Dear mehfil
Debojit is not ‘normal’ in the sense we use it. He is suffering from some disoder- either parkinson’d diease or some other disorder where the body grows but the mind remains childlike. So I think he is definitely not a regular cae. a psychologist frined of mine also watches this programme, and she confirmed it.
as fro VOI, if they present a sympahy case can saregama be far behind? You know what happens in this battle of TRPS. Both these shows are at loggerheards with each other in terms of TRPS.
dear raghu,
I agree with you. I know debojit will be in top 5. bengalis are too powerful in zee. But instead of debojit couldn’t they havce hsoen sayon/ mansiha? Both these young singers ha dthe spark and talent.
My top 5 will be pratibha, shahsi sumna, naina, mitika and debojit(not becaseu I want debo to bethere, i would prefer arhad but I don’t think arshad will be back)
Please take that mind (bengalies etc) abt Debojit. He may be having some weaknesses like versatality, Pronounciation etc..but he brings Josh to the song.Sayan can not sing Joshila songs..He may be good for soft songs..Manisha’s performance has weaknesses..No consistancy in her singing also lack of confidence too..
But Debojit is better than these..I do not think he will make it to the top.but..He deserves this position..
@Sheila
You see … both prathiba and debojit were partners in duet song and both were applauded … so the judges HAD TO critisize Debojit in his solo performance in order to give prathiba the ‘chakra’ … little bit of off-stage politics and planning … just my opinion .. i might be wrong …
In todays performance (IMO) 3 poeple deserved the chakra
1. Debojit himself
2. Prathiba
3. Yashita
According to ‘gharana politics’ Yashita already had the chakra, so she is out … debojit had it for one week, so the judges wanted to give it to prathiba and the only way they can do that is by promoting prathiba and downplaying debojit … Every judge probably want the chakra in his gharana at least once …
I really dont think Debojit NEEDS any sympathy votes … the guy can make it to the top on his own talent! … It was the ‘Bahu’ Anupuma who was playing the sassu-maa-and-child-at-home card … quite pathetic if you ask me …
It was a nice epiode. But another format change…! Really everything is very disorganized on this show. Did they dcide thisbeacuse thye realized current top 12 is not the best top 12?
If shashi returns thorugh bramhastra, zee will probaly bring him to top 5 but not allow him to win. winner is debojit/sunvinder. mark my words
and if its a female winner it has to be pratibha/naina/mitika. These 3 girls rock
yes rhea,shashi and sunvinder should come back.they are good and i hope when they come back they choose the songs that suit their voices.this show is like a war pattern,one mistake and you could be the one eliminated.i hope they learned their lessons and when back will rock the stage
If you want shashi back please manil zee at response@zeenetwork.com. The more mails they gte, they will realzie shahsi is going to earn them votes and get him back
Yshita’s weakness and debojit’s weakness is that they cannot sing in a polsihed way. i am not a music expert but if I compare them to shahsi and pratibha and naian I do see the diff. i may be misatken but plz could someone help me here?
@Sheila,
Just a clarification……’parkinsons is a neurodegenerative disorder that affects certain areas of the brain that control motor skills and speech. The very fact that Debojit sings so well…..he does not suffer from parkinson’s disease.
I may be wrong abou the name but the FACT is he is suffering froma disroder where the body grows but the mind doesn’t…one can make thi sout from his body language and way of talking.
That doesn’t take away from his singing…but I don’t want him to win becaue he is not a worthy successor of debojit and aneek. though debojit sahha has improved drasticallyof late, his win was not deserved. Aneek was excellent though. and the little benagli girl anwesha in chote ustaad was OUTSTADING but didn’t iwn. so I don’t agree about the bengali lobby theory…
sometimes bengalis are voted out even when theyd eserved to win. Eg Monali thakur in indian idol 2, anwesha in chote ustaad, amit pual in indian idol 3
Please Please ..
let us not talk about the disorder ,Bengali etc..about Debojit..
Please think about Michael Phelps(9 olympic gold medal winner) he has ADHD (Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder )..
what he created..
So let us not under estimate any one disorder etc..
raghu you are so right,look at the fighting spirit and not the weaknesses of the boy.and as far as i heard his mom told in the show that if he is not normal,he is not abnormal either,so lets leave it.he is a very good and powerful voice full of energy and thrill.enjoy his determination and will power.the way he sung james song in his first performance,my favourite one,na jane koi,i started adoring him.he wins or not doesnt matter,he is a good addition to the indian music stage.in my opinion this year a girl should win,unless they do blunders.
He is only ‘Simple’ ..he is not suffering from any disease.. and i couldnt stop laughing when people say he has Parkinsons..LOL..I should salute the psychiatrist who has diagnosed him just watching him on the TV…:-)
yeah agree shashi, i too am amused on that tv diagnosis that too of parkinsonism.i couldnt help myself laughing thinking most of the singers dance or do certain movements.so are they all suffering from…..?anyway he is a good singer,deboujit.and i like his voice
Don’t mind if i say something observing and watching the show live when his mother said it openly in the show that Debojit is not a normal person but has passion for music Either i’m wrong listening or his mother is wrong to say that. He did perform Na jane koi remarkably well but his weakness was obvious in this episode. His other performances were remarkable and must be appreciated. He is humble and meak person and good at heart. thanks.
Good stack ranking by AgentX. Sahi hai.. I would rank them the same.. except that the “feel” in a song is a majjjjjjor factor for me to like a performance. Ya, I m a kaansen too
My kaan protests in two cases.. one if the pronunciation kicks, the other if the voice lacks emotions.
So I would award extra brownie points to Yashita just for bringing the “feel” into her songs. I never noticed her that much before.. but she sure is stepping up.
Yashita’s solo was a catchy marathi (I think) song. I dont know this song, and I have no clue what she was singing about.. but her body language and her expressions adding to her good singing said a lot about the song and obviously she was enjoying it. I liked her the best today.
Debojit stands out coz he adds the “feel” into his performances as well. Kabhi kabhie kuch over enthu ho jaata hai and then his sur takes a break, but if you noticed in the Debu-Pratibha duet, Debu ek dumm doobke gaa raha tha..”jai jai shiv shankar” and Pratibha was looking very detached and casual. I didnt like her as much in that round as in her solo.. which was very very good. Hmm.. maybe I gotta kooky kaan.
If I give a brownie point to Debojit for the “feel”, I would take it away for his lisp. Clarity of words is important for me as well.
Shujjat slips down in my ranking jus coz of this reason too.. He steps down on emotions and sometimes, I find his classical twists actually hindering an otherwise good controlled performance. Today, in his solo song, his “aa” came out as “ae”.
Feel weel chhodke, sirf sur taal etc dekho to .. Pratibha, Shujjat and Yashita were good today.
Last, but o certainly not the least.. apna Adi putr needs a complete charitra parivartan ..a.k.a character makeover.
He needs a better lipi, mucho better kesh .. err hair-stylist, MUCHO better vastra-designer, go easy on the ati-shuddh hindi (he sounds like Doordarshan gone wild!) and needs to just be natural and comfy on stage. Otherwise, we need a shabdkosh on the sidebar.
Debojit does not have Parkinsons…. he is just too simple for this world !
Its amazing how someone can be “simple” and feel out of place amongst the rest of us !
I would say, its all of us who are weird. Not him.
???!!!! Wah! Wah! – Hey sangeet visharad , Kahan they aap ?. Bravo ! Succinct , precise review by a true music lover who writes above any parochial considerations. Superstar Reviewers ki sangat (Senty, Mehfil et al ) mein aapka swagat hai.
@ Senty – Dudette ! Do not get into the diagnostic mode in haste. Be prepared for da dreaded TanaaaaaaNaaNana background music for da seedha sadha Debojit. In my cynical opinion (IMCO) Da cash hungry mongrels @ Zee TeeVee will reveal all at an appropriately heart tugging moment.
Senty/Mehfil/DocKaul,
I tried to post my comments on our other blog site but it didn’t work due to some problem. Any way thanks for your warm welcome, its nice to interact with you again.
Now my take on todays episode:
Shujaat seems a bit ambitious and always shows hurry in his performance, and due to this reason he loses control. Otherwise, he has the talent & training to give a good performance.
Yashita is here to stay!! she has good voice and there is feel in her singing (agree with Senty)
Debojeet! he brings emotions in his performance and can move the audiance but loses control of sur often with overdose….
Faraz looked promising in the beginning but has not been consistent so far…
For tomorrow I have hopes with Zaheer and Koshak.
Mehfil G, I too compared 2007 shows (SRGm & SVOI) with the current ones and lost my interest as I miss Mussarat & Toshi. Actually I 100% agree with DocKaul and add that down the line when we will think about these shows, we will remember Mussarat & Toshi only from 2007.
I agree with Senty which supplements my opinion that we have to enjoy the present although we always miss the past.
Thats that, hope tomorrow’s episode is better and more interesting to share our thoughts.
sheila i would slightly disagree with you in case of debojit.yes he is a bit retarded and might gain a few symapthy votes but i still have in my head his first day performance when he sang gangster song na jane koi.and because that song from james is a very strong one and everybody cant sing it.the way he performed ,i think speaks in itself.its,in my opinion,not so good selection of songs,rather then talent in cases of most of the contestants.for example,arshad and shashi commited suicides.and faraz and shujat tried their best too to get eliminated.pratibha,naina,yashita,naina are not only beautiful voices but beautiful minds too when it comes to the selection of songs.well done girls
DocKaul G,
I read your comments of 29 Aug episode and we are in the same boat regarding judges of both shows.
Can you pl upload Toshi’s couple of performances mentioned below at your esnips:
1. Pia re (from sonyshow Ustadon ke Ustad)
2. Teri Dewani (from sonyshow Ustadon ke Ustad)
3. O re Pia (from Jo Jeeta wohi Superstar)
Actually, I am in the process of making DVD of the memoreal performances of Toshi & Mussarat. As we can’t rely on youtube, many of vedios are no longer available. I will appreciate if you can help me create the dvd of our favourite singers.
Regards.
Dear Basit Bhai,
Sorry , No can do. My collection is primarily of MP3 files. The video somewhat detracts from the performance. I still cringe at the editing of Mussarat’s Saanware. The guy was delivering the performance of a life time & the judges were chitchatting, sipping liquids, The mahagurus ??!!*%( Sajjid/Vidya ) giggling away exchanging sweet nothings grrr the woes were many , so sorry the only multiple music vdos in my collection are Nusrat saabs live performances.
yes infact since 22 of august episode no english reviews are available.plz shahsi try to add those reviews too.i dont know about the others but i used to read reviews before seeing the video
so nice to hear from you.i told you not visiting the site was irresistable harjeet je.yes i too am waiting for the performances of kaushak,zaheer,sara,naina.we know you are on vacations but keep posting.have nice time
@fayyaz je ramadan main kahen weakness to nahe ho rahe janab jo kam kam nazar ate hain.roze hamare lambe hain aur thak ap jate hain?anyway just joking.plz send your commoents when you watch todays episode plz.
ok shashi is not all that..dats y he was out twice..once he was brought bak but he cud only sing one kind of song n dats ghazal…too me dats nothing…da person dat deserves to win this is Debojit..no one can sing like the way he does…he sings from his heart…he sings with his heart out n no other contestant cud sing da way he does…not jus da bheegi bheegi song was gud…da saawariya song was marvelous..give dat song to ne other contestant in da show n dey will never get close to on how debojit sang it…HATS off to him…debojit ur my winner
This time, girls are better than boys on an average. So all the top three singers should be girls. Pratibha (undoubtedly no. 1), Nayana /Yashita (not sure about the ranks).
Sorry for the sexist comments. But girls hardly become toppers you see!!!
no this time its equal n it shud not be three grlz in da top there… it will b debojit, prathiba, and another boy mayb…it shud not b all grlz for sure..
THIS SAREGAMAPA CHALLENGE 2009
DEKHO ZO LOG IS SHOW ME AA RAHE HAI VO SANGEET KO SEEKHE HUYE INSAAN HAI..MERE KHAYAL SE “RAGHU” AAP KI BAAT SE MAI BILKUL BHI SEHMAT NAHI HOON.
I think sashi has a wonderful voice. It was very wrong to eliminate him twice. I think the judges should give him a chance cuz he is a SANGEET PANDIT!!!
debojit has an amazing voice.my fav was the saawariya song…
pratheeba and yashita are good. they fit to be top three.
hi adi i hope u read this message I LOVE U.
well u can message me at KSJM@YAHOO.COM
well when r u going to perform in bollywood
and write a song for me.And i have i 1 sister
KHAYATI,my mom JYOTI, my dad MUKESH, and me
SIDDHI.And r u going to be in saregamapa
challange 2010 sangeet ka vishvauth?well i hope u will mail me at KSJM@YAHOO.COM.i want to be a singer too.my sister loves u and ASMA
MOHOMMAD RAFI. HAPPY NEW YEAR! i am gujrati ,
vahariya. i watch u every friday, saterday.
when ever u mail me write your e-mail address
i love u.
Dear mehfil
Debojit is not ‘normal’ in the sense we use it. He is suffering from some disoder- either parkinson’d diease or some other disorder where the body grows but the mind remains childlike. So I think he is definitely not a regular cae. a psychologist frined of mine also watches this programme, and she confirmed it.
as fro VOI, if they present a sympahy case can saregama be far behind? You know what happens in this battle of TRPS. Both these shows are at loggerheards with each other in terms of TRPS.
dear raghu,
I agree with you. I know debojit will be in top 5. bengalis are too powerful in zee. But instead of debojit couldn’t they havce hsoen sayon/ mansiha? Both these young singers ha dthe spark and talent.
My top 5 will be pratibha, shahsi sumna, naina, mitika and debojit(not becaseu I want debo to bethere, i would prefer arhad but I don’t think arshad will be back)
Dear Sheila,
Please take that mind (bengalies etc) abt Debojit. He may be having some weaknesses like versatality, Pronounciation etc..but he brings Josh to the song.Sayan can not sing Joshila songs..He may be good for soft songs..Manisha’s performance has weaknesses..No consistancy in her singing also lack of confidence too..
But Debojit is better than these..I do not think he will make it to the top.but..He deserves this position..
this is my view..
@Sheila
You see … both prathiba and debojit were partners in duet song and both were applauded … so the judges HAD TO critisize Debojit in his solo performance in order to give prathiba the ‘chakra’ … little bit of off-stage politics and planning … just my opinion .. i might be wrong …
In todays performance (IMO) 3 poeple deserved the chakra
1. Debojit himself
2. Prathiba
3. Yashita
According to ‘gharana politics’ Yashita already had the chakra, so she is out … debojit had it for one week, so the judges wanted to give it to prathiba and the only way they can do that is by promoting prathiba and downplaying debojit … Every judge probably want the chakra in his gharana at least once …
I really dont think Debojit NEEDS any sympathy votes … the guy can make it to the top on his own talent! … It was the ‘Bahu’ Anupuma who was playing the sassu-maa-and-child-at-home card … quite pathetic if you ask me …
It was a nice epiode. But another format change…! Really everything is very disorganized on this show. Did they dcide thisbeacuse thye realized current top 12 is not the best top 12?
If shashi returns thorugh bramhastra, zee will probaly bring him to top 5 but not allow him to win. winner is debojit/sunvinder. mark my words
and if its a female winner it has to be pratibha/naina/mitika. These 3 girls rock
Rhea..
where are you man.sunvinder out of contest now unless he comes back as Brahmastra…
I wish sashi suman should come back..
For all the folks..
is there any on line voting for Brahmastra…
yes rhea,shashi and sunvinder should come back.they are good and i hope when they come back they choose the songs that suit their voices.this show is like a war pattern,one mistake and you could be the one eliminated.i hope they learned their lessons and when back will rock the stage
i think yashita has the potential to be the winner. just giving my oppinion. sorry if my reply hurt you… can’t help it for that’s a fact!!
If you want shashi back please manil zee at response@zeenetwork.com. The more mails they gte, they will realzie shahsi is going to earn them votes and get him back
Yshita’s weakness and debojit’s weakness is that they cannot sing in a polsihed way. i am not a music expert but if I compare them to shahsi and pratibha and naian I do see the diff. i may be misatken but plz could someone help me here?
I concur this completely
I mean PRATHIBHA AND DEBOJIT duet energized the show..I watched it almost 20 times …
superb, fantastic, outstanding, mindblowing, history. their performance rocked out the stage.
@Sheila,
Just a clarification……’parkinsons is a neurodegenerative disorder that affects certain areas of the brain that control motor skills and speech. The very fact that Debojit sings so well…..he does not suffer from parkinson’s disease.
@Mehfil,
VOI rocks..
Any of you know where I can watch star voice of India. Please??????
@DM Queen
You can watch the Star Voice of India here:
http://starvoi.com/
Cheers
Jamshid
@rekha
I may be wrong abou the name but the FACT is he is suffering froma disroder where the body grows but the mind doesn’t…one can make thi sout from his body language and way of talking.
That doesn’t take away from his singing…but I don’t want him to win becaue he is not a worthy successor of debojit and aneek. though debojit sahha has improved drasticallyof late, his win was not deserved. Aneek was excellent though. and the little benagli girl anwesha in chote ustaad was OUTSTADING but didn’t iwn. so I don’t agree about the bengali lobby theory…
sometimes bengalis are voted out even when theyd eserved to win. Eg Monali thakur in indian idol 2, anwesha in chote ustaad, amit pual in indian idol 3
Please Please ..
let us not talk about the disorder ,Bengali etc..about Debojit..
Please think about Michael Phelps(9 olympic gold medal winner) he has ADHD (Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder )..
what he created..
So let us not under estimate any one disorder etc..
so far debojit is good..He may not be the best..
Please it is a request for all
raghu you are so right,look at the fighting spirit and not the weaknesses of the boy.and as far as i heard his mom told in the show that if he is not normal,he is not abnormal either,so lets leave it.he is a very good and powerful voice full of energy and thrill.enjoy his determination and will power.the way he sung james song in his first performance,my favourite one,na jane koi,i started adoring him.he wins or not doesnt matter,he is a good addition to the indian music stage.in my opinion this year a girl should win,unless they do blunders.
He is only ‘Simple’ ..he is not suffering from any disease.. and i couldnt stop laughing when people say he has Parkinsons..LOL..I should salute the psychiatrist who has diagnosed him just watching him on the TV…:-)
yeah agree shashi, i too am amused on that tv diagnosis that too of parkinsonism.i couldnt help myself laughing thinking most of the singers dance or do certain movements.so are they all suffering from…..?anyway he is a good singer,deboujit.and i like his voice
Don’t mind if i say something observing and watching the show live when his mother said it openly in the show that Debojit is not a normal person but has passion for music Either i’m wrong listening or his mother is wrong to say that. He did perform Na jane koi remarkably well but his weakness was obvious in this episode. His other performances were remarkable and must be appreciated. He is humble and meak person and good at heart. thanks.
hey could you post the written update too? thank you!!
hi harjeet
where r u?
UZma
HI.
Why the long silence?
I had Just watched the 5th September episode.
Good stack ranking by AgentX. Sahi hai.. I would rank them the same.. except that the “feel” in a song is a majjjjjjor factor for me to like a performance. Ya, I m a kaansen too
My kaan protests in two cases.. one if the pronunciation kicks, the other if the voice lacks emotions.
So I would award extra brownie points to Yashita just for bringing the “feel” into her songs. I never noticed her that much before.. but she sure is stepping up.
Yashita’s solo was a catchy marathi (I think) song. I dont know this song, and I have no clue what she was singing about.. but her body language and her expressions adding to her good singing said a lot about the song and obviously she was enjoying it. I liked her the best today.
Debojit stands out coz he adds the “feel” into his performances as well. Kabhi kabhie kuch over enthu ho jaata hai and then his sur takes a break, but if you noticed in the Debu-Pratibha duet, Debu ek dumm doobke gaa raha tha..”jai jai shiv shankar” and Pratibha was looking very detached and casual. I didnt like her as much in that round as in her solo.. which was very very good. Hmm.. maybe I gotta kooky kaan.
If I give a brownie point to Debojit for the “feel”, I would take it away for his lisp. Clarity of words is important for me as well.
Shujjat slips down in my ranking jus coz of this reason too.. He steps down on emotions and sometimes, I find his classical twists actually hindering an otherwise good controlled performance. Today, in his solo song, his “aa” came out as “ae”.
Feel weel chhodke, sirf sur taal etc dekho to .. Pratibha, Shujjat and Yashita were good today.
Last, but o certainly not the least.. apna Adi putr needs a complete charitra parivartan ..a.k.a character makeover.
He needs a better lipi, mucho better kesh .. err hair-stylist, MUCHO better vastra-designer, go easy on the ati-shuddh hindi (he sounds like Doordarshan gone wild!) and needs to just be natural and comfy on stage. Otherwise, we need a shabdkosh on the sidebar.
Debojit does not have Parkinsons…. he is just too simple for this world !
Its amazing how someone can be “simple” and feel out of place amongst the rest of us !
I would say, its all of us who are weird. Not him.
i agree
???!!!! Wah! Wah! – Hey sangeet visharad , Kahan they aap ?. Bravo ! Succinct , precise review by a true music lover who writes above any parochial considerations. Superstar Reviewers ki sangat (Senty, Mehfil et al ) mein aapka swagat hai.
@ Senty – Dudette ! Do not get into the diagnostic mode in haste. Be prepared for da dreaded TanaaaaaaNaaNana background music for da seedha sadha Debojit. In my cynical opinion (IMCO) Da cash hungry mongrels @ Zee TeeVee will reveal all at an appropriately heart tugging moment.
Senty/Mehfil/DocKaul,
I tried to post my comments on our other blog site but it didn’t work due to some problem. Any way thanks for your warm welcome, its nice to interact with you again.
Now my take on todays episode:
Shujaat seems a bit ambitious and always shows hurry in his performance, and due to this reason he loses control. Otherwise, he has the talent & training to give a good performance.
Yashita is here to stay!! she has good voice and there is feel in her singing (agree with Senty)
Debojeet! he brings emotions in his performance and can move the audiance but loses control of sur often with overdose….
Faraz looked promising in the beginning but has not been consistent so far…
For tomorrow I have hopes with Zaheer and Koshak.
Mehfil G, I too compared 2007 shows (SRGm & SVOI) with the current ones and lost my interest as I miss Mussarat & Toshi. Actually I 100% agree with DocKaul and add that down the line when we will think about these shows, we will remember Mussarat & Toshi only from 2007.
I agree with Senty which supplements my opinion that we have to enjoy the present although we always miss the past.
Thats that, hope tomorrow’s episode is better and more interesting to share our thoughts.
sheila i would slightly disagree with you in case of debojit.yes he is a bit retarded and might gain a few symapthy votes but i still have in my head his first day performance when he sang gangster song na jane koi.and because that song from james is a very strong one and everybody cant sing it.the way he performed ,i think speaks in itself.its,in my opinion,not so good selection of songs,rather then talent in cases of most of the contestants.for example,arshad and shashi commited suicides.and faraz and shujat tried their best too to get eliminated.pratibha,naina,yashita,naina are not only beautiful voices but beautiful minds too when it comes to the selection of songs.well done girls
DocKaul G,
I read your comments of 29 Aug episode and we are in the same boat regarding judges of both shows.
Can you pl upload Toshi’s couple of performances mentioned below at your esnips:
1. Pia re (from sonyshow Ustadon ke Ustad)
2. Teri Dewani (from sonyshow Ustadon ke Ustad)
3. O re Pia (from Jo Jeeta wohi Superstar)
Actually, I am in the process of making DVD of the memoreal performances of Toshi & Mussarat. As we can’t rely on youtube, many of vedios are no longer available. I will appreciate if you can help me create the dvd of our favourite singers.
Regards.
Dear Basit Bhai,
) giggling away exchanging sweet nothings grrr the woes were many , so sorry the only multiple music vdos in my collection are Nusrat saabs live performances.
Sorry , No can do. My collection is primarily of MP3 files. The video somewhat detracts from the performance. I still cringe at the editing of Mussarat’s Saanware. The guy was delivering the performance of a life time & the judges were chitchatting, sipping liquids, The mahagurus ??!!*%( Sajjid/Vidya
Do you write the reviews in English anymore?
The part about what the judges say but in English or have you stopped?
yes infact since 22 of august episode no english reviews are available.plz shahsi try to add those reviews too.i dont know about the others but i used to read reviews before seeing the video
Its not possible for this week..but i will try from the next week…
So “bahu” has finally made her Exit…However unlike some of the other contestants, she took the elimination very gracefully…Well Done Kudiah
Yashita & Shujaat’s duet performance was the Best. Shujaat really did Justice to His solo performance…can’t wait to hear him sing more classical songs
For the first Time I actually liked Yashita’s performance…Not bad she can also sing In Marathi…I liked her in the the “Chaiya Chaiya” song
Prathiba has always been Very Good in her performances…She’s pretty…
Faraz performance was good…BUT this Munda can do so much better
I think Debojit’s previous performances were so much better…No offence FOlks But I think he might be making His exit….
P.S. SureshWAd wore a very Nice Paghdi today…
@FaYYaz Mia and Dr. Amir
I’ll post my comments for the next episode tomorrow. Can’t wait to hear Naina, Sara, Kaushik and Zaheer.
Take care
so nice to hear from you.i told you not visiting the site was irresistable harjeet je.yes i too am waiting for the performances of kaushak,zaheer,sara,naina.we know you are on vacations but keep posting.have nice time
@fayyaz je ramadan main kahen weakness to nahe ho rahe janab jo kam kam nazar ate hain.roze hamare lambe hain aur thak ap jate hain?anyway just joking.plz send your commoents when you watch todays episode plz.
P.S. Why Is Ghulam Ali Saab not present in this episode? Hmmm…Hopefully SRGMPA will invite him along with Jagjit Singh Saab for the Ghazal round
And both Must perform on the show….NOt Two lines…
prathiba u are superb.. the way u sing a song,,its awesome.. i am already your fan. keep it up
ok shashi is not all that..dats y he was out twice..once he was brought bak but he cud only sing one kind of song n dats ghazal…too me dats nothing…da person dat deserves to win this is Debojit..no one can sing like the way he does…he sings from his heart…he sings with his heart out n no other contestant cud sing da way he does…not jus da bheegi bheegi song was gud…da saawariya song was marvelous..give dat song to ne other contestant in da show n dey will never get close to on how debojit sang it…HATS off to him…debojit ur my winner
Ok here is my BIASED two cents. But I am serious.
This time, girls are better than boys on an average. So all the top three singers should be girls. Pratibha (undoubtedly no. 1), Nayana /Yashita (not sure about the ranks).
Sorry for the sexist comments. But girls hardly become toppers you see!!!
no this time its equal n it shud not be three grlz in da top there… it will b debojit, prathiba, and another boy mayb…it shud not b all grlz for sure..
THIS SAREGAMAPA CHALLENGE 2009
DEKHO ZO LOG IS SHOW ME AA RAHE HAI VO SANGEET KO SEEKHE HUYE INSAAN HAI..MERE KHAYAL SE “RAGHU” AAP KI BAAT SE MAI BILKUL BHI SEHMAT NAHI HOON.
HAI SHEILA
IS ME M.P KI BAAT KAHASE AAGAYI
I think sashi has a wonderful voice. It was very wrong to eliminate him twice. I think the judges should give him a chance cuz he is a SANGEET PANDIT!!!
debojit has an amazing voice.my fav was the saawariya song…
pratheeba and yashita are good. they fit to be top three.
i love u adi.
hi adi i just love u.
hi adi i hope u read this message I LOVE U.
well u can message me at KSJM@YAHOO.COM
well when r u going to perform in bollywood
and write a song for me.And i have i 1 sister
KHAYATI,my mom JYOTI, my dad MUKESH, and me
SIDDHI.And r u going to be in saregamapa
challange 2010 sangeet ka vishvauth?well i hope u will mail me at KSJM@YAHOO.COM.i want to be a singer too.my sister loves u and ASMA
MOHOMMAD RAFI. HAPPY NEW YEAR! i am gujrati ,
vahariya. i watch u every friday, saterday.
when ever u mail me write your e-mail address
i love u.
from: siddhi mukesh shah
to: aditya narayan