I totally agree with. Everyone has its own respect.. and whatever happened was really an upsetting event !
We all know Asma cant sing but that does not give us any right to offend her in Public on tv and millions watching !
TO ZEETV !
C’mon piece of sh*ts…. if you guys didnt want this to happen … that poor little girl would have been happy even though is she got eliminated…. !!! But NOO!! money must roll-in and to hell with anyone’s respect !
I am a Pakistani and i personally feel bad when Asma’s uncle got on stage and made those comments… !
At 2008.10.25 07:21, feminist (the original one) said:
Out of all the negative comments on Asma, I was most disgusted by Debojit and Shujat’s comments! They have revealed their low, cheap character. Shame on them!
I have no comments about Debojit’s comments on Asma because he is a “special child” and sometimes he doesn’t even know how he acts…for example the way he says “Arz hai” with that piculiar posture before starting his shayeries..proves that poor chap doesn’t realize what he is doing.
So I actually sympathize with him for his behavior!!!
Just my 2 cents about Debojit. Yashita is rthe best anyways!!
that’s true.and the sad part is that they make debojit say it over and over( the arz kiya hai part),but they are actually making fun of him.it’s very unfair.i am sure pratibha will go off soon too.she is a great singer,but she doesnt do any drama ,no extra smart talks,no nonsense and i had the utmost respect for her cos she didnt comment about asma.she was the only one who didnt.this show is no longer about talent but just about popularity based on drama.it is sad for all the talented kids.i am so upset that shashi,manisha and kaushik are out
JABIRTHEFASTEST hi kaminay batoon say pata chalta hai shakal buhat burri ho gi app ki.asma ke bare mai jo kaha theek tha .besure ko besura nahi to aur kya kahin ge.us ki waja se shujat itna acha surila contestant bahir ho gaya.chlo asma to abhi compitition mai hai.zaleel jahil islami muashare ko kiyu bura bhala kahte ho.mujhay to tum asma ke baap lagte ho badi takleef mai bachare konse izzat ki bat karte ho kya kih diya hai ke tum galiya de rahe ho..aur itni besharmi say kaha mare papa ni mama ko divorce dadi. tum gana chhor datin aur maa ko manati BAP business mind hoga pata tha mere beti buhat agay jaye ge itni khubsurat hai paisa kamae gi.is liye biwe chhor di.naina faraz kaushik shujat fantastic singer the sab nakal gae is ki waja se.aur zaheer ni tu kuch kaha bhi nahin.tarun ne jo kaha zee tv walon ne kaha hoga to kaha.debojit buhat accha hamesha sach bolta hai.ye sab kuch zee ne asma ko hamdardiya dilane ki liye kiya .look sab log ban gaye na us ki hamdard.yahi to zee chahta hai.
.
asma got comments on her personal life because she opened her personal life on stage……… and i wonder if a person can sacrifice her mother for just singing on that stage
and the outburst of other contestant is fair ……. asma gets history even for mediocre performance just on the base that she is improving but it is a competition and the judgement should be on a comparison basis and not individual growth
asma is nowhere close to the eliminated singers like naina , kaushik, mitika n shujat……….. and i think esp aadeshji is too biased abt her….
At 2008.10.25 23:07, feminist (the original one) said:
I’m not a fan of Asma, but here is what I have to say:
Even though Asma may have revealed her personal life on stage, that does not give the contestants any right to comment on it! Neither is Shujat anyone to say what he did. And though people might say that their comments on Asma are justified because Asma is, undoubtedly, the weakest singer of the lot, the fact still remains that they are no Lata Mangeshkar to judge her singing. They aren’t even the judges to judge her. If they really feel that she does not deserve to be in the contest, they could have put their opinions across in a mature manner – like Yashita and Sara. It was completely unnecessary to take cheap potshots on other people like how Debojit did. He didn’t come across as a “special” child at all. And as someone pointed out on another site, if Debojit’s comments were really scripted by Zee TV, why would they let him refer to Laughter Challenge which airs on a rival channel? If he is really a “special” child, it is the responsibility of his parents to ensure that he does not do anything that might embarrass himself – which I do not think they have upheld at all.
I am disgusted with the levels of stupidity this show has reached.
every episode aik naee drama bazi asma ki hoti hai.agli episode mai kahe ge mere maa mar gaye mai.zee tv wali usse winner bana dange.aur aap sab bewakuf kahin ge buhat accha hua .she diserve to be winner.JAHIL SAB KE SUB .
Hi All,
Could you all visit youtube “SRGMP 1st Episodes Starts With A Fight” and listen to the comments of the host. She mentioned about ” show ko hit karaney key hathkandaun ki Jang” .
What happened on 24th, was one of the such dirty HATHKANDA. The management should be ashamed of putting this kind of dirty games. The participants were interviewed about Asma individually. It was not a conversation between the participants.And then wickedly, they put it on air to create a drama. “Show ko Hit Karaney Ka Hathkanda” as narrated by the host in above mentioned video clip.
They are also trying to portray it as a JANG between the two countries, which is wrong.
I think Zee TV should avoid such Hathkandas ,otherwise this beautiful contest will end in controversy.
Yes I agree with you as well. They are not kids. But the thing is why did Zee Tv created this Drama. This wasn’t participants private conversation. They were asked individually and probably they might have been guided what to say.
Please visit youtube “SRGMP 1st Episodes Starts With A Fight” and listen to the comments of the host. She mentioned about ” show ko hit karaney key hathkandaun ki Jang” .
What happened on 24th, was one of the such dirty HATHKANDA.
Like many others, I just dont feel good about the managements strategy about creating such dramas and also portraying as a war between the 2 countries. I am sick of it and hate it. I was enjoying the good music till now.But if this goes on, then Ill have to stop watching this programme
TO ZEE TV
You must have gone through the comments and realized the level of rage for creating this kind of controversy. I am a Pakistani and living in Dublin. I watch this programme with my beautiful Indian Friends. We watch this for entertainment, for music, nothing else.This is not a cricket match being palyed at Mohali or Lahore. This is a contest of music, which has no language, no religion, no boundaries. And you people are trying to generate hatred in music. Millions of viewers all over the world must have been disturbed what you people are trying to do. I was enthralled by the love and affection shown by Indians to Pakistani singers. The viewrs were commenting and judging the contestants on their SANGAT nothing else. This programme is providing a base for love and affection.
And now you people are trying to convert it into a contest based on boundaries.
I would request rather not to invite singers from other countries in future. I will still watch this programme and millions of viewers around the world as well. As we love music but we dont want to see another contest based on hatred and drama.
I hope you understand it
If the indian people vote fairly then last years sa re gama pa winner should be ammanat and u also know about that.Pakistani singers r gr8 they r singing in india and still serviving (apna gher ma to kuta(dog) bhi shair(loin) hota ha) our kisi ka gher ma ja ka pcharna ata ha pakistani singers ko.
aur ha yeh massage asma ke aupporter’s ke liya hain sab dikha do ki asma jeet sakti hain ya nahi aur in sabne kaha hain ki woh top 10 me aane layak nahi hain ab inhe bata do vote kar kar ke ki ki unhone bilkul sahi kaha ki asma top 10 ke layak hain hi nahi balki she will be winner of saregamapa in 2009. and this is my chhallenge to all participants
From a talent and competition level this show has indeed been a disgrace to all.But I was flabbergasted yesterday when for the “Aaj Kal Tere Mere” Song sung by Asma, the channel said the original singers were Rafi / Asha. A show at such a International level, atleast check your facts. Its a Rafi /Suman duet.
It’s a big insult to a great singer. I am writing to Zee response, they should atleast apolozise.
We can take your crap, but such faux-pauses are just too much. Get your act together please.
I hope you some of the music lovers on this forum agree and write to Zee.
I AGREE WITH YOU VIJAY SUCH CRAPS ARE HAPPENING AT SUCH A LEVEL WHICH IS SHAMEFUL AND DRAMA CREATED BY THE ZEE IS ALSO SHAMEFUL AND DISGUSTING AND SOME ARE BELIEVING HERE THESE ARE TRUE FEELINGS OF THE CONTESTANTS NOT THE CREATED ONE.
Iam in agreement with everybody that the attack on Asma was shameful,this could have been deleted,like they deleted Amanat Ali famous song Tugh see naraz,which was sung four times at audiences demand,but they deleted to hurt amanat.This year they are playing INDIA-PAKISTAN card.How can Indians vote For Pakistani’sknowing that it is a war between two countries.Ilive in USA,we subscribe to ZEE TV.nOW WE HAVE TO think twice if we should continue.Last year it was a beautiful show ,good singers,of a high caliber.Ismail merchant was eliminated because he stood up for Amanatand criticised ZEE’s selection process.
Are you stupid?
Don’t you know that the show has to run for a specified time? That’s the reasons Amant’s encore was edited!
Please do thinkk twice to continue! We indians don’t need ungrateful people like you. You can flourish in Pakistan.
Ismail merchant ????
You don’t even know the name and you are commenting?
Yashita/Pratibha/Sarah: All three of them crushed it!!! Way to go girls! I am sooo proud of you.
For those who never paid attention to Sarah:
Please listen to her songs once again. Please don’t underestimate her! She has improved a lot! Poor girl.. every week she goes to those bottom three ka chairs…with a smile in her face! I like her!
I think this time girls should be the toppers.
Regarding that Asma criticism part..I won’t blame the other contestants.They were being assertive about it!
I think it’s a partiality- Zee is giving maximum air time to Asma compared to others…!But I won’t blame Asma for that…it’s all zee’s startegy. Kudos to Asma for her confidence!
Regarding Pratibha: I agree with some of the bloggers here that she got the least air time…doesn’t give any extra twist..I agree that her negetive point is that wood face but she is a good singer. Remember what Ashaji said once “baharse nehi manmey nacho”-that’s what she does.
This week none of the male cntestants was up to the mark!!!
MAZRAT KAY SATH TUMHAIN TU AISEY MIRCHI LAG RAHI HAI JESEY SHUJAAT BHAI TUMHAREY JEEJAJEE HAIN AGAR WOH ITNA HE ACHA SINGER HAI TU BEHAN KE SHAADI KARWA DO US SE ADHI ADHI RAAT KO US PER ULTEY SEEDHEY COMMENTS KARTA RAHEY GA (HAHAHAHAHAHA) BY THE WAY I AM MUSLIM AND PAKISTANI AND I AM NOT ASHAMED TO SAY THAT SHUJAAT KHAN IS SUCH A BASTARD AND U TOO.
hi hi bechara jabirthefastest tarap utha .tum apni behan ki shadi us ke baap ke saath ker do .abhi abhi us ne bewi ko divorce di hai .aur tum asma ki look after bhi ker lana.tumhari lauguage bohat jahilana hai.mujhay lagta hai tum hindu hoo.jalan nazar a rahi hai.tum galiyu ke siwa kuch nahi ker saktay donkey monkeyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy
DONKEY MONKEYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
ASMA KA ASHIQ NAHIM AB TU US KA MAMO HAI
HAHAHAHAHAHAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
This show is a ridiculous Joke. I’ve stopped watching since Shashi’s elimination. Mrs informed me about the shenanigans. Indian Idol’s standards are so much higher.
Judges give proper feedback. The back stabbing selfish contenstants here have made a big cock up by having a go at Asma it will def back fire. Honey Bear cum Gorrilla to go next!!!!
At first I got all excited that Amanat finally had his OWN song, but after I heared it I was very disappointed!! I mean come on, his voice is way to good to use for JUST that 1 line or so.
Lets hope that his full fledged song will come our way very soon!!
Wow, what a brilliant show Zee TV put together this weekend. Congratulations to their creative team! If I had to summarize the success of the show in one word, I would say: Asma. Her mere presence lights up the stage like nobody’s business.
This weekend’s shows had all the hallmarks of a blockbuster.
DESIGNS FOR GLOBAL DOMINANCE
It was an excellent theme – India vs Pakistan vs Oman. Oman came out victorious which makes me proud as a hard-core Indian. Despite what some bloggers may surmise, we Indians are proud to see an underdog fight back and win. Alas, this year Pakistan lacks in the talent department. Their best soldier, Zaheer, sounds like an ancient Roman town crier.
REVENGE OF THE PRINCESS OF OMAN:
Shujat said nasty things about the dignified, poised princess Asma. So did Zaheer, Yashita, Soumen, Tarun, Debojit, etc. She forgave Debojit because of his childlike innocence – and his powerhouse talent – and also because he openly professed his love for Asma! Others were all mean to Asma so she has a surprise planned for them next week. Sorry, you have to wait and find out.
INDIANS RULE
Though Oman stole the show, the real winner was India because Indians always vote for the best singer irrespective of country of origin. Last year, they voted for Aneek who was clearly better than Amanat and Raja (Amanat’s recently released song bombed though Shankar-Ehsan-Loy gave it their best shot). This year, it may be Soumen or Debojit, both from Bengal, who can easily learn better Hindi/Urdu pronunciation, and beat the competition. But Indians are in love with Rock Kanya Asma who will carry the flag of Indian music to all corners of the world. Sarah and Pratibha (is she looking hotter every week? Asma is helping her) are improving. Yashita should sign up with Hollywood or Broadway – she sounds far too Western. The dark horse in all this? Debojit, the child Romeo.
PAKISTAN IS TRYING
Pakistan is certainly a worthy opponent. In my opinion, to win SRGMP, they need to send a handsome, modern singer, not an ugly classical singer (like someone from the band called Fuzon). Also more women will enhance Pakistan’s image and the odds for winning.
SEE YOU ON THE MOON
Kudos to ISRO, We are the 6th nation to plant a flag on the moon. This will help us expand our musical range. Ismail Durbar’s “Chaand Chhupa Badal Mein” is directly lifted from a French song but now he can claim he was inspired by his first-hand knowledge of the lunar surface (I mean we should put him on the spacecraft and dispatch him).
FINAL WORD
A new (or renewed) wave of nasal singing is going to pervade and prevail on the musical landscape over the next decade. Leading the charge: Rock Kanya Asma who will champion the cause of poor kids through her singing.
It’s disappointing to see how conformist most folks here are! Though many of you complain about te judges, the reality is most of you cannot see past Yashita and Zaheer. And the reason is obvious – it’s because the judges have praised them the most. And all of you, despite pretensions to the contrary, are like a herd of goats following the shepherding judges.
Please, develop your own sense of music, make your own decisions, vote for the truly deserving – don’t just follow the judges blindly.
Close your eyes. Listen to the songs. Then ask, mirror, mirror, who is the most beautifully nasal of them all?
The Rock Kanya Asma. The path-breaking princess -singing, dancing and spreading joy to the world!
A very disappointing show. I had a house full of family and friends with tears i their eyes for Asma. I was totally shocked as well. Not fair to hit on Asma the way all her fellow contestants have done. Asma comes from an Arabic back ground, she obviously enjoys singing, which is what she is doing, she has learnt to speak and sing the Hindi language as well, she is trying, give her the benefit.
Asma did not pour out to the viewers her recent personal encounters, she had just mentioned that her parents have divorced due to her wanting to sing. Fat Debojit is not a “special child”, if he is, he should be playing with stones at home and not singing. She knows very well what he says, and that silly stomach act of his, makes him look retarded.
As for the Jack Sh*t Shujat, one things good is that he god out. He does not sing well at all and he had absolutely no right to comment on Asma’s parents divorce. He deserves to go out….IDIOT….
Go back to the recordings for this episode, none of the contestants have sung well. They have their good and their bad days. All we see is that if they perform poorly, the excuses start pouring in, like I’m not feeling well or someone called in and said that I should have sung in praise of ALLAH, what nonsence.
Sara and Yashita, I would think that they are traitors towards Asma to have said such hurtful things about her. Asma has always been true friends to them and she has supported them as well.
Tarun hasn’t been doing to well himself, he’s been quite useless recently.
What about Vaishali, she’s working on the pity of her husband. She’s actually worse off than Asma, she should be sitting at home taking care of her husband, instead of passing silly comments to others.
I short, this Zee was totally unprofessional to broadcast these comments, and therefore have become a BIG JOKE to world out here. I have lost my respect for the heartless contestants for their comments, and I think that having a stone heart is better than having the hearts that these contestants have. It portrays they upbringing and the dirt they habour in their hearts.
I completely agree with you that Asma is an inspiration to all young people who have dreams; she shows us how to go about achieving our dreams with tenacity and a smile. We Indians love Asma; I vote for her thousands of times every week. In Hindu we call her the Rock Kanya!
How’s everything going in RSA (I guess it is Royal Saudi Arabia?). In my hometown NYC, mayor Bloomberg got the laws changed so he can run for a third term.
However, there are some points you make on which I am not with you 100%.
I think Zee did us a service by airing the nasty comments and exposing the two-faced hypocrites. It was a touching show as evidenced by your family members all crying. That’s what we want on TV.
Debojit is just a child Romeo. He is not fully aware of himself. He actually loves Asma (and all the other babes).
The rest of them were just mean and jealous.
Asma is the future of Bollywood music. She is going to win the SRGMP crown and rule Bollywood. Her movie about the camel-and-stick is going to be a hit, and will be remade in India by Himesh (with Himesh in the role of the camel’s caretaker).
What is this nonsens please stop this bloody drama all singers are gentle and kind they can not play this bloody dram……….. this is from ZEE onl…………..and stop this India Pakistan war…….PLEASE
i’m no speaking hindi and malay race but love to watch hindi movie sometime.first time see Asma yesterday in Astro zee. she is a germ and will be a hit…..
I completely agree with you that Asma is an inspiration to all young people who have dreams; she shows us how to go about achieving our dreams with tenacity and a smile. We Indians love Asma; I vote for her thousands of times every week. In Hindu we call her the Rock Kanya!
How’s everything going in RSA (I guess it is Royal Saudi Arabia?). In my hometown NYC, mayor Bloomberg got the laws changed so he can run for a third term.
However, there are some points you make on which I am not with you 100%.
I think Zee did us a service by airing the nasty comments and exposing the two-faced hypocrites. It was a touching show as evidenced by your family members all crying. That’s what we want on TV.
Debojit is just a child Romeo. He is not fully aware of himself. He actually loves Asma (and all the other babes).
The rest of them were just mean and jealous.
Asma is the future of Bollywood music. She is going to win the SRGMP crown and rule Bollywood. Her movie about the camel-and-stick is going to be a hit, and will be remade in India by Himesh (with Himesh in the role of the camel’s caretaker).
A very disappointing show. I had a house full of family and friends with tears i their eyes for Asma. I was totally shocked as well. Not fair to hit on Asma the way all her fellow contestants have done. Asma comes from an Arabic back ground, she obviously enjoys singing, which is what she is doing, she has learnt to speak and sing the Hindi language as well, she is trying, give her the benefit.
Asma did not pour out to the viewers her recent personal encounters, she had just mentioned that her parents have divorced due to her wanting to sing. Fat Debojit is not a “special child”, if he is, he should be playing with stones at home and not singing. She knows very well what he says, and that silly stomach act of his, makes him look retarded.
As for the Jack Sh*t Shujat, one things good is that he god out. He does not sing well at all and he had absolutely no right to comment on Asma’s parents divorce. He deserves to go out….IDIOT….
Go back to the recordings for this episode, none of the contestants have sung well. They have their good and their bad days. All we see is that if they perform poorly, the excuses start pouring in, like I’m not feeling well or someone called in and said that I should have sung in praise of ALLAH, what nonsence.
Sara and Yashita, I would think that they are traitors towards Asma to have said such hurtful things about her. Asma has always been true friends to them and she has supported them as well.
Tarun hasn’t been doing to well himself, he’s been quite useless recently.
What about Vaishali, she’s working on the pity of her husband. She’s actually worse off than Asma, she should be sitting at home taking care of her husband, instead of passing silly comments to others.
I short, this Zee was totally unprofessional to broadcast these comments, and therefore have become a BIG JOKE to world out here. I have lost my respect for the heartless contestants for their comments, and I think that having a stone heart is better than having the hearts that these contestants have. It portrays they upbringing and the dirt they habour in their hearts.
Mara bhai yeh sab zee ka drama han zaheer have to do what zee will say
main lahore pakistan se taluq rakhti hoon ilove zee saregamapa mujeh asma m rafi ki awaz buhat achi lagati hai
The Winner of Saregamapa2009 Is …
Asma Mohammad Rafi 100% Conform.
Hi2
I totally agree with. Everyone has its own respect.. and whatever happened was really an upsetting event !
We all know Asma cant sing but that does not give us any right to offend her in Public on tv and millions watching !
TO ZEETV !
C’mon piece of sh*ts…. if you guys didnt want this to happen … that poor little girl would have been happy even though is she got eliminated…. !!! But NOO!! money must roll-in and to hell with anyone’s respect !
I am a Pakistani and i personally feel bad when Asma’s uncle got on stage and made those comments… !
you’re so fulloshi*t….
This is waht Zee is trying to do
Out of all the negative comments on Asma, I was most disgusted by Debojit and Shujat’s comments! They have revealed their low, cheap character. Shame on them!
I agree
I have no comments about Debojit’s comments on Asma because he is a “special child” and sometimes he doesn’t even know how he acts…for example the way he says “Arz hai” with that piculiar posture before starting his shayeries..proves that poor chap doesn’t realize what he is doing.
So I actually sympathize with him for his behavior!!!
Just my 2 cents about Debojit. Yashita is rthe best anyways!!
that’s true.and the sad part is that they make debojit say it over and over( the arz kiya hai part),but they are actually making fun of him.it’s very unfair.i am sure pratibha will go off soon too.she is a great singer,but she doesnt do any drama ,no extra smart talks,no nonsense and i had the utmost respect for her cos she didnt comment about asma.she was the only one who didnt.this show is no longer about talent but just about popularity based on drama.it is sad for all the talented kids.i am so upset that shashi,manisha and kaushik are out
JABIRTHEFASTEST hi kaminay batoon say pata chalta hai shakal buhat burri ho gi app ki.asma ke bare mai jo kaha theek tha .besure ko besura nahi to aur kya kahin ge.us ki waja se shujat itna acha surila contestant bahir ho gaya.chlo asma to abhi compitition mai hai.zaleel jahil islami muashare ko kiyu bura bhala kahte ho.mujhay to tum asma ke baap lagte ho badi takleef mai bachare konse izzat ki bat karte ho kya kih diya hai ke tum galiya de rahe ho..aur itni besharmi say kaha mare papa ni mama ko divorce dadi. tum gana chhor datin aur maa ko manati BAP business mind hoga pata tha mere beti buhat agay jaye ge itni khubsurat hai paisa kamae gi.is liye biwe chhor di.naina faraz kaushik shujat fantastic singer the sab nakal gae is ki waja se.aur zaheer ni tu kuch kaha bhi nahin.tarun ne jo kaha zee tv walon ne kaha hoga to kaha.debojit buhat accha hamesha sach bolta hai.ye sab kuch zee ne asma ko hamdardiya dilane ki liye kiya .look sab log ban gaye na us ki hamdard.yahi to zee chahta hai.
.
Stop this nonsense
asma got comments on her personal life because she opened her personal life on stage……… and i wonder if a person can sacrifice her mother for just singing on that stage
and the outburst of other contestant is fair ……. asma gets history even for mediocre performance just on the base that she is improving but it is a competition and the judgement should be on a comparison basis and not individual growth
asma is nowhere close to the eliminated singers like naina , kaushik, mitika n shujat……….. and i think esp aadeshji is too biased abt her….
I absolutely agree with you David
I’m not a fan of Asma, but here is what I have to say:
Even though Asma may have revealed her personal life on stage, that does not give the contestants any right to comment on it! Neither is Shujat anyone to say what he did. And though people might say that their comments on Asma are justified because Asma is, undoubtedly, the weakest singer of the lot, the fact still remains that they are no Lata Mangeshkar to judge her singing. They aren’t even the judges to judge her. If they really feel that she does not deserve to be in the contest, they could have put their opinions across in a mature manner – like Yashita and Sara. It was completely unnecessary to take cheap potshots on other people like how Debojit did. He didn’t come across as a “special” child at all. And as someone pointed out on another site, if Debojit’s comments were really scripted by Zee TV, why would they let him refer to Laughter Challenge which airs on a rival channel? If he is really a “special” child, it is the responsibility of his parents to ensure that he does not do anything that might embarrass himself – which I do not think they have upheld at all.
I am disgusted with the levels of stupidity this show has reached.
every episode aik naee drama bazi asma ki hoti hai.agli episode mai kahe ge mere maa mar gaye mai.zee tv wali usse winner bana dange.aur aap sab bewakuf kahin ge buhat accha hua .she diserve to be winner.JAHIL SAB KE SUB .
dont remove asma, she is improving and doing good
Why is aditya wearing blue trouser with yellow shirt. Looking joker
cos it was a 1960′s disco look!!!
aaj kal tere mere pyar is sung by md rafi and suman kalyanpur, not asha bhosale.
Hi All,
Could you all visit youtube “SRGMP 1st Episodes Starts With A Fight” and listen to the comments of the host. She mentioned about ” show ko hit karaney key hathkandaun ki Jang” .
What happened on 24th, was one of the such dirty HATHKANDA. The management should be ashamed of putting this kind of dirty games. The participants were interviewed about Asma individually. It was not a conversation between the participants.And then wickedly, they put it on air to create a drama. “Show ko Hit Karaney Ka Hathkanda” as narrated by the host in above mentioned video clip.
They are also trying to portray it as a JANG between the two countries, which is wrong.
I think Zee TV should avoid such Hathkandas ,otherwise this beautiful contest will end in controversy.
Yes I agree with you as well. They are not kids. But the thing is why did Zee Tv created this Drama. This wasn’t participants private conversation. They were asked individually and probably they might have been guided what to say.
Please visit youtube “SRGMP 1st Episodes Starts With A Fight” and listen to the comments of the host. She mentioned about ” show ko hit karaney key hathkandaun ki Jang” .
What happened on 24th, was one of the such dirty HATHKANDA.
Like many others, I just dont feel good about the managements strategy about creating such dramas and also portraying as a war between the 2 countries. I am sick of it and hate it. I was enjoying the good music till now.But if this goes on, then Ill have to stop watching this programme
TO ZEE TV
You must have gone through the comments and realized the level of rage for creating this kind of controversy. I am a Pakistani and living in Dublin. I watch this programme with my beautiful Indian Friends. We watch this for entertainment, for music, nothing else.This is not a cricket match being palyed at Mohali or Lahore. This is a contest of music, which has no language, no religion, no boundaries. And you people are trying to generate hatred in music. Millions of viewers all over the world must have been disturbed what you people are trying to do. I was enthralled by the love and affection shown by Indians to Pakistani singers. The viewrs were commenting and judging the contestants on their SANGAT nothing else. This programme is providing a base for love and affection.
And now you people are trying to convert it into a contest based on boundaries.
I would request rather not to invite singers from other countries in future. I will still watch this programme and millions of viewers around the world as well. As we love music but we dont want to see another contest based on hatred and drama.
I hope you understand it
If the indian people vote fairly then last years sa re gama pa winner should be ammanat and u also know about that.Pakistani singers r gr8 they r singing in india and still serviving (apna gher ma to kuta(dog) bhi shair(loin) hota ha) our kisi ka gher ma ja ka pcharna ata ha pakistani singers ko.
tum apne gane par dhyan do
oman zindabad asma zindabad
aur ha yeh massage asma ke aupporter’s ke liya hain sab dikha do ki asma jeet sakti hain ya nahi aur in sabne kaha hain ki woh top 10 me aane layak nahi hain ab inhe bata do vote kar kar ke ki ki unhone bilkul sahi kaha ki asma top 10 ke layak hain hi nahi balki she will be winner of saregamapa in 2009. and this is my chhallenge to all participants
@All Music lovers.
From a talent and competition level this show has indeed been a disgrace to all.But I was flabbergasted yesterday when for the “Aaj Kal Tere Mere” Song sung by Asma, the channel said the original singers were Rafi / Asha. A show at such a International level, atleast check your facts. Its a Rafi /Suman duet.
It’s a big insult to a great singer. I am writing to Zee response, they should atleast apolozise.
We can take your crap, but such faux-pauses are just too much. Get your act together please.
I hope you some of the music lovers on this forum agree and write to Zee.
I AGREE WITH YOU VIJAY SUCH CRAPS ARE HAPPENING AT SUCH A LEVEL WHICH IS SHAMEFUL AND DRAMA CREATED BY THE ZEE IS ALSO SHAMEFUL AND DISGUSTING AND SOME ARE BELIEVING HERE THESE ARE TRUE FEELINGS OF THE CONTESTANTS NOT THE CREATED ONE.
@Vijay,
Agree with you! They are making money so who cares about the facts! Suman Kalyanpur ko jane do bhaad mein….!ASMA is the History maker!!
Next week…Asma IS going to be in top three just watch….all these nautankies are only to hype Asma.
Looks like Pratibha is going to be out next week.I will feel like killing Zee if that really happens…..!Sigh!
Pratibha is the only one who hardly got any media focus!!Looks like zee is planning to eliminate her very soon…!
Iam in agreement with everybody that the attack on Asma was shameful,this could have been deleted,like they deleted Amanat Ali famous song Tugh see naraz,which was sung four times at audiences demand,but they deleted to hurt amanat.This year they are playing INDIA-PAKISTAN card.How can Indians vote For Pakistani’sknowing that it is a war between two countries.Ilive in USA,we subscribe to ZEE TV.nOW WE HAVE TO think twice if we should continue.Last year it was a beautiful show ,good singers,of a high caliber.Ismail merchant was eliminated because he stood up for Amanatand criticised ZEE’s selection process.
Are you stupid?
Don’t you know that the show has to run for a specified time? That’s the reasons Amant’s encore was edited!
Please do thinkk twice to continue! We indians don’t need ungrateful people like you. You can flourish in Pakistan.
Ismail merchant ????
You don’t even know the name and you are commenting?
very well said karim i personally agree with you …..Indians and their politics….
Yashita/Pratibha/Sarah: All three of them crushed it!!! Way to go girls! I am sooo proud of you.
For those who never paid attention to Sarah:
Please listen to her songs once again. Please don’t underestimate her! She has improved a lot! Poor girl.. every week she goes to those bottom three ka chairs…with a smile in her face! I like her!
I think this time girls should be the toppers.
Regarding that Asma criticism part..I won’t blame the other contestants.They were being assertive about it!
I think it’s a partiality- Zee is giving maximum air time to Asma compared to others…!But I won’t blame Asma for that…it’s all zee’s startegy. Kudos to Asma for her confidence!
Regarding Pratibha: I agree with some of the bloggers here that she got the least air time…doesn’t give any extra twist..I agree that her negetive point is that wood face but she is a good singer. Remember what Ashaji said once “baharse nehi manmey nacho”-that’s what she does.
This week none of the male cntestants was up to the mark!!!
Yashit is the best so far!
MAZRAT KAY SATH TUMHAIN TU AISEY MIRCHI LAG RAHI HAI JESEY SHUJAAT BHAI TUMHAREY JEEJAJEE HAIN AGAR WOH ITNA HE ACHA SINGER HAI TU BEHAN KE SHAADI KARWA DO US SE ADHI ADHI RAAT KO US PER ULTEY SEEDHEY COMMENTS KARTA RAHEY GA (HAHAHAHAHAHA) BY THE WAY I AM MUSLIM AND PAKISTANI AND I AM NOT ASHAMED TO SAY THAT SHUJAAT KHAN IS SUCH A BASTARD AND U TOO.
hi hi bechara jabirthefastest tarap utha .tum apni behan ki shadi us ke baap ke saath ker do .abhi abhi us ne bewi ko divorce di hai .aur tum asma ki look after bhi ker lana.tumhari lauguage bohat jahilana hai.mujhay lagta hai tum hindu hoo.jalan nazar a rahi hai.tum galiyu ke siwa kuch nahi ker saktay donkey monkeyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy
DONKEY MONKEYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
ASMA KA ASHIQ NAHIM AB TU US KA MAMO HAI
HAHAHAHAHAHAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
This show is a ridiculous Joke. I’ve stopped watching since Shashi’s elimination. Mrs informed me about the shenanigans. Indian Idol’s standards are so much higher.
Judges give proper feedback. The back stabbing selfish contenstants here have made a big cock up by having a go at Asma it will def back fire. Honey Bear cum Gorrilla to go next!!!!
At first I got all excited that Amanat finally had his OWN song, but after I heared it I was very disappointed!! I mean come on, his voice is way to good to use for JUST that 1 line or so.
Lets hope that his full fledged song will come our way very soon!!
God bless x
Wow, what a brilliant show Zee TV put together this weekend. Congratulations to their creative team! If I had to summarize the success of the show in one word, I would say: Asma. Her mere presence lights up the stage like nobody’s business.
This weekend’s shows had all the hallmarks of a blockbuster.
DESIGNS FOR GLOBAL DOMINANCE
It was an excellent theme – India vs Pakistan vs Oman. Oman came out victorious which makes me proud as a hard-core Indian. Despite what some bloggers may surmise, we Indians are proud to see an underdog fight back and win. Alas, this year Pakistan lacks in the talent department. Their best soldier, Zaheer, sounds like an ancient Roman town crier.
REVENGE OF THE PRINCESS OF OMAN:
Shujat said nasty things about the dignified, poised princess Asma. So did Zaheer, Yashita, Soumen, Tarun, Debojit, etc. She forgave Debojit because of his childlike innocence – and his powerhouse talent – and also because he openly professed his love for Asma! Others were all mean to Asma so she has a surprise planned for them next week. Sorry, you have to wait and find out.
INDIANS RULE
Though Oman stole the show, the real winner was India because Indians always vote for the best singer irrespective of country of origin. Last year, they voted for Aneek who was clearly better than Amanat and Raja (Amanat’s recently released song bombed though Shankar-Ehsan-Loy gave it their best shot). This year, it may be Soumen or Debojit, both from Bengal, who can easily learn better Hindi/Urdu pronunciation, and beat the competition. But Indians are in love with Rock Kanya Asma who will carry the flag of Indian music to all corners of the world. Sarah and Pratibha (is she looking hotter every week? Asma is helping her) are improving. Yashita should sign up with Hollywood or Broadway – she sounds far too Western. The dark horse in all this? Debojit, the child Romeo.
PAKISTAN IS TRYING
Pakistan is certainly a worthy opponent. In my opinion, to win SRGMP, they need to send a handsome, modern singer, not an ugly classical singer (like someone from the band called Fuzon). Also more women will enhance Pakistan’s image and the odds for winning.
SEE YOU ON THE MOON
Kudos to ISRO, We are the 6th nation to plant a flag on the moon. This will help us expand our musical range. Ismail Durbar’s “Chaand Chhupa Badal Mein” is directly lifted from a French song but now he can claim he was inspired by his first-hand knowledge of the lunar surface (I mean we should put him on the spacecraft and dispatch him).
FINAL WORD
A new (or renewed) wave of nasal singing is going to pervade and prevail on the musical landscape over the next decade. Leading the charge: Rock Kanya Asma who will champion the cause of poor kids through her singing.
It’s disappointing to see how conformist most folks here are! Though many of you complain about te judges, the reality is most of you cannot see past Yashita and Zaheer. And the reason is obvious – it’s because the judges have praised them the most. And all of you, despite pretensions to the contrary, are like a herd of goats following the shepherding judges.
Please, develop your own sense of music, make your own decisions, vote for the truly deserving – don’t just follow the judges blindly.
Close your eyes. Listen to the songs. Then ask, mirror, mirror, who is the most beautifully nasal of them all?
The Rock Kanya Asma. The path-breaking princess -singing, dancing and spreading joy to the world!
A very disappointing show. I had a house full of family and friends with tears i their eyes for Asma. I was totally shocked as well. Not fair to hit on Asma the way all her fellow contestants have done. Asma comes from an Arabic back ground, she obviously enjoys singing, which is what she is doing, she has learnt to speak and sing the Hindi language as well, she is trying, give her the benefit.
Asma did not pour out to the viewers her recent personal encounters, she had just mentioned that her parents have divorced due to her wanting to sing. Fat Debojit is not a “special child”, if he is, he should be playing with stones at home and not singing. She knows very well what he says, and that silly stomach act of his, makes him look retarded.
As for the Jack Sh*t Shujat, one things good is that he god out. He does not sing well at all and he had absolutely no right to comment on Asma’s parents divorce. He deserves to go out….IDIOT….
Go back to the recordings for this episode, none of the contestants have sung well. They have their good and their bad days. All we see is that if they perform poorly, the excuses start pouring in, like I’m not feeling well or someone called in and said that I should have sung in praise of ALLAH, what nonsence.
Sara and Yashita, I would think that they are traitors towards Asma to have said such hurtful things about her. Asma has always been true friends to them and she has supported them as well.
Tarun hasn’t been doing to well himself, he’s been quite useless recently.
What about Vaishali, she’s working on the pity of her husband. She’s actually worse off than Asma, she should be sitting at home taking care of her husband, instead of passing silly comments to others.
I short, this Zee was totally unprofessional to broadcast these comments, and therefore have become a BIG JOKE to world out here. I have lost my respect for the heartless contestants for their comments, and I think that having a stone heart is better than having the hearts that these contestants have. It portrays they upbringing and the dirt they habour in their hearts.
They suck…..
You Go Asma…you’re still the apple of most eyes….
@Fayeez RSA
I completely agree with you that Asma is an inspiration to all young people who have dreams; she shows us how to go about achieving our dreams with tenacity and a smile. We Indians love Asma; I vote for her thousands of times every week. In Hindu we call her the Rock Kanya!
How’s everything going in RSA (I guess it is Royal Saudi Arabia?). In my hometown NYC, mayor Bloomberg got the laws changed so he can run for a third term.
However, there are some points you make on which I am not with you 100%.
I think Zee did us a service by airing the nasty comments and exposing the two-faced hypocrites. It was a touching show as evidenced by your family members all crying. That’s what we want on TV.
Debojit is just a child Romeo. He is not fully aware of himself. He actually loves Asma (and all the other babes).
The rest of them were just mean and jealous.
Asma is the future of Bollywood music. She is going to win the SRGMP crown and rule Bollywood. Her movie about the camel-and-stick is going to be a hit, and will be remade in India by Himesh (with Himesh in the role of the camel’s caretaker).
Jai Hind. Jai RSA.
with all due respect to all the singers, no one can replace Amanat Ali!
Yeah!
Aneek and Harpreet are far better!
What is this nonsens please stop this bloody drama all singers are gentle and kind they can not play this bloody dram……….. this is from ZEE onl…………..and stop this India Pakistan war…….PLEASE
i’m no speaking hindi and malay race but love to watch hindi movie sometime.first time see Asma yesterday in Astro zee. she is a germ and will be a hit…..
I completely agree with you that Asma is an inspiration to all young people who have dreams; she shows us how to go about achieving our dreams with tenacity and a smile. We Indians love Asma; I vote for her thousands of times every week. In Hindu we call her the Rock Kanya!
How’s everything going in RSA (I guess it is Royal Saudi Arabia?). In my hometown NYC, mayor Bloomberg got the laws changed so he can run for a third term.
However, there are some points you make on which I am not with you 100%.
I think Zee did us a service by airing the nasty comments and exposing the two-faced hypocrites. It was a touching show as evidenced by your family members all crying. That’s what we want on TV.
Debojit is just a child Romeo. He is not fully aware of himself. He actually loves Asma (and all the other babes).
The rest of them were just mean and jealous.
Asma is the future of Bollywood music. She is going to win the SRGMP crown and rule Bollywood. Her movie about the camel-and-stick is going to be a hit, and will be remade in India by Himesh (with Himesh in the role of the camel’s caretaker).
Jai Hind. Jai RSA.
A very disappointing show. I had a house full of family and friends with tears i their eyes for Asma. I was totally shocked as well. Not fair to hit on Asma the way all her fellow contestants have done. Asma comes from an Arabic back ground, she obviously enjoys singing, which is what she is doing, she has learnt to speak and sing the Hindi language as well, she is trying, give her the benefit.
Asma did not pour out to the viewers her recent personal encounters, she had just mentioned that her parents have divorced due to her wanting to sing. Fat Debojit is not a “special child”, if he is, he should be playing with stones at home and not singing. She knows very well what he says, and that silly stomach act of his, makes him look retarded.
As for the Jack Sh*t Shujat, one things good is that he god out. He does not sing well at all and he had absolutely no right to comment on Asma’s parents divorce. He deserves to go out….IDIOT….
Go back to the recordings for this episode, none of the contestants have sung well. They have their good and their bad days. All we see is that if they perform poorly, the excuses start pouring in, like I’m not feeling well or someone called in and said that I should have sung in praise of ALLAH, what nonsence.
Sara and Yashita, I would think that they are traitors towards Asma to have said such hurtful things about her. Asma has always been true friends to them and she has supported them as well.
Tarun hasn’t been doing to well himself, he’s been quite useless recently.
What about Vaishali, she’s working on the pity of her husband. She’s actually worse off than Asma, she should be sitting at home taking care of her husband, instead of passing silly comments to others.
I short, this Zee was totally unprofessional to broadcast these comments, and therefore have become a BIG JOKE to world out here. I have lost my respect for the heartless contestants for their comments, and I think that having a stone heart is better than having the hearts that these contestants have. It portrays they upbringing and the dirt they habour in their hearts.
They suck…..
You Go Asma…you’re still the apple of most eyes….
[Reply]
jo kal asma kay saath hua bahut bura laga,i like asma very much baki sab bakwaas hain