pakistani singers Sara, Shujaat and Zaheer all r qualified singer and have attained good training in every walk of music. your disappointment on faraz elimination is just bcz u r his younger brother. Sara and Zaheer have performed some beautiful songs at number of occasions. And ‘akka’ India is fan of them. Today also zaheer performed a pretty powerful performance again. Summing up, Sara & Zaheer both are excellent singers and every one votes them a lot.

    [Reply]
• At 2008.10.04 03:21, Basit said:

  Vaisali & Yashita rocked!! They were much ahead of the rest tonight.
  All other performances were ordinary, Debo & Sara couldn’t maintain their earlier promise. And as I have noticed times and again Shujaat has some problem for not concentrating on his singing rather he tries to be a showman, idher udher dekhna, zulfain jhatakna.. he is just spoiling his talent. I don’t know why the gurus are not correcting this most obvious shortcoming in him.
  I look forward to tomorrow’s episode and as usual I have expectations from Zaheer & Kaushak to give entertaining performances.

  Last but not the least, I request Mehfil to come back. Yar eik din ka ghussa kafi hai, pl write after tomorrows episode. If you haven’t read my comments of 27 Sep episode (after your breaking news) then I repeat them below:
  Mehfil dear,
  No way u can leave this blog.. I mean NO WAY at all. You can’t do it dude. I agree with AgentX that ignoring is the best policy. your time is too precious to respond to such cheap threads.
  And for me, you along with Dockaul are same to this blog what Shankar M is to srgmp. And we all know well what srgmp look like if SM is taken out!!!
  So you are coming back FOR SURE!!!!!!!!!!

  [Reply]
  • At 2008.10.04 10:06, AgentX said:

    Shujaat surely is distributing his talent in singing and showmanship.. i think he has gotten the grip of latest “attach with audience” trend.. and he is doing it pretty good.. i am amazed how he took at initiative of appologizing with debo’s mother.. that certainly “earned” him some “respect” in “janta’s” eyes.. i would certainly appreciate IF he sticks with singing..

    Cheers!

    [Reply]
• At 2008.10.04 04:10, dockaul said:

  Dear Basit Bhai!
  It is an honour for this irreverent gadfly to be spoken of in the same terms as Mehfil Da Ossumly Special.
  Thanks for the encomiums ,as lately we seem to be “Mahaguroors with hidden specious agendas” to our detractors & it is indeed gratifying to be remembered positively. Thank you.

  [Reply]
  • At 2008.10.04 05:57, Basit said:

    Dr. Saheb,
    I wrote what I feel and I do mean it. There is no shame in acknowleding some one’s valuable work.
    I have replied to your mail through my hotmail address (diwanbasit@hotmail.com) as I was having problem with gmail address.

    [Reply]
  • At 2008.10.04 11:49, AgentX said:

    “irreverent gadfly”.. thehro.. meri dictionary kidhar hai.. hmmm.. irreverent means.. hmm.. okay.. got it.. okay now for the gadfly.. gadfly.. gadfly.. okay here it is.. hmmm.. got it..

    Hayyyyy.. Doccccc… you should not say THAT.. man you are one hell of a guy..

    okay.. what is encomiums.. hmmm.. got it again.. okay.. now for detractors.. okay.. here it is…

    FINALLYYYYYYYYYYYYY.. a mango person understood you Doc :D … Yipeeeeeeee

    ha ha ha.. that was just for fun jigar.. dont mind

    You tot up as a laudable philanthropist and i deference your opinion..

    

    Cheers!

    [Reply]
    • At 2008.10.04 18:34, dockaul said:

      My Dearest Agent X,
      Your stellar efforts at “ad capatandum valgus” by using aenostic means are blithely apparent even to a cacotin. This capatation by your efforts at chareintism remain balantroinc to say the least. My exhortation to you - stick to clinquiant cantatory affairs.

      Dicki Dat ! Jigar !

      [Reply]
      • At 2008.10.04 19:02, Mehfil said:

        Dockaul, Duh ? can you please write that piece again in ENGLISH ? please ? ha ? bcoz I I wonder if Shakespeare used all of these words in nay of his works !

        Way to go Doc !

        Basit and Doc, I’m around, just lost the interest, I will be fine, as long as the show continues to be retarded, and the decency in the blog remains an issue, I will try to refrain from posting unnecessary comments. Thanks

        [Reply]
      • At 2008.10.04 19:38, AgentX said:

        Okay.. I give up.. *hands in the air*

        hahahaha…

        Cheers!

        [Reply]
    • At 2008.10.04 18:43, dockaul said:

      oops! Before anybody erudite corrects me - errata -
      balantronic , Clinquant ,

      [Reply]
      • At 2008.10.04 19:36, dockaul said:

        Disclaimer -
        Lest any cretin henceforth accuse me of being a showoff with BEEG words, I confess I had never heard any of them before tonight. Google Bhagwan ki Jai ho.. Type Luciferous logolepsy in search & enjoy.

        [Reply]
• At 2008.10.04 05:33, NYCOOLJ said:

  Asma showed genuine emotions toward Faraz. She has a heart of gold and a silky voice. She is already a champ.

  @Mehfil - please don’t leave the board. I didn’t mean any offense. Everyone seems to be so uptight here - this is just a message board - please do not make it the centerpiece of your life. I promise to stop mailing you meds for flatulence. Again, please keep posting.

  @Gaayika - Aunty-ji, I think I am being misunderstood because of using American slang. “Sucking up to” someone is a common practice when you want something from that someone - it has zero/nil/nada/zip sexual connotation. Don’t be embarrased to suck up to Uncle-ji. Similarly, an “old fart” is a humorous way to describe a veteran who keeps repeating the same statements. Also, we refer to our dads fondly as “my old man”. So please chill out.

  @DocKaul and @AgentX … you guys have a great balanced approach and the gravitas to influence others. Good job.

  Now let’s all get back to making Asma the winner - she’s the harbinger of a new nasal style of singing which will make all other styles obsolete. Go Asma.

  [Reply]
  • At 2008.10.04 06:34, Basit said:

    NYCOOLJ,
    My gut feeling is that you are making a mockry of srgm team for selecting Asma in the finals. Her presence in the finalists has aleady put a dent on the credibility of Zee Creative team and now you want to punish them further for keeping Asma in the show at the expense of deserving candidates.
    Lets see “kub tak Zee apne paoon pe kulhari marta hai” I don’t think they are too foolish to linger on this drama. A few more days for “TRP” and she would be gone. I hope after that you will be at peace with yourself and others….

    [Reply]
  • At 2008.10.04 10:28, AgentX said:

    @NYCOOLJ

    This was a much needed message from you mate!.. i agree with you that it is just a message board.. a cyber space gathering.. but you have to keep in mind that it is enriched with people of certain background and culture.. i do NOT deny your culture of America but i surely will expect you to follow the culture of the majority of people coming here.. so in respect of majority.. you should refrain from using “normal” American slang..

    Now don’t start about “freedom of speech” thingy with me.. you DO NOT have that even in USA or UK (where I live).. its just a myth, a metaphor used to keep “other” people “in check”.. there are certain things which you simply CANNOT say or DO..

    I am not blaming you but in last few days.. the mood of this board has changed drastically.. I started coming/commenting here cuz people use to give their “opinion” in a very civilized way.. they use to discuss and talk about positives and negatives of contestants purely on singing basis.. they use to agree/disagree but were always “respectful”..

    Its still up to you what route you take from here..

    Just my two cents..

    Cheers!

    [Reply]
  • At 2008.10.04 19:07, Mehfil said:

    NYCOOL,

    No dude, trust me I am not offended by you, you said nothing wrong, I’m fine with a few pithy remarks here and there, I just couldn’t handle that south africa guy going ballsitic, I guess it was meant for you.
    and I just want you to know that I have a lot of time at my disposal, despite a 24/7 IT alerts. this and some other blogs keep me busy and going.

    BTW, do not stop the shipment fo rthe meds, I can use a few ! hehehehe

    [Reply]
• At 2008.10.04 09:58, Imran said:

  OMG. faraz is out for the wish wauood. now i m telling all of u the winner is obviously debojit or other bangali. its bet baki sary darame hein zee tv kay. bus hum log hi ullo banny ja rahy hein.
  yashita ne gaya eik ho gaye hum aur tum woh ek hogaey hum aur tum tha. aur dosri jis ne second number hasil kiye . us ka gala kaanp raha tha. oh god. in ko history bakiuoon ko. tay tay fish

  [Reply]
• At 2008.10.04 14:36, AgentX said:

  Admin.. Good work taking those comments OFF the site..

  Cheers!

  [Reply]
  • At 2008.10.04 14:37, AgentX said:

    btw.. i think it would be helpfull if you add ban words in this forum’s basic script.. that’ll ease ur work a lot..

    Just my thoughts..

    Cheers!

    [Reply]
• At 2008.10.04 16:15, Alhamra said:

  Sara u r fabulous great singer. Inshallah u will win and all votes are for u. Love u

  [Reply]
  • At 2008.10.05 03:40, srgmp said:

    Yup she will win!

    [Reply]
• At 2008.10.04 23:47, Shashi Supporter said:

  By the way did everyone hear Asma’s hindi when Faraz was eliminated?!

  No “Main Gaata Hai”, “Thoda Thoda” crap!!! Perfect hindi! Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

  [Reply]
• At 2008.10.05 00:43, Leila said:

  what the HELL is this?? I just CANT believe that Faraz got eliminated and that stupid little JOKER, Asma is still there. thats JUST SHITT,..do you people want a SINGER or a JOKER. I mean C’MOn asma CAN NOT sing,..FARAZ is such a GOOD singer,..I didnt deserve to go today,..not only this stupid Joker but there are also others that are not better than him. SO C’MON PEOPLE lets be FAIR yeah,…
  thank you

  [Reply]
• At 2008.10.05 11:02, Iqra said:

  Sara is No. 1 she sang a difficult song this episode. She is proving herself a mature singer with beautiful unconventional voice. Her high tones are equally good to that of low tones. Luv you so much.

  [Reply]
• At 2008.10.10 06:17, raj said:

  Hi naina you sing very well with your smaileing also so cute i love you so much. mai teri diwana huwahu ho saketo mujhe is id me mail jarur karna. diwanadil21@yahoo.com iam waiting your mail ok anyway wish you all the best.

  [Reply]