Comments on: Saregamapa Little champs Videos – 15th February episode

By: cwxwwwxwwxwx

cwxwwwxwwxwx — Tue, 23 Dec 2008 09:23:12 +0000

well, hi admin adn people nice forum indeed. how’s life? hope it’s introduce branch

By: Rajiv

Rajiv — Sun, 02 Mar 2008 02:57:00 +0000

This whole episode leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

All these kids are very talented. Some of the kids in previous episodes took in such great sporting support when they were eliminated. Even their parents were very sportive.

This is just a show, every episode some one has to be eliminated. And, this is not a matter of life and death.

Also, it is not correct to raise a minority issue every time there is a less favorable result. If one minority candidate has been eliminated, haven't 10X of majority candidates not eliminated?

Grown ups should behave as grown ups. It is challenging to accept elimination at this stage of the competition, but please broaden your perspective.

Amir has a bright future ahead, and so do others who have been eliminated. These kids are all celebrities at such young age. Take the positives out of it and move on.

Life is much bigger than one competition.

My humble two cents on it!

By: m_khan90

m_khan90 — Sat, 01 Mar 2008 18:26:00 +0000

@ravi,

All reading all the comments from all the people if you still said what you said then i can say that"

"Samaj Samaj ke Samaj ko Samjho
Samaj samaj nah bhi ek Samaj hai
Samaj Samaj ke jo nah samjee
Mere nazar mein woh nasamaj hai"
Aur
Ek(Bewquf)dhodo hazaar milte hain.

By: Ravi

Ravi — Sat, 01 Mar 2008 16:10:00 +0000

This is the common problem with these muslims. Sonu was right in saying “Jis thali mein khate hai usi mein ched karte hai”. The fault was totally on Amir’s family who have ruined their son’s future. I would say they are not to be blamed, its in the muslim blood that makes them behave like this. If you cannot accept defeat then why do you bring your child in a competition. They know that winners will be decided on public votings and public voted for Tanmay so why to fight now. If Tanmay would have been eliminated, his family would have never created any scene because they are civilized people.

By: Raj

Raj — Thu, 28 Feb 2008 17:56:00 +0000

Simply best Comments @Sam Singh, I totally agree with you. The best talented singer is out from the show, who is Amir, who could be the year best search talent of the country through this show, But we still hope for Anamika. God knows what happen.

We are with you Amir. Go Ahead, Your road will not be easy in the industry, but the good man also in the industry, wish you could meet with them.

By: Ismail

Ismail — Thu, 28 Feb 2008 15:32:00 +0000

Amir’s family is known to be illiterate. So, they could not tell the story of mathematical impact in a proper way to make the judges feel about the mistake they committed by extending one episode and gathering votes of two episode. Amir’s brother tried to tell the thing quite sincerely in the beginning. But the host Adi commented in a rude manner. Then Amir’s brother was becoming more upset and the drama took place. How can the judges expect from the winner to agree to extend one more episode? They sowed courtesy for two reasons. (1)They thought it would give wrong message to the voters due to not agreeing the judges. (2)The judges would give bad comments in future. So, the judges should understand this. Within seconds, it is hard to decide by the contestants to agree about extending one episode. Losers can agree immediately. public voting is just like a lottery. Can it be right to say the winner of a lottery to agree upon for the next draw and canceling the winning result? In Amir’s case the mathematical calculation was such that if elimination from Raturi or Rohan was made as per scheduled format, Amir was second in that round and hence winner. In the next gathered voting, he was first in a voting. So, he was already within last three contestant. So, he was deprived of his third already gained position. Amir’s familt is apoor. They lost 10 lakh rupees. They can be angry. But the way host Adi and judge Sonu Nigam commented was very rude as he personnally attacked. Personnal comments of praise is always a good thing but personnel attack is very bad… very bad. Sony lost his respect from many people. Amir’s family is illiterate. Why? Sachar committee report is available. The Muslims are suffere in India. They contain about 20 per cent population of the country. In a democracy, the fruits of democracy must be shared according to population in every respect like education, employment, parliament seats, assembly seats. Now everybody can see, how many percentage sharing muslims have in parliament,assemblies, employment etc. So, if Amir’s family is illiterate, Govt. of India and State governments are responsible. The muslim suffer all these. So, nothing wrong if in an angry mood, such thing comes out. The truth is coming out.

By: Jay

Jay — Wed, 27 Feb 2008 15:33:00 +0000

@Sam Singh. What you have written here is wonderful. Hats off to your maturity and thinking. I too agree with you. It is very sad to see that our so-called music legends have been sold out. And it is even worse that we have many folks out there who think that what zee is doing is right and what Sonu had said about Aamir’s family was not wrong.

By: Sam Singh

Sam Singh — Wed, 27 Feb 2008 07:37:00 +0000

To Rohini

Its interesting that you mentioned the US elections. Sorry to give you a little insight and dishearten you enthusiasm. Every word any of the presidential candidates say (it makes no difference whether Democrat or Republican) has been paid for by one lobbyist or another. Bottom-line politics of money plays the game. With 25+ years in US I know this little too well.

This brings up a very important point – even the kids are not spared from the same type of money politics and it comes in all shapes & sizes, even voting – select the winner thru public votes. So, a talent search contest has now become perfect platform for playing money politics.
It does not matter that Anamika is by far the best of the bunch by stretch of any standard – yet she in 3rd rank and both Vasudhara and Amir have been eliminated. Two of the most talented singers are now gone – not by their lack of musical talents – but by the dark forces of the money politics that just has more power as “Power-lifters”. Who on earth would vote for Rohan or even Tanmay over Anamika, Vasundhara or Amir, and if they do – they are either deaf or dumb, or simple been won over by the dark side.

Also, I had a lot of respect for both Sonu and Sureshji. To see such stalwarts of Indian music – have completely sold themselves to the evils of money politics and such injustice to little kids is beyond comprehension.

I strongly object to your contention that voting is only based on state / community / language. I am from Panjab, and will probably not be able to speak a single proper sentence in Bengali or Assamese – yet I believe that Anamika is the best we now have. Off course I will support Rohan – but given a choice I will most certainly vote for Anamika. She is simply the best of the 3.

By: raveena

raveena — Tue, 26 Feb 2008 04:40:00 +0000

WHAT I FIND REALLY FRUSTERATING IS HOW MEDIOCRE PERFORMANCES GOT A+ FOR THE PAST FEW WEEKS AND ALTHOUGH THEY HAD FLAWS, SONU AND SURESH DONT POINT THEM OUT. BUT WHEN IT COMES TO AMIR, THE SMALL MISTAKES ARE NOT FORGIVEN LIKE THE OTHER KIDS’ ARE. FURTHERMORE, HE IS DISCOURAGED WEEK AFTER WEEK FOR THE TINIEST DETAILS AND HIS MINDBLOWING SINGING IS COMPLETELY DISREGARDED. HE WAS GIVEN VERY LITTLE OR NO POSITIVE FEEDBACK AT ALL – AND HENCE HIS SINGING BECAME PROGRESSIVELY WEAKER. THEY ALSO INITIATE WHAT I’LL CALL ‘CUTE TALK’ WITH THE OTHER KIDS THAT DISTRACTS THE PUBLIC FROM THE MEDIOCRE PERFORMANCE SO THAT ITS NO LONGER THE SINGING, BUT THE CHARISMA A CHILD EXUDES ON STAGE THAT DETERMINES HIS/HER FATE IN THE VOTES.

LASTLY, WHY DID SONU SCOLD AMIR FOR NOT MAKING EYE CONTACT WITH HIM. OBVIOUSLY IF SONU LOOKED OVER AT THE OTHER KIDS, AMIR WOULD DO THE SAME!!.. AMIR THOUGHT HE WAS ADDRESSING ALL THE KIDS SITTING DOWN SO HE LOOKED AWAY.
?????????????????????????????????

By: Ismail

Ismail — Tue, 26 Feb 2008 04:24:00 +0000

Though Amir’s family had no right to question after two episodes, the family tried to complain how Amir had to suffer. There was mathematical impact on the result by extending one episode by not eliminating one of the contestants from Raturi and Rohan Preet. Amir was first in the gathered voting of two episodes. He was second in previous episode. So, if elimination was as per the routine format, Amir was already in the final three contestants. The Sonu Nigam’s comments when Amir was first “Soch samaj kar vote dijiye” was fingerpointing while the judges last three episode comments on Amir was negative. Judges found inconsistant as at one time they recognise Amir as very good singer and at the last three episode comments , as if Amir was a dull. Strange! when their favourite is very near to last three.