Hungama, Tare Hain Barati, Rang De, Kuhu Kuhu, Ni main Samajh gayi, Vande Matram, Dil to Pagal hai, Der na ho jaye – Poonam

Gulabi aankhen, Tere bina nahin lagda, Afreen, Sanware – Musarrat Abbas

Aisa pehli baar – Junaid

Bahon ke darmiyan, Nigahen milane ko, Aaj ki raat, Tere bina Jiya jaye na – Sumedha

Jeene ke hain chaar din – Harpreet

Tumse milke dilka, Chaand mera dil, Jaane jaa – Aneek

Meri zindagi ek pyas, Tu to jaane na, Allah ke bande,

Aankhon ki Ghustakhiyaan – Tushaar (From HR gharana)

I am Poonam’s fan. My favorite singers have always been Asha Bhosle and Mohammed Rafi, with Kishore Kumar, a close second. In Poonam I found the voice clarity of Lata Mangeshkar and the thump, bass and versatility of Asha Bhosle. Other than her, I have never favored any other contestant. However, I do listen to all of them, and appreciate their good renditions. I have all along observed that Besides Poonam Musarrat Abbas has the powerful voice. In present circumstances I would rate Amanat as the better of the trio. Although he looks like Sanjay Dutt from the film Rocky, same “nasheeli aankhen” dhala hua chehra, yet he manages to churn out some very good songs. He has been very consistent and has done full justice to all the songs he has sung.

As far as Raja is considered, he is totally different from Amanat. He is more like Aneek. While Amanat is purely a singer, the other two are performers. In one of the interviews, Vishal has said that they are not on the look out for Classical singer, all they want is a performer, an entertainer. When either of them take to stage they go around doing various stunts, which actually affects their stamina, and thus they cannot deliver with proper surs or taal. However, their onstage activity tend to hide whatever deficiency would be there in their rendition of songs. As for Raja, I will, prefer him over Aneek anytime, as he has got a manly voice. Forget about his forgetting the lyrics, its a non issue, because all playback singers look at complete lyrics chart whilst singing, none of them sing by heart. His voice has great thump, proper diction and pronunciation. Compared to Amanat or Aneek he only lacks in sur especially lower notes, as has been pointed out by Shekhar himself numerous times.

Aneek is also a good singer, makes full use of the stage space, has got good grasp over most of the songs. Sometimes, like Raja, due to being hyper active and unnecessary onstage activity he also tends to affect his sur. What Aneek lack is a manly voice (presently his voice is suitable only for Sachin Tendulkar), lack of emotion or soul (there is no dard in his voice – as he only makes faces, whilst singing without being able to put his soul and emotion into the songs), and not being from hindi speaking belt, his grasp over pronunciation of hindi/urdu words is really weak, diction is also not all that good. He tends to eat words. He is a highly overhyped contestant, a male version of Mauli (though Mauli was worst of all the contestants, and Aneek is a good singer).

Yes, you are right in one point. But in another point he sang very average songs too.
He even was votted out by the Mahagurus once. Those days the guy from Assam (Joy) was singing better than him. Luckily Zee TV introduced Brammastra to give chances to few more people and Raja got in.
So my friend if you want to see the past performances you have to see those too.

I have not seen below average performance from Amanat or Aneek.

Thanks,