Videos of 6h October Episode of Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenge 2007
Here are videos of 6th October Episode of saregamapa challenge 2007
Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenege 07 – [Episode-46] – 6th October 07 – Pt02 *HQ*
Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenege 07 – [Episode-46] – 6th October 07 – Pt03 *HQ*
Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenege 07 – [Episode-46] – 6th October 07 – Pt04 *HQ*
Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenege 07 – [Episode-46] – 6th October 07 – Pt05 *HQ*
Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenege 07 – [Episode-46] – 6th October 07 – Pt06 *HQ*
pls. vote 4 raja he is the best.
amanat is gud but not as gud as raja AND RAJA DOES NOT MIMIC SUKHWINDER AND IS VERY STRONG ON HIGH AND LOW NOTES.aneek has come through unfair means and should not win.RAJA HAS BEEN THE BEST SINCE THE STARTING AND HAS A TRIL OF AWESOME SONGS LIKE
1.ALLAH KE BANDE
2.MERI ZINDAGI EK PYAS
3.TEREBIN NAHIN LAGDA DIL MERA
4.NAINA THAG LENGE.
5.TU HI RE
6.MAHIYA
7.RUT AA GAYE RE
8.MAA TUJHE SALAM
9.PIYA HAJI ALI
10.RANG DE BASANTI
11.KUDI SAPNO MEIN MILTI HAIN
12.DARE E DISCO
13. CHAIYYA CHAIYYA
14.TERI DIWANI
WHOEVER SAID RAJA IS ONLY A QAWWALI SINGER IS WRONG HE CAN SING ANY TYPE OF SONG.
whoever says that raja is bad at low notes is wrong he is the best in the show since the starting and is very good at both low and high notes
aneek might be a good singer but which music director would choose a would be sonu if he can get the real man to sing fer him. moreover aneek is way too much hyped by himass besharamiya (what the heck does that overgrown chimp think of himself?????? he is like a damn unwanted tape recorder……just goes on and on bout aneek and tries to put raja down). i would also like to add that whomsoever thinks that raja is bad really really needs to consult a doc….the person is suffering from himass induced deafness (freakfaces!!!!!!)
Hey can someone help me?? Is the finale going to be shown live in Singapore??? If it is, what time is it going to be shown (Singapore time)??? Pls someone tell me. Thanks!!!
)))
I really don’t care who wins.. All of us now knows who is the best singer ..
BTW, heard that Amanat sang Tujhse Naraaz four times.. does anyone have that video?
Sonu Nigam came to Bombay in 1990 and struggled for 7 years before he got the recognition.
In the initial stages, he was type-cast as a Rafi-sound-alike. In 1997 after Border and Pardes only he was able to establish his unique style of his own.
Same thing will happen to all new comers. If you think that getting one offer or two, will make Amanat, Aneek or Raja will be established singer, you still do not know Bollywood.
Previous Indian Idols and SRGMP contestants are still struggling without much success.
No MD wants to take chance in Bollywood. So they keep using the established singers only.
When Lata, Asha were in their young age they used sing almost all songs. Same goes to Rafi, Kishore, Mukesh.
Sonu’s hard work and perseverance kept him in the industry and he got the needed break in Sandese Aate Hai” from Border (1997) and “Yeh Dil Deewana” in the film Pardes (1997).
So if you want to see them succeed just wait another 5 years minimum.
Thanks,
@Any
The reason u are saying all this stuff about raja is because u r a fan. u r trying to sound like a critic but are sounding ignorant because of it. raja is definitely not good on low notes. and u say he has been good from start to finish??? yeah right, he forgot lyrics in 2 of his performances earlier and then had a horrible 3 week but still managed to stay in.. . do not compare raja to Amanat because that will be an insult to Amanat. Jagjit singh, Sanjay Gupta, Adnan sami, and all the judges themself have said that Amanat is best and he deserves to win..
need i say more??
VOTE FOR AMANAT EVERYONE..
PLEASE… HE DESERVES IT..
o yeah, i can list Amanat’s songs too. and btw Raja got voted off once but came back for some weird reason. Amanat has always been there and didnt need any pity to make him come back.
1. Aie Mere Pyare Watan
2. Bijuriya
3. Chori Chori Chupke Se
4. Dil Lutiya
5. Fiza
6. Hame Tumse Pyar Kitna
7. Jane Kaha Gaye Wo Din
8. Jhoka Hawaka
9. Kabhi To Najar Milao
10. Khadi Aa Mil
11. Kuch Mere Dil Ne Kaha
12. Mere Naina
13. Mitawa
14. Parda Hai Parda
15. Rangeen
16. Rasme Ulfat
17. Sawan Bita Jaye
18. Tera Jadu Chal Gaya
19. Ya Rabba
20. Ye Hosla
21. With Junaid and Mussarat – Jazzbat Junun
AMANAT DO NOT WORRY AT ALL, YOU ARE A WINNER ALREADY & ALWAYS. YOUR VOICE IS AS SWEET AS HONEY. MY GENUINE FEELING IS THAT, ZEE SAREGAMAPA OR ANY OTHER TALENT SHOW, CANNOT PRODUCE A GIFTED SINGER LIKE YOU. YOU ARE UNIQUE AND NUMERO UNO.
COMING TO THE SUPPORT FROM YOUR GURU, HE IS DOING THE RIGHT KIND OF THING, HE IS FULLY QUALIFIED AS A GURU, HE IS UNBIASED AND GIVES HIS JUDGEMENT OR SCOLDING GENUINELY AS AND WHEN NEEDED. NOT LIKE THE OTHER GURUS WHO GIVE THEIR SUPPORT IN A BIASED MANNER EVEN IF THEIR SINGERS GIVES LOW PERFOMANCES.
I.D. PURELY MEANS AND FEELS, THAT AMANAT’S VOICE SHOULD SPEAK AND NOT UN-NECCESSARY HYPE TO GET THE VOTES.
THOSE WHO ARE GENUINE MUSIC LOVERS AND PATRIOTS WILL DEFINITELY VOTE BASED ON THE OVER-ALL PERFORMANCES AND THEIR VERSATALITY RATHER THAN THE ARTIFICIAL HYPE CREATED BY THE JUDGES WHICH DEFINITELY NOT WORTH TO BE CONSIDERED TO JUDGE ONES TRUE TALENT
HATS OFF TO YOU AMANT, I BOW MY HEAD WHOLE HEARTEDLY, IF POSSIBLE PLEASE PLEASE AND PLEASE MIGRATE TO INDIA, WITH YOUR WHOLE FAMILY AND RELATIVES, I BOW MY HEAD ONCE AGAIN TO YOUR PARENTS AND ALL THE GURUS WHO MADE AN AMANAT LIKE YOU.
MY VERY VERY BEST WISHES FOR YOUR PRESENT AND FUTURE AS WELL
Amanat Ali says, I JUST NEED YOUR PRAYERS,LOVE AND SUPPORT….SO PLZ PLZ PLZ KEEO LOVING AND SUPPORTING ME.THNX ALOT.BYE EVERYONE LOVEEEEEEEEEEEEEE YOUUUUUUUUUUUU ALLLLLLLLLLLL
Amanat Ali says, EVERYONE GOOD BYE, AND LUV FROM AMANAT. PLZ VOTE FOR ME BY SENDIN SMS TO, AMANAT AND SEND IT TO 57575. OR VOTE THROUGH INTERNET ON REDIFF.COM
Here is a video of Amanat singing “Hungama hai kyun”
http://youtube.com/watch?v=VI-XG46kjJ0&mode=related&search=
if anyone kind find ANY song by raja or Aneek that is sung better than that. then ill stop voting for Amanat and vote for them. NO JOKE. and i say this because i KNOW no one will be able to find a better song than Amanat’s.
btw “Mitwa and Tujhse Naraz” are equally as good as Hungama hai kyun. so yeah thats combined. and notice how EVERYONE on the show got up and applauds for Amanat for tujhse naraaz and make him sing it 3 times. that makes him a winner right there.
Abdullah Saying…
Here is a video of Amanat singing “Hungama hai kyun”
I am sorry you are forcing me to say this. I like Amanat’s songs.
But how many Ghulam Ali songs you have seen in Bollywood? And also if they want this kind of song in Bollywood don’t you thing that GA is still alive?
This competition is all about Talent hunt for playback singer not a ghazal singer.
I have read a lots of comments from different people. Most of people just comment in favour of singer whom they like, not giving honest comments to deserving singer. People who thinks raja is better then amanat should see the episode of 28th Sep. and tell me do they know music more then Padit Yashraj ji and Jagjit ji, as both said Amanat is No. 1 better then raja. FOR ANEEK: Aneek is far behind both Raja and Amanat.
I took a strong liking to Raja after seeing the Piya Haji Ali video. I still think it’s a great visual performance. I started following him closely thereafter and found his facial expressions and awkward body movements distracting and started to play the video without actually watching it, only listening to it with my earphones. I notice with Raja that eventhough he has a somewhat haunting and unusual voice, his singing is quite unrefined. He is technically challenged and goes offkey fairly often. Interestingly, Aneek, who I didn’t really care for, sounds much better with only audio.
If you LISTEN to Amanat’s last performance, again, you can hear a world of difference between him and Mika or Mike or whatever singing. Amanat sounds far better than the “accomplished” professional singer. It’s the same song, same stage, two different singers, one professional and the other wannabe but the wannave is clearly superior.
By the same token, Amanat’s last “Mitwa” where he rouses up the crowd when he goes low and takes off to go high, you can easily HEAR a break – it’s as if his vocal chords won’t quite cooperate, like a plane hitting a patch of turbulence and then resuming gaining altitude.
So, listen instead of watch, and it’ll be quite a different experience.
@Everyone…
Please don’t fight over music. It is supposed to bring people together, not create hatred.
Spread the message of love and peace through music….
Sourabh:
Thanks for being the voice of reason. All three of them are winners. Each one has touched our hearts at some point with their beautiful rendition of a song.
Aneek with “Sandesha aate hai”
Raja with “Piya Haji Ali:
Amanat with “Tujse Naraz Nahi Zindagi”
One person will ofcourse get the first position via popular voting. Looks like Amanat is leading at this point.
ha yaar sab log chill ho jao! Vote for the person you love the most. That person deserves your vote. Doesn’t matter who says what. And stop trying to convert people. Let the artist’s work stand for what it is and everyone has the right to decide for themselves who their favorite is.
My favorite is Amanat and I love daal chawal( my favorite dish)…if you love biryani..all the power to you..similarly if you love Raja…vote for him! He got inside your heart with his singing..he deserves your vote and if you love Aneek…vote for him!
So, come one guys! We are all here because we love music and that’s bigger than raja, amanat, aneek!!
Respect others and their feelings that are obviously moved by whichever contestant.
“ALL YOU NEED IS LOVE.” -BEATLES
Here enjoy John Lennon’s genius before the grand finale on Saturday!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NzJ2NKp23WU&mode=related&search=
Music, any art form is there to inspire! Simple.
RAJA is a singer of a specific category. He sings Sufi songs well and the songs where high pitching is required. he is not good in lower notes.
AMANAT is the most versatile singer on the show. throughout the contest he tried to let people analyse himself by giving the most versatile performances. He has remarkable knowledge of music and talent as well.
So my vote is for AMANAT. He can really become a successfully playback singer. RAJA can get few songs per year. Bcoz the category of singers he belongs to. We only get 4, 5 good sufi songs every year … RAJA is good for that. But AMANAT really can make his place in top 5 indian playback vocalists.
I request everyone to plz vote for AMANAT and make him a star.
plzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz shut mouth of HR nd let aditya speak a bit….. he is taking the job of aditya
which cant be tollerated…
aneek is a very very nice singer but he will not win u know why? just because of HR
[ I posted this on the wrong comment board again. ._.
So I'm reposting it in the proper location~ ]
Mika and HR on one show? My god, the whole thing would have been completely unbearable if it hadn’t been for the singing.
First of all, Mika is an arse. He has no decency, no sense, no respect, no values, no style (he looks like a baboon’s backside), I could go on and on. As annoying as HR was, Mika was even more irritating (which I didn’t think possible) merely because when HR opens his mouth, at least you can Mute the TV. But snatching the mike from poor Amanat? You can mute the TV, but you can’t stop from seeing that. Amanat had sang so emotionally, only to get his mike snatched away and have his melodious notes replaced by a donkey’s braying?
I hate Mika with a passion; I hope he gets voted off ‘Jhalak Diklaja.’
If there’s one thing that must be said…today was definitely Amanat’s day. I mean, did you see him? He was so focused, and didn’t get side-tracked by all the distractions (what, with the presence of like 22 guests most of them nonentities with nothing better to do) and really delivered smash-hit performances each time. The first and second times he sang, he was superb…and the second time where everyone came up on the stage (without anybody telling them to, mind you…not the case for Raja or Aneek)and began dancing like drunken monkeys, he continued to sing on sur. Where as Aneek was somewhat distracted by Dia Mirza and the 10+ random girls that came on stage and Raja couldn’t resist the urge to dance (that too with Mika the Monkey. Ugh).
But the last performance; my god. God bless Amanat. Not only did he sing perfectly on sur, but the emotion that radiated in this voice, expressed themselves on his face; he was truly singing from the heart and I had to shed a few tears. My parents, who I don’t think are die-hard Amanat fans, rewinded the performance to watch it again (and I shed tears the second time too). He really touched a lot of hearts worldwide, and that is the mark of a true singer.
He was really serious about what he was doing today. Usually he is a bit more lively, and smiling and everything but today he was dead set on what he had to do and he NAILED it. Honestly, I don’t care who wins the damn competition because Amanat is too good for SRGMP anyway, and has already won. Love you, man. (I’m sure I don’t stand alone when I say this).
One thing that sort of puzzles me is how little they promote Amanat in comparison to Aneek and Raja. HR is in love with Aneek to the extent that one could call him gay, and V&S always are eager to call people onto the stage or get Raja to repeat his performance. Amanat has neither of this going for him; ID barely promotes him. I’m not sure how to feel about this; I’m glad that Amanat doesn’t need to resort to cheap tactics to gain votes, but at the same time I can’t help but feel frustrated at the lack of enthusiasm for Amanat.
I suppose it shouldn’t matter; he’s a top-notch singer as well as a very humble human being. But I just get the feeling that the lack of such tactics may be his downfall…
And another thing: I hate ZeeTV for cutting off Amanat’s performance. They don’t mind repeating Raja’s and Aneek’s performances over and over…but the section they showed of Amanat’s didn’t reek even 1/16th of the emotion that was actually present when he was singing the song (what, like four times!). But ZTV made it appear forgettable which I think is injustice to such an excellent performance. AS someone above said, now I almost hate ZTV as much as I hate HR.
Moving onto another topic; what the heck was with all those guests? Why did they bring do damn many? I’m surprised the stage didn’t break when they all were standing there. That too, they asked for opinions from basically every single one of them. They took up more time talking than the contestants did singing.
And did anybody notice at the end where they called up V&S, ID, Amanat, Aneek and Raja on the stage to release the new music album. BUT they didn’t call HR! To add insult to injury, he went on to say that V&S and ID were the BEST music directors in the industry. I admit I laughed that they omitted HR from the thing altogether.
Bottom line(s):
- Mika should be banned from ever showing his ugly face on stage again. His face itself violates the law.
- Amanat is totally underrated, hype-wise. But after the sheer focus and ability he demonstrated today, he deserves to go places.
- 22 guests is overkill.
- Now HR knows what it feels like to be ignored.
Guys another longish post
I type really fast and therefore long posts are not a problem for me…But folks who find it a pain are free to ignore this..After all these opinions are not worth much 
Dear Avinashji:
1> Singers(in Bollywood) are the presentation or face of a composition. When most people hear a song they remember the singer but when discerning music lovers like a song they find out who wrote the lyrics, the composer and other details(some people maintain diaries with these kind of details, I Kid you not)…I am not exaggerating…if you say Majrooh Sultanpuri (who? to most people) to some folks they will go into raptures and name hit after hit…Singers like Lata and Mohd. Rafi have three fantastic traits which so far(Since SRGMP 95) none of the singers(except maybe for Shreya G) have -
a. They have a god given vocal range and truly amazing abilities of vocal modulation (none of the 3 in the current SRGMP are in this category).
b. The nos. of hours of training(like waking up at 4 in the morning and continuing on for 4-5 straight hours) they put in riyaz.
c. Their knowledge of hindustani vocal. I mean they really can discern a lalit from todi (witness Asha Bhonsle educating the mahagurus on the subtleties of aakar and ekar)…
Composers (for example Anil Biswaas modifying for Lata) have modified their styles to utilise these amazing singing abilities. If they have sounded out of this world to you….dig a bit deeper to find out who was actually singing through those voices…and what was it about these voices that made them out of the world.
2> These 3 are not the best SRGMP has thrown up. But as you can see, I was never getting into that argument (I was not saying Amanat is better than Raja or vice versa)…I was just saying that if you like a song and call someone divine…STOP. In my opinion they are decent singers and Amanat is slightly ahead of Aneek. Raja needs to practice some more (I had stated this opinion quite some time back in a post).
3> I think, like I said before, if this song was chosen for Amanat..the choice was made by Ismail Darbar not by Amanat himself(recall a recent episode where ID talks about how he chose Albela Sajan and modified the composition to suit Amanat). There are quite a few good songs in Bollywood and the fact that Aneek and Raja did not choose them reflects on their mentors.
About Mika..his performance was impromptu…Amanat practices his performances for a week or so before shooting. Earlier in SRGMP they used to have a random song where a song would be choosen at random and the contestant would have to sing that…if you see those episodes, you will observe very few people able to carry that round…Mika sings a different style and was singing impromptu…
I hope my points make more sense now. Think of my posts as opposed to the madness sweeping here, where people were suddenly calling Amanat as the next Tansen(who used to make his own compositions BTW) and who had the spark of divinity…About the contest, they are good, but not that good as yet. Read Manik_Mia’s(the time it takes for a singer to get his “Roti” in Bollywood..7-8 yrs is optimistic) and Nagarajan’s comments(about closing your eyes and listening…)
Dear RajK16ji:
Pls. see my comments above. For very good singers like SPji or Lataji or Rafi Sahabji…I would give them maybe more than 30% because the composition gets influenced so much by their unique abilities. It’s said Kishore da used to modify a lot of composition s…sing it differently and get the MD to see his point of view. They were unique and I back Anonji’s comments in this regard. We are talking about mountains and pebbles here…
About Mika snatching the mike, pls. do not be so harsh on him or judge him prematurely. I read one of the posts where someone was explaining that he did that because Amanat was in tears/choked and had difficulty in singing. So Mika jumped to the stage…Maybe this is true, maybe not…the point being we do not know the reason behind it. Mika has made quite a name for himself(in more ways than one) and I am sure does not need to compete in SRGMP for a chance…
I think again you are confusing my point. My point was in context of Amanat being ascribed divine powers…He is a good singer, and in terms of ability, he has sung better than the other two. But, has limited range(high notes…which was immediately pointed out by Mika), had breath control problems and sings in jerks. He also loses sur in quite a few places(maybe intentionally as some advanced music rasika’s might suggest)…
I think, its good for people to know song’s and singers. But, the people who are genuinely interested in music, its imperative to understand that singer’s are the tip of the pyramid…the lyricists and the music directors(also the movie director) are the true heroes/”base of pyramid”. And, that’s the way Bollywood operates…a producer first signs a director then they sign a music director…lyricist and then they search for a suitable voice to fit the context and requirements of a particular composition and not the reverse. Which is why I never understood how they make offers for singers on the sets of SRGMP (In Amanat’s case, if you see, it was Guptaji and young Bappaji who agreed on Amanat for a particular context). In Bollywood, the music directors/composers *RULE*, the singers are second rate citizens.
….You are of course free to ignore all this and focus on the singer and song only. It’s your choice.
Like I said earlier, Amanat deserves to win on the base of his performances till date. But SRGMP(especially) after the public voting system has been mooted, always had a winner who was probably not the best talent. I think this year also Raja looks like he will win by a big margin. If the people in W. Bengal start voting for Aneek, he will be second. Amanat will not get that many votes as the other two will…that’s a fact of life and people can rant about India-Pakistan or whatever.
If Amanat does win however, it would be good and I will be happy that the public voting system has started throwing the right results.
-$0.02Worth.
This is the first in any indian reality show, a singer sang a song three times by the request of all the stars and audiance. Incredible Amanat. No body can touch you… you rocked… no words to express our feelings about your mind blowing singing. Your sweet, soft and sentimental voice touches our heart.
$O.02 Worth,
I think now I got the clear picture of your personality. I was wrong earlier to have thought of you at such high esteem. Anyways, end of the day everyone is a human being including me.
I don’t want to argue with you for anything as you are not at all giving any due consideration to anybody who is replying to your post. You are firm on your opinion so good for you.
Just one thing to say these 3 contestents especially Amanat and Aneek are teenagers. You are expecting from these guys to have fantastic traits and different modulations. If you remember even Pt. Jasrajji said that even today his sur would go wrong some times and for that one must keep doing the riyaz. So, you never know if anyone of these 3 can really become a legend tomorrow by working hard and keeping their riyaz up. You shouldn’t under estimate anyone; you never know how things and people change.
Please give the credit where it is due, don’t simply bring some issues like some people said that Amanat is a legend and for that you are dissecting Amanat left, right and center. If you do the same dissection process to Raja and Aneek you may come up and say these 2 are not at all singers even though they have reached the finals.
People just write anything, you can’t use some point written somewhere by some one to strengthen your argument to say that Amanat doesn’t have different modulations in his voice etc, that is true with Aneek and Raja also at this young age. You also stated that some one had written that Mika snatched the mike from Amanat because he was crying and you are justifying it by saying may be it is true (you are fine with Mika’s actions!!!), how can you blindly take into consideration some statement written by some one in the blog. I mean there is clearly something wrong here, I can’t understand why you are only picking up the portions that you can use to put Amanat down. There are so many people writing so many extraordinary things about Raja and Aneek. Respective fans have called Raja and Aneek also legends many times but you are up behind only to critic Amanat. Why are you not looking for such statements about Raja and Aneek? I am sure you will find a few dozen.
Write what is there in your heart; don’t look for statements which you can use to write to favor what is there in your heart and at the same time trying to show that you are unbiased and neutral. It’s perfectly fine if you don’t want to agree with anyone calling Amanat a legend even I don’t agree with that and in fact no one would agree to that.
But, I can clearly see that you have a soft corner to Aneek (also, Shreya Ghosal so, I really don’t know who is talking). I may be wrong but I don’t really care now. Don’t take me wrong otherwise.
Take care.
@ avinash
yaar dont take tension at 0.02
he is the most dispassionate dissector of music here, i dont think he has vested interest of aneek or any one
he did have one brief phase of temporary im balance when he went out of his way to justify himesh besharmias besharm behaviour as justifiable due to some convoluted logic
lekin sab maaf hai- dont come at me with a machette 0.02 ji!
i have to agree with him about the current 3 tho, amanat is the best singer no doubt of the 3 lekin u can hear him catching his breath between lines of songs..he is NOT a finished product.. i think he is v good at the high and low surs but mussarat was the one guy jiske awaaz sunke, you got goosebumps..
apparently mussarat also has technical issues, and me thinks this whole crop of singers has some shortcoming or the other..raja and onik dont even enter this discussion for me..
him-ass has been v free with using “divinty” to describe his man crush onik’s singing ( what? singing mahi ve or some such non sense).. please dont get carried away with the divinity references..no one of this generation has earned that honor, not even sonu
divinity is rafi saab singing “man tarpat hari darshan ko aaj”
someone upthread suggested amanat was like second coming of Rafi saab.. ludicurous to say the least..
having said all of that, i think amanat deserves to win this title of the 3 ( albela sajan and hangama sealed the deal for me)
lekin , i refuse to participate in this fraudulent voting system jisme you can make hazaaar dummy ID’s and vote for people online, there is no accountability,or transparency.. this is no different from ballot box stuffing or vote rigging seen in up/bihar..
from what i have seen mika decided to randomly come and warble a few lines of the song cuz he just felt like it.. you u cld the other B grade stars embarrased as hell, telling him to back off.. sanjay gupta even told him to basically STFU and let ONLY amanat sing in the encore, so 0.02 ji i find your version of events rather suspect.. from what i have seen of the unedited footage..
no one- and i mean no-one grabs the mic in the MIDDLE of a kids performance just cuz he got emotional? i mean mika ke brains sachmuch uske ghutne mein lagtey hain!
Before, I had posted this comment:
“raja doesn’t just sing kaleish kher & sukhwinder singh songs, he has sung:
tenu leke- sonu nigam
maine poocha chaand se- mohammed rafi
hum the vo thi (when mussarat got eliminated) -kishore kumar
garam masala- adnan sami
ore chori(lagaan)- udit narayan
tu hi re- hari haran
sara zamana haseenon ka deewana- kishore kumar
piya re- nusaret fateh ali khan
hoga tumse pyara kaun – shalender singh
humko tumpe pyar aaya (nirupama’s elimination episode)- mohammad rafi
so raja can sing different songs, not just kaleish and sukhwinder,”
The reason I wrote these sons was also because Raja was heavily praised for singing these songs, u can even check the reviews to clarify this
Anonji:
Thanks for the vote of confidence. Yoou are right I attempt to be non-partisan, unbiased and hopefully devoid of bigotry.
About HR, time will tell. About the Amanat part, for some reason I am not making much headway(people say when elaboration fails take recourse in brevity…and the ultimate form of brevity is silence).
About Mika, I made that statement with appropriate disclaimers…Someone upstairs has made a case for Mika. Saying this happened when Amanat was choked and Mika jumped to the stage with the intention of helping out. I myself have not seen that part…I just saw the first part(how lucky can one get?) and the part towards the end…So me non faux pas
-$0.02Worth.
0.02 ji,
I chose to disagree with you. By the way I am not confused, I am very clear in stating “Singer is the one who steels the heart of the people”.
Vishal said to Raja “your’s is divine voice” after ‘Teri Deewaani” performance. I don’t know what to make out of this statement now with all the dissection going on.
I listen to ‘Afreen Afreen’ song sung by Mussarat almost daily, do I know the meaning of these words? No. Do I really need to know the meaning to enjoy this song? No. It’s the voice of Mussarat that touched me and I am enjoying it.
I know we are heading no where, but I want to make one thing clear I am not discrediting any of the geniuses who write the lyrics. I think I will end this matter here.
Thank you.
AMANATTTTTT IS THE BEST……
VOTE FOR HIM…..
PLEASEEEEEEEEEE….
and im tired of posting here, so ill just support Amanat and not have any arguments.
@ Anon,
Thanks anon, you put me at ease. I will never bother to reply to $0.02 Worth. I am totally irritated.
End of the day this is just a show and we will get to know if anyone is really talented only after a few years. Kunal was not the winner in saregamapa but still he could come up because he had a talent and he is a successful singer now. So, we should calmly wait and see who will be the successfull singer from 2007 saregamapa team if at all there is any.
Thanks once again.
@ RajK
I respect your opinon, as do I everyone elses. Maybe the “blinded” comment was not so much what I meant, thinkin back on it, I dont really remember what my thought process was, but either way I do think music is 20% technicality and 80% emotion and to me Raja has touched my heart and soul numerous times, as he is a stranger to me like evryone else. Again we should all vote for who we love, admire, and appreciate…and for me thats the one and only Raja
P.S. Dayum, i shouldnt even be respondin to ur post, i mean after all you are a SOX fan…eww…how nice it would have been to kick ur butt next round, but hey the era had to end someday…and Torre’s out too…it was def a sad day here in new york…anyway Hate on…hate on…( I will respect ur choice in singer but NOT baseball team)
=)
Hello Everyone
Its true Raja and Amanat both are good singer . Both has gud quality of voice . But Amanat has much control on his voice ! I read all the topic going here by Everyone ..
Well we cant deny this that Amanat is a muslim but and even pakistani. And Raja is Indian.
But I dont think so it does matter alot !
In pakistan You guys tell me . what is the worth of Singer ? This is only Indian Industry who give big break throw to any artist or singer !
See The Comments of all jugdes!
The way he was blessed and honor it was really awesom !
No hard feelings . Im also from Pakistan live in UK . and we here in UK are big fan of AMANAT … Personally I like both AMANAT ANAD RAJA …
But AMANAT is no doubt awesom!
So lets see what gonna happen !
Still if Amanat doesnt win the title… Please behave urself and stay put off !
I also read that someone Said this is not about that Allah/bhagwan make them win .. Only their performance and etc .. Ya true .. But ALLAH / Bhagwan WITHOUT their wishes noone can Win !
So Countdown start …. Accept what gonna happen in FINAL !
In The last: If i have said anythign harsh I appologies and sorry for being that. I WROTE what i feel so !
Allah Neigheban – Namaste – Gud Bye … Be happy and live long …
Jahanzaib
@Jahainzaib
Are you kidding me????
Pakistan’s music industry is amazinggggggg… have u ever heard of Atim Aslam, Ali Zafar, Junoon, Vital signs, Adnan Sami, — all these guys became big in PAKISTAN… i love all pakistan’s music… Call, E.P. Atif Aslam, Ali Zafar.. wowwww… the only reason some pakistani come to india to sing is because India has a worldwide industry. in pakistan when u release an album (it only releases in pakistan). but in india u can release it worldwide.
Hey guys,
I just got to know that top 9 contestants are going to perform on 13th October.
I just can’t wait to watch a performance by Mussarat Abbas, I am so excited!!!
I really don’t care who will be the winner. Mussarat is going to perform and thats all it matters to me.
Enjoyyyyyyyy
btw. if anyone knows. PLEASE tell me that if Raja Hasan is a muslim or not. his name obv. is muslim name, and he says “ammi” “abbu” and “inshAllah” all the time. and says “Allah” a lot. so yeah just wanted to know. nothing big.
shukriya,
Abdullah Abbas
I have been listening to the “Tujhse Naraz Nahin Zindagi” song for over 20 years, both versions, the male version sung by Dr. Anoop Ghosal and the female version by Lata Ji. The original movie was released in 1983.
I am not joining the debate of Raja vs. Amanat (Aneek was never on my list) but I would like to add a comment that Amanat’s rendition of this specific song had lot of “soul” and he made the song his own.
Follow up to my previous post….
Ofcourse, there is Poonam’s performance too.
Mussarat and Poonam are my all time favorites. I think they are favorites to the majority.
Just enjoy.
@CutiePie,
I am not anybody’s fan, I respect all the singers out there; they are all there for a reason. Isn’t it sad to down play a singer after a soulful performance? And don’t forget you too seconded it.
Try to replace “Amanat “ with “Raja” or “Aneek” in that post and you know what I am talking about.
I really feel bad for J Torre, poor guy always under pressure; Steinburner should understand buying some big time players would not fetch a championship always. Seriously, instead of J Torre they should ship A Rod. Hey, we were cursed for 86 years for shipping B Ruth. Now its our time.
Thank you.
@Abdullah Abbas
Raja Hasan is indeed a muslim but people like by enquiring create huckas…YOU SUCK!!!He is great Singer along with Amanat….
Cutie pie..l
Lets not talk to anyone else..looks like people cant face reality of Raja;s talent..lets keep voting for Raja.
Whatever he sang was great, specially Mahi Ve, the way ARA came up on stage and offered a song with a compliment, thats simply great..the compliments of Adnaan Sani, the compliments of Manoj Bajpayee..the are true and meant something..good .
He is in the eyes of Shankar Ehsan Loy where shankar mahadevan is a much refined and very talented singer. ..he knows what he is doing, he will be a very very busy singer and people ga ga about after him after this competition, now there are oppositions, none of these can weaken a real singer right, the roar and applaud after his songs cannot and will not be muted so soon..
Lets hope the best for Raja as well as other singers, after all they also are struggling to run the race..
hey AMANAT, i think u r da amanat of india and i really love u nd ur singing too. u r da winner for me. i damm care about da results so amanat keep rockin as u do naw. for da viewers plz vote AMANAT dont make me cry on da results day plzzzzzz.
WITH BEST WISHES
Aaquib.
@ Guggi
Yes, lets just continue to love and support Raja as we have been doing. He is indeed very talented and i believe he is an amazing artist and has reached hearts all over the world. I agree when such incredible music directors have given Raja work, what more needs to be said. He is accomplishing what he should be: bringing joy to his fans worldwide.
@RajK
I did not mean to speak of the other two singers. I have said over and over that I do think Amanat and Aneek are good, and yes Amanats last performance WAS good, however i did agree with some of what .02 said about it not being that out of this world as everyone has mentioned, again thats only my opinion, but of course everyone can have their own because i know he has touched many hearts as well. Again mine is all Rajas, thats all.
Lets all remember: Music is all subjective…or at least i believe it should be, kind of like the saying “beauty is in the eyes of the beholder”
and Btw, i think Torre is gonna be first and do think Arod is goin right after him. I totally agree, Steinbrennner needs to seriously change the way he approaches this team, i have a feeling this “era” is truely over…sad, very very sad…i miss the Tino Martinez, Bernie Williams Dayz sigh =(
plz guyz just watch this video.what did zeetv do.plz send thiz video everyone.thx
http://youtube.com/watch?v=yg-JI6d3shA
As I have said before, raja ki awaaz mein jaadu aur sachai hai! he’s a rockstar! I just hope he doesn’t end up like karunya- super talented but not ackknowledged in the play back industry, god bless them both!
Chak de Raja!
I HATE ZETV USA FOR DELETING THE BEST PARTS OF AMANAT’S PERFORMANCE!!.THEY SHOWED HISISNGING ONLY ONCE WHEN HE SANG THREE TIMES!!…MAJOR DISCRIMINATION I TELL U!!!.thank u ppl for posting these videos!!..Thanks Alot!!
As of yesterday, Amanat in the lead over Raja & Aneek! Go Amanat! People continue to vote for Amanat and keep doing what you are doing.
You can download all Amanat songs free from –
http://music.cooltoad.com/music/search.php
Search Title by “Amanat – “
Listen to his songs without any visual. Amazing vocalist!! You can just listen over and over again, so versatile!!…from gazal to classical to pop rock to oldies goldies…with his every song he touches your soul…
I also believe he is also a perfectionist. He is always well prepared no matter how difficult the song is. He pours his soul to the song..
I am looking forward to his CD release. I will be the first one to buy
At this point I really don’t care, all we can do is continue voting.
I will be looking forward to Amanat’s and Mussarat’s US concert series and I will be there…
@ raj
are you by chance in beantown? moved here some months ago and have been bombarded by the red sox overhype machine! sheesh.! lol they are still muuch much better than the yanks who r the scum of the earth, basically buying the best players possible and STILL loosing in the first round of playoffs he he .. there is poetic justice afterall.. lekin i am sick of bosox too, they are real chokers, from a 14 game lead to a 1 game lead.. whatever
i am a phillies fan.,,ryan howard rocks!
nehow to answer you other question upthread.. no i dont think “tujse naraaz nahin” was a poonam kind of song, not that she wld have screwed it up , but i dont think her voice wld have suited it.. amanats voice had the silken smooth touch, poonams voice is not silken smooth , which is exactly why i love it, its different and v v powerful..
RE your discussion with 0.02 , i have to agree that singers DO make a huge difference to a listeners visceral response to a song.. but to me this applies more to the greats of the bygone eras, none of the newbies seem to have originality… they r rippin off someone or the other..( except amanat , poonam and even mussarat brings his own take to his “genre”) in other words, if any of the SRGMP contestants come up with their own albums and then they move you with their singing, now THAT wld be an achievement..not when they are singing already established classics
someone said upstream that srgmp kid sameers versoin was better than amanat, that is laughable at best,, that kid shouts his songs..ufff, why even have kids srgmp , with all the politics and drama
and lastly this song” tujse naraaz nahin” doesnnt make me cry.. i have no idea why.. i cry at other songs, like “poocho na kaise maine rain bitayi” or “aaya hai mujhe phir yaad wo zaaalim guzra zamana bachpan ka” and “jeena yahan maran yahaniske siva jaana kahan” i m positively bauling when mukesh comes to the part about ” jab khel mein ham ho na hoon gardish mein tare rahenge sada” and “yeh duniya agar mil bhi jaaye to kya hai” from pyaasa
altho those are great lyrics ( tujse naraz)by gulzar, they dont speak to me personally
Watch Amanat exclusively on rediff.com.
Here is the link:
http://specials.rediff.com/movies/2007/oct/09video.htm
Just listen to him with your eyes closed, it is so beautiful there is no necessity of music.
Divya
Yeah we all will pray , wish and give him a lots and lots of votes..
Karunya was such a wonderful singer , even though he did not get rewarded but still will be remembered..in South India he is rocking conducting beautiful shows..infact his classical music base is too too strong, he sang wonderful songs on a stage show..andhra people will give him a lot of love and support, he is good now.
We all know that Raja is the best , amanat also is good but only after Raja..Raja;s unforgettable spell bound voice , and his devotion , his belief in the almighty, do you observe after every song he songs he just prays silently..this wil give him success and only success all through
Rajji:
I agree on the last part, when rationale meets sentiment, denial is the usual outcome. So, people who have idolized or become emotionally attached will refuse to see reason and that’s a universal phenomenon. I do not post here to convince all of my reasoning. I know that will not happen and its ok to have your view…
If you ever get the chance to observe a recording session, one thing will stand out. The music director usually sings out the notes of the composition to the singer and then asks the singer to sing note by note what has been composed. This is v. difficult and usually done in pieces which are recorded, edited and then stitched together with further processing. Ismail no doubt does this with Amanat…so their goes your theory of improvisation, versatility etc.
So, to make it simple, I will use a paradigm – If you listen to a violin performance and it moves you. You tend to applaud the violinist(Music director) and the composition not so much the violin(singer). Maybe that is a oversimplification but the role of the violin/singer is in being tuned and having a timbre/tone which can enable rendering the composition effectively. Of course a connoisseur you will still value a stradivarius (lata, Rafi, Kishore…) compared to an ordinary violin(An Amanat or a Mika…). I am sorry you feel so hurt by me running down Amanat’s performance as you said in your post.
But a drunk(with liquor/emotion) also complains when you try to sober him up. One has to do what one feels is right.
Avinashji:
I did experience some amusement reading your post.
When you choose not to understand, whether due to an affliction or due to some other limitation, I can only offer my commiserations…
The reason I post here is to express my opinion and defend it in case I have to. I do not post to solicit responses. If you choose to not respond to my posts in the future, it will save me from typing an additional response. That’s all
-$0.02Worth
@ALL
I THINK AMANAT, RAJA & ANEEK THIS THREE DIDN’T FIGHT TO EACH OTHER,
EVEN THEY DON’T KNOW HOW MANY PEOPLE ARE FIGHTING FOR THEM…
DON’T WORRY FOR THEM; THEY ALL KNOW THEIR STATUS, AND PICTURE WILL BE CLEAR IN THREE DAYS.
JUST VOTE FOR YOUR FAVORITE AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE
@lostworld1975
lol i suck???? for what…
@ RajK
We can only laugh out loud now after knowing the truth.
What say you? Good riddance.
Be careful buddy, sometimes it’s better to be a bystander. Majority of the folks are following a policy of ignoring but we learnt our lesson now.
God bless all.
So far I have seen Shekhar is the only Judge who provided good or bad justified comments on all participants.
Can you check how times he said “I am seeing you number one not in this tournament but in this industry”? Can you tell me for whom he said that?
@Manik..
I believe he said that to Aneek.
To all the AMANAT ALI groupies -
Why don’t you say something interesting for a change? You do have (what I suspect) the ISMAIL DARBAR sponsored site where you can group worship AMANAT in breathless escitement without fear of any critical comments, so why hang out here?
Aarusha…
Please try to be ORIGINAL man!!
@anon
Regarding Poonam, after reading your post I listened to couple of Poonam’s songs, yes agree with you, lot of power in the voice.
Discussion with 0.02, my reaction would have been the same if any other’s singer’s name was out there in place of Amanat’s, especially after that kind of soulful singing. Not a fan of anyone, so there is no question of emotional bonding or attachment. I fall into certain category of people who love music but not dwell too much into the details. So for people like me it’s the Singer, I am sure there are lots of people fall into this category.
I couldn’t agree more with your statement.
“if any of the SRGMP contestants come up with their own albums and then they move you with their singing, now THAT wld be an achievement..not when they are singing already established classics”
Nop, moved to BigApple few months ago from Northern VA. I follow most of the sports and it’s in my nature to root for the underdog. Saw enough of Redsox losing to Yanks in playoffs and that made me to root for redsox. 2004 playoff heroics of Big Papi (David Ortiz) against Yanks are still fresh in my mind. Yes, I agree with you they choke lot of times. I like the way Terri Francona manages the team, heard he doesn’t do the micro management especially when it comes to bunting situation, but not sure if this is true.
I really don’t know much about Phillies because I follow MLB from playoffs (regular season (160 games) too much to follow). They made it this time but they got swept. Heard lots of good stuff about your guy Ryan Howard though.
I love running, started with 10K, moved to half marathon, planning one more half next March.
Thank You.
Folks,
Even $hashi who runs this blog agreed to the message by Sandhya which I have posted above and deleted the voting information from this blog which he had earlier posted saying that it is not reliable as there is a live show this time and zee hasn’t leaked its information to anyone. He also said that they used to get the information previously because Friday/Saturday episodes were shot earlier. You can check his mail in the Grand Finale section.
I came across one more post by Sandhya on rediff.com. I can’t beleive people play all such dirty games.
CHEAP GAMES PLAYED
by Sandhya on Oct 11, 2007 02:06 AM | Hide replies
The person named Aanshi who runs http://www.saregamapachallenge2007.com blog is so biased and manipulative.
Firstly, he has posted wrong voting information on his site:
Raja leading by 1 lakh votes
Second is Aneek
Third is Amanat
He is an Aneek supporter and with the above information he wants to push Aneek fans to vote more in the hope of getting him to no.1 position. ZEE has not leaked its voting information to any one.
I sent my message thrice to let people know the truth but he never posted my message. Now, he is writing a bit against Bengalis and Aneek in his own blog just to appear unbiased. So, that people think that he is not biased towards Aneek. He is also deleting few comments all of a sudden now from the blog because he is scared and wants to appear as unbiased and righteous. He is playing all these silly games, shame on him. I challenged him for his behavior; again he never posted my message because he knows he will be exposed very badly.
I am writing it in this blog because I want all of you to be aware of such false information and cheap games played. Just keep voting for your favorites, no one knows the voting information.
Its this person Aanshi who is the culprit and is trying to spread false voting information and at the same time wants to appear neutral and very righteous.
@Sohani
are you kidding me???? why r u being such an idiot and being so ignorant… i said i frikkin liked poonam and sumedha ARE THEY MUSLIM??? NOOOO just asking that if raja is a muslim or not does not mean im gonna start voting for him. im voting for music here and Amanat is the best… AMANAT WILL WIN AND DESERVES to win and he is better than all… and why do u people take everything the wrong way.. i never said anything about the indian industry. im very very very happy that bollywood lets our pakistani artists work for them and help them out. i appreciate that a lot. stop being so ignorant and get out of ur box SOHANI.. u hav serious issues..
“He has done better in these songs than A.R.Rahman; Kishore Kumar; Sonu and all the others!” u also said that… ARE YOU KIDDING ME????
satrangi re and main agar kahoon were sung by SONU NIGAM and he sung them amazingly and aneek tried his best but was no where near Sonu..
Aneek is not going to win.. soo GIVE IT UP.. itll either be raja (because he is leading in voted right now) or Amanat who is an unbelievable singer.. ANEEK WILL LOSE LIKE A LITTLE GIRL and he DOES NOT deserve it.
AMANAT IS THE BEST.. PEOPLE PLEASE VOTE FOR HIM.. HE NEEDS TO WIN… HE DESERVES to win… here is the link to vote. its free, so vote vote vote.
http://saregamapa.rediff.com/poll/index.html
@ raj
i am in agreement ,a large part of response to the musically unnschooled like us, is the sort of intangible indescribable effect it has on you.. even if some of the surs may be out of place.
now i have nothing against 0.02 who seem to know the nuances of HCM a lot more than me.. i learn a lot from him.. but does it make my response or your response at a gut level to a song or its performance any inferior to his ? i think not..
ultimately the way u look at it,, music sld have the power to move u, different things move differenct people in different ways..
i will NEVER be moved by the kind of nonsense heard these days headlined by the liked of himesh reshamiyaa with lots of high pitched nasal braying.. but some ppl love him and swear by him, similarly i hate the kind of songs exemplified by Dhoom2 ( crazy kiya re,, ufffwhat sadela nonsense) and stupid bhangra rock from partner.. now again, some people love em,, and more power to them
i guess what i am trying to say is, that there is no correct answer,,one can have “bikhre ue sur” to quote shekhar and still be a recording artist..
so the value of “emotional response” to music is not to be underrated
mussarat , poonam and some junaid songs did that for me ( and amanat in the ghazal round)
btw, my hubby will be running a full marathon next month, he is in midst of training
lived in philly for 8 years , hence attachment to those perennial losers
@abdullah
Like it or not, Aneek is going to win. From what I hear, there is mass hysteria in Siliguri and Asansol and to top it there is Durga Puja fervor right now, so people are voting en masse in Durga Pandals.
He is deservedly the best candidate.
Why?
Because he sings Sonu like songs. You know at early stage of his career, Kumar Sanu only sang Kishore songs, people said he copied Kishore. He ended by being one of the prolific Bollywood singers.
My question :
1. How many Sonu/Udit/Shaan songs get recorded in a calender year?
2. How many ghazals/classical songs get recorded in a calender year?
3. How many Sukhvider/Kher songs get recorded?
Ratio is 10:2:1 — so Aneek definitely has a better chance breaking in to Bollywood.
Vote For Aneek!!!!
Peace
@SEOLosAngeles
get the thought out of ur mind about Amanat only singing ghazals. he sings ghazals when he is told to. But Amanat has also sung songs like : dil lutiya, Ajab si, Fiza, bijuria, mitwa, mujhko kya hua hai… what about all those songs???? Amanat sings old and new songs. he can sing any song, you name it. Aneek is good but not better than Amanat.. and i dont care what you have heard or what u know, because there is no way u know or can find out who is going to win. according to last week, Amanat was #2, raja was first and Aneek was #3… so yeah.. and U.S.A. is voting for Amanat like crazy.. i have put in more than enough voted for Amanat.
AMANAT IS THE BEST… EVERYONE VOTE FOR AMANAT.. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE.. AMANAT IS GOING TO WIN AND HE DESERVES IT..
o yea and Amanat has already sung 4 songs for bollywood movies. HOW MANY HAS ANEEK SUNG????? 1… so i dont wanna hear it..
Since Amanat is so versatile,
I am still waiting for a good fast song in league of
Dard e Disco (Raja)
Mast Kalander (Aneek)
Still waiting….
Hi, Raja All the Best……I know you are going to win. We all are with you. God Bless you. You are really a good Human and an Excellent Singer. I am Praying for your good future and life. All the other Singers with you are also good. Amaant, Aneek and specially Poonam. She is a Very Good Lady and I love her Voice too. Raja you are the Best. So Pls Win For Vishal and Shekhar. Lots Love. DEEPA.
I have been watching this show the day this challenge start…..I have gone through all commnets which are posted here..most of them are true..I msut say vishal and shekhar are simple best..they not only supprt their contenstant but also support those who are from different gharanas…
I have heard that Raja can only sing sufi/gazal type song..but i donot agree with this..as he show him self how verstile he is..not about amanat thats true he is alrounder..but to be very frank if you have heard preety woman song original..which is far far better then what amanat sung..but overall amanat is good singer..
bout aneek no comment as he os copy cat thats for sure..
now from last episode all of sudden people will take side of amanat and vote for him because his perfomance make guse cried..but what is performance?if his performance make guest cry then Raja’s performance make people happy,make people dance and jsut fill woth power..so depending upond the song they perform very well..
so please think twice before you guys vote..anyhow they are good singer doenot matter they who win this challnege..good people/singer will earn their name..example shekhar …who participate in this cotest lost this..and now he is one of the top music director in this industry….so…donot worry accpet what god desire..so wish you all the best to all contenstants…..this is very genral comments..i am nither agenst amanat nor raja..but i want raja wins…
about aneek..forget it..
@intact info
do u think he gets to pick songs?? no ID picks songs for him.. and what about songs like “mitwa” “koi mil gaya” “dil lutiya”.. give the guy a break he is unbelievably great. MashAllah..
@Deepa
LOL u say HI Raja, win, do this do that. like raja will come to this website and read ur comments. HAHAHHAHAHA.. those type of comments make me laugh. idk why people think that known people will come to little websited and read what everyone wrote. HA
@Verilog_Maan
lol. Performance does not make anyone happy or cry. SINGING does. Amanat was so soulful and amazing in his singing that it made everyone think of their parents, cuz thats what the song is about. as for raja, who cares if he performs. this show is for playback singing talent and when u sing for a movie, performance wont matter JACK. so thats why Amanat is the best and deserves to win.
AMANAT IS THE BEST.. PEOPLE PLEASE VOTE FOR HIM.. HE NEEDS TO WIN… HE DESERVES to win… here is the link to vote. its free, so vote vote vote.
http://saregamapa.rediff.com/poll/index.html
Amanat is Great. Please Vote for Amanat. When I was Hear Song ” Tujhse naraj nahi zindgi” I really impress. Amanat is winner. I Love U Amanat
Hi SEOLosAngeles,
Good comments.
Guys in USA are becoming like Americans; with short memory.
Competition was not for last 2 episodes only.
If you combine all the episodes Aneek has better performances than any one.
But wining is different; any one can win (Especially when you see previous winners of II2, II3 or SRGMP 2005).
People say Aneek copies Sonu. I will say he copies any singer’s song perfectly. It is an art any good singer has to learn.
I saw an interview with Sunidhi Chauhan. She used to learn Lata’s song in her earlier age so much that she can now talk like Lata’s voice.
All playback singers have to learn this trick to be successful in Bollywood. When a singer sings for SRK it should sound like as if SRK is singing.
Sonu, Udit and Kumar Sanu are doing it very well.
WHY DO THE AMANAT ALI FANS HATE IT WHEN THE RAJA HASAN FANS PRAISE HIM …………. THE RAJA HASAN FANS DO NOT PASS BAD COMMENTS TO THE AMANAT FANS WHEN AMANAT IS PRAISED….. WE JUST SAY RAJA IS BETTER THAN AMANAT
raja isnt better than Amanat. Amanat is the best period…
Its funny how people like “Manik_mia” say that it doesnt matter who wins or they are all winners and THEN go on to say this person should win or this person is better than this person. sheesh get a life people. Amanat ROCKS and u know. inshAllah he will win…..
AMANATTTTTTTT ISSSSS THEEEEEE BESTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT
RAJA IS THE BEST AND NOT AMANAT
RAJA WILL WIN
VOTE 4 RAJA
@Any
Hey lets not react to anyone’s comments, let them say whatever they want to , we know what is our objective..Raja should win..thats all and lets do what all we should do for that..
@ RAVI
THATS THE SPIRIT
WE KNOW THAT RAJA SHOULD WIN
AND WE SHOULD NOT STOP VOTING FOR HIM
VOTE 4 RAJA
AMANAT IS THE BEST.. PEOPLE PLEASE VOTE FOR HIM.. HE NEEDS TO WIN… HE DESERVES to win… here is the link to vote. its free, so vote vote vote.
http://saregamapa.rediff.com/poll/index.html
so far me and my friends have give 10,000+ votes for Amanat… and we still have 2 days to go. so theres a LOT more to go..
AMANAT IS THE BEST.. PEOPLE PLEASE VOTE FOR HIM.. HE NEEDS TO WIN… HE DESERVES to win… here is the link to vote. its free, so vote vote vote.
http://saregamapa.rediff.com/poll/index.html
@anon
Well said.
Me too… Nothing against 0.02 or anybody else for that matter. Different people, different personalities and different views, trying to coexist and respecting each other’s views makes this world a better place.
Good luck to your husband; it’s my dream to do the full marathon not sure if I can pull it off. I will do it at least once in my life time. Anyways Phillies are out, pull for redsox.
@Avinash
Yes, we are all humans with certain limitations. If I sense that if we cannot attain some common ground then I try to end the matter with no hard feelings.
Thank you.
Abdullah,
Just lay off man – We love Amanat too. But, your crazy & repeated advertising of him is really putting us off! I don’t think you should be jeopardizing his chances! You can’t coerce people this way…you’ve got to use a better method!!!
DO NOT COMPARE AMANAT TO RAJA IT IS AN INSULT TO RAJA
AMANATS FIRST PERFORMANCE WAS NOT LIKED BY ANY JUDGE
WHEREAS RAJA GOT A STANDING OVATION ON HIS FIRST SONG (MERI ZINDAGI EK PYAS)
SINCE THAT TIME RAJA HAS BEEN BETTER THAN AMANAT
AMANAT HAS BECOME ALMOST AS GOOD AS RAJA ONLY IN THE FINALS ie.TOP 5
RAJA ROX
VOTE 4 RAJA
@ manik and surabi,
He also said this of Amanat, AS DID Jagjit Singh and Jasrat Singh.
From TORONTO, Canada: we are voting for Amanat with 100% confidence that he is overall the most technically proficient and versatile singer of the bunch. If you don’t think so, then your thoughts are largely sujective which doesn’t count for anything when it comes to reaching an ojective decision as to who the winner should be in any competition such as this.
To reinforce the above, you absolutely cannot ignore the comments of Jagjit and Jasrat Singh to Amanat during the ghazal episode.Their definitive/conclusive comments was their public endorsement that he should be the winner.
Their comments can also reasonably be considered a wakeup call to this judging system which uses public votes to determine a winner of the competition. I think the voting has worked well to determine the best 3, however from this point on the winner should corectly be done by qualified music directors/professionals who have objective “ilm” in the art of sangeet.
If anyone watched the Amul Star Voice of India with Khayyam as the guest when they had to decide which eliminated singers come back, even Khayyam adamantly stated that the public should not determine winners. But rather, the ultimate winner should be determined by a qualified group …its just common sense. Whenever the Olympics roll around, competitions are judged by qualified groups right? Right. This should be no different when it comes to the Final 3.
Eid Mubarak to All from Toronto!!!
@ any
‘DO NOT COMPARE AMANAT TO RAJA IT IS AN INSULT TO RAJA’
u seem more a fanatic thn a fan…just because u have ur fav doesnt mean u resort 2 such cheap remarks as to demeaning and degrading other contestants…take a chill pill!each of the 3 have earned a fan following coz of sheer talent..so please stop downplaying other contestants performances 2 bring ur fav up…i personally think Amanat is the man…he has already won a million hearts….so whether he wins sme biased music show is a matter of small significance 2 this genius…
lol vittal,
its not like im saying anything engative. just repeating the same thing and telling people to vote for him doesnt make me hitler.
@ BLUESE 78
WHAT FO U THINK THAT ABDULLAH IS DOING EVEN HE SAYS DO NOT COMPARE RAJA TO AMANAT AS IT IS AN INSULT TO AMANAT
ISINT HE MORE FANATIC THAN A FAN
AMANATS FIRST PERFORMANCE WAS NOT LIKED BY ANYONE
RAJA GOT A STANDING OVATION AT HIS FIRST PERFORMANCE SINCE THAT TIME RAJA HAS BEEN BETTER THAN AMANAT
AMANAT HAS BECOME CLOSE TO RAJA ONLY SINCE TOP 5. AND HAS NOT SUNG THE SONGS VERY WELL (THE SONGS THAT HE SUNG BEFORE TOP 5, ORIGINAL WERE BETTER) WHEREAS RAJA HAS SUNG ALMOST ALL HIS SONGS BETTER THAN THE ORIGINIAL
RAJA IS BETTER THAN AMANAT
RAJA ROX
VOTE 4 RAJA
@any
lollllll yeah right.. im pretty sure u have not watched the show at all…
“RAJA HAS SUNG ALMOST ALL HIS SONGS BETTER THAN THE ORIGINIAL” — that has to be a joke, and i think u r getting a little too attached. its time to take a break.. i mean by the statement u r saying that raja sings better than sukhwinder sing (rut agai re), kailash kher (teri deewani), and nusrat fateh ali khan (piya re)..
i laugh at u when u say raja is better than Amanat or anywhere near him.. it puts a HUGE smile on my face, but again any type of joke or BS does that to me… Raja is a brokeback singer… Amanat is very very unique and versatile ..
so people ONE DAY LEFT… vote for Amanat ALI.. he deserves it…
PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE..
AMEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEN
Hi, namaskar & salamwalekum
yeh massage mai jan buzkar hindi me likh raha hoon kyonki yah program jo hai woh hindi hai aur use dekhne wale sare hindi bhasa ke jankari hai.
meri ray is programm ke prati thidi nagative(galat) hai,
yah programm jo hai woh sara sms ka khel hai. ek SMS ka 6rs. pay karo. yadi TV channel wale ko more then 1crore (10 milioun) SMS aate hai to sas ke jariye unhe sidhi 6crore ka fiyda hota hai unmese sare Ruppes divide hote hai.
Yaha TV producer or Brodcaster & Judges ko koi matlab nahi ki kounsa partiptant jite unhe to sirf SMS se matlab hai.
Doosri ek baat me DAave se puchta hoon ki muze aisa koi bhi ek kalakar batiye jo SMS ke jariye jitkar superstar ban gaya ho. abhitak jo bhi jite hai unmese kitne log film industiers me safal ho paye hai?
mai yah program sirf entertement ke nazriye se dekhta hoon. na inmes koi bhi kalakar Top par nahi pahuch sakta sirf koi daya khakar saal me ek ya do gana gavale.
yane yah sab bakwas hai koi SMS me apna paisa barbad at karo ise bhi ek enterment ki nazar se program dekhio aur bhool jaao.
Agar iska sahi jawab koi de sakta hai to muze mere is email par de sakte hai
anu.mnu@gmail.com
Regards
Anu Manu
@ abdullah
I SAID ALMOST ALL
NOT ‘ALL’
SUKHWINDER, NUSRAT FATEH ALI KHAN,AND KAILASH KHER ARE UNBEATABLE
I MEAN SONGS LIKE
ALLAH KE BANDE
KUDI SAPNE MEIN MILTI HAIN
MAA TUJHE SALAM
NAINA THAG LENGE
TU HI RE
MERI ZINDAGI EK PYAS
CHAIYYA CHAIYYA
ABDULLAH
AMANAT IS A VERY VERY GOOD SINGER
I AGREE WITH THAT
BUT RAJA HAS A UNIQUE AND STRONG VOICE
HE BRINS SOUL IN ALL THE SONGS THAT HE SINGS
AMANAT HAS BECOME ALMOST THAT GOOD ONLY SINCE TOP 5
BEFORE THAT ONLY 1 OR 2 PERFORMANCES WERE OUTSTANDING LIKE RAJAS (FIZA, SAWAN BEETO JAAYE)
RAJA IS MUCH BETTER THAN AMANAT
ONLY 1 DAY LEFT VOTE 4 RAJA
HE DESERVES TO WIN
RAJA ROX
@any
nah.. u r definitely wrong about the raja singing better than original OVERALL.. and just cuz u say raja is better than Amanat, it does not make it true…. Amanat is definitely the best. and if you wanna talk about soul then listen Amanat’s “mitwa” “yeh honsla” “tujhse naraz” “perda hai perda” “hungama hai kyun”… u cant even beat Amanat, the man is just simply amazing and the entire industry would agree with that.. raja is decent but should be rated and is rated #3 with the pro’s… so yeah thats all. Amanat is def. the best..
EVERYONE VOTE FOR AMANAT..
HE DESERVES TO WIN…
PLEASEEEEEEEEE….
SHUKRIYAAAAAAAAAAA
It’s really disgusting how Amanat’s talent is undermined by ZTV. He is by far the most deserving candidate, his last performance was edited so much that viewers in Canada and USA missed out on what a mind blowing performance it was. He was asked to sing the song THREE times, and he recieved amazing comments, which were all conveniently edited out by the producers. It’s sad to see how he is ignored, while Raja and Aneek are hyped. Raja and Aneek are both good singers, but no where near Amanat’s caliber.
Aneek Fans,
Dont waste time on these forums. It is now or never. Concentrate your energy on voting now, and voting often.
Now is not the time to be complacant. With MahaShashthi and MahaShaptami will come the two best voting days for Aneek.
Aneek Rules!
It really doesn’t matter who was voted more, he already is winner mashAllah. May Allah bless him with lot of success in his life . ameen. Thank you india for giving him a chance.
Amanat Pakistan is proud of you.
ABDULLAH
PLS. GET UR EARS CHECKED
IF U LIDTEN 2 RAJA PROPERLY U WILL REALLY SEE THAT MOST OF THE SONGS THAT HE HAS SUNG ARE BETTER THAN THE ORIGINAL
AMANATS MITWA WAS AMAZING BUT THE ORIGINAL IS BETTER
AND HUNGAMA HAIN KYON WAS NOT AS GOOD AS THE ORIGINAL GHULAM ALI IS UNBEATABLE
AMANAT CANT BEAT RAJA
WHAT ABOUT RAJAS
MAA TUJHE SALAM, CHAIYYA CHAIYYA, TU HI RE, NAINA THAG LENGE, PIYA HAJI ALI, MERI ZINDAGI EK PYAS, ALLAH KE BANDE ETC.
RAJA IS SIMPLY THE BEST OF BEST
IT HAS ALREADY BEEN SHOWN THAT RAJA IS BETTER THAN AMANAT BUT IN THE WRONG WAY
RAJA SHOULD HAVE BEEN 1ST
AMANAT 2ND
AND ANEEK 3RD
ANEEK WON BECAUSE HIMASS KEPT ON HYPING HIM EVEN IF HE SANG BADLY AND NEVER LEFT AN OPPORTUNITY TO LET DOWN RAJA
ANEEK SUXX
RAJA ROX
RAJA IS THE TRUE WINNER
Hi Shashi:
These videos can no longer be watched. It says “the content has been rejected”. Can you fix that?
Arup,, YOu have written some Stupid talks, what you think that is wrong, and if this is right then also you don’t disclose it here in this forum.
dear sir plz give me singing chance i am very exited listen you our voice my name khalid gill pakistan now in south korea i belong of christian faimly i hope you do contect with me this is my phon no. 82 1058231588 thanks