Comments on: Saregamapa Challenge 2009 Videos – 19th September episode

By: nona

nona — Fri, 26 Sep 2008 17:56:46 +0000

I agree with the common theme here: Asma has no business to be on the show–she does not even know basic sur, any other of the eliminated participants is way above her in singing. Come on, Zee, this is a SINGING show!! Pick the best singer, not the funniest/silliest person. Get your basic criteria of selction right..it is an insult to singers like Shashi to have this silly girl selected over him. And all this drama of “main koshish karronga, main mehnat karoonga” is ridiculaous. There are more accomplished people already ahead of her–why waste their chance??
If these comments are read by the producers/Aditya Narayan, I hope they take note.
And i agree again–Tarun is a good singer, but Shashi is better! He was perhaps picked for his sob-story which seems to work always.
Sara should be thrown out for her tactics as well..she is such a hypocritical person…did anyoen notice in a round when there were mahagurus, she touched Ghulam Ali sahib’s feet, but did not even look at Suresh Wadekar ji??

By: Anil Tiwari

Anil Tiwari — Thu, 25 Sep 2008 10:02:22 +0000

Pratibha is strong contender of saregamapa….
she has got very good voice …and why asma she does even don’t know basic(SA RE GA MA PA) of indian music she can but for we should not leave then who are really deserve for ….

By: Yusuf

Yusuf — Wed, 24 Sep 2008 17:10:21 +0000

Asma was not the best to come back although she is a lovely girl. She will leave soon anyway. I like Mitika most but I know she won’t win. Debojit will probably be the winner and he sings well.

By: Jit

Jit — Mon, 22 Sep 2008 22:21:33 +0000

No offense..you need to get your musical strings tuned. Aneek was a deserving winner, not because he’s cool..but because he can sing. It is a shame that Zee brings Tarun and Asma instead of Sashi/Manisha/Sunvinder..where is this world going to? I have always questioned the musical taste of the Indian Junta..but this reinforces the fact that most of Indian public do not understand good singing from poor singing. This selection preposterous!

By: Harjeet

Harjeet — Sun, 21 Sep 2008 13:12:50 +0000

@Sashi – Admin

Pls remove this guy’s statement

By: Harjeet

Harjeet — Sun, 21 Sep 2008 13:05:22 +0000

@Sashi – Admin

Pls remove this lady’s statement

By: Image Babble

Image Babble — Sun, 21 Sep 2008 10:22:56 +0000

In all other countries you will see they try to uphold their own participants over overseas ones in any international show. But our poor country must be the only one that purposely puts down rightful and deserving Indians over buffoons from overseas. I cannot understand the logic behind this fake attempt to be great. There is no logic in Asma coming back to a show where the likes of Shashi, Sayan, Sunvinder, Divya Kumar are present. The music sense of Indian audiences cannot have gone down as much. The audiences very well understand that they are here to listen to great talents not to watch a silly soap opera. So I am sure this was not their verdict. The ones who would like to watch Asma would rather tune into comedy serial than to SRGMP. Is Zee listening???

By: Image Babble

Image Babble — Sun, 21 Sep 2008 08:45:11 +0000

SRGMP is turning out to be quite another Laughter Challenge or at least more fake than the Saas Bahu serials. Looks like the program directors are bent on crushing the huge good will that the program built over so many years of genuine dedication to find real musical talents. No wonder you cannot see Gajendra Singh’s name in the crew casting. He was the one who took the program to unprecedented glory, now the rascals that have replaced him are undoing his good work. I miss him

By: Navi

Navi — Sun, 21 Sep 2008 04:20:33 +0000

Wow. I havn’t cried this much over any other show. I didn’t really understand the move they made with Asma. I mean, shes a sweet girl but I’d say the other girls were cheated because of their talent. Anyway, this show is so inspiring and beautiful. The individual stories of each singer just amaze me. Definitely a worthwhile show, and great for your soul.

By: haha

haha — Sun, 21 Sep 2008 03:37:29 +0000

hahahahah…………..crap!