Videos of 22nd September Episode of Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenge 2007

Written on September 23, 2007 – 1:21 am | by admin |

Here are videos of 22nd September Episode of Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenge 2007

Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenege 07 – [Episode-42] – 22nd September 07 – Pt01 *HQ*

Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenege 07 – [Episode-42] – 22nd September 07 – Pt02 *HQ*

Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenege 07 – [Episode-42] – 22nd September 07 – Pt03 *HQ*

Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenege 07 – [Episode-42] – 22nd September 07 – Pt04 *HQ*

Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenege 07 – [Episode-42] – 22nd September 07 – Pt05 *HQ*


75 Comments

  • At 2007.09.23 17:29, Avinash said:

    Saregamapa lost its charm when Aneek and Abhijeet joined the show. Abhijeet lost out because he didn’t have sufficient time to build an emotional connection with the audience, seeing that HR has been relentlessly shoving Aneek down our throats. The bias has been obvious and the show has lost many good singers because of this favouritism. If Aneek hadn’t joined the show, HR would not have switched sides and disowned his one time favourite Mussarat. Since that time other gurus like Bappi also started to push singers like Mauli and ID said “mere paas Amanat hai” etc etc. I really wish Aneek wasn’t a part of this show; it would have been so much more pleasant and nicer.

    • At 2007.09.23 17:30, Avinash said:

      The stupid judges and guests of saregamapa
      A few weeks back HR made a few monumental blunders, firstly he emphatically stated that (not once but twice) the viewership of saregamapa is 500 crore!!! and also said that 90% of Tushar Kapoor’s movies are hits!! LOL. As if that was not bad enough this time Kareena Kappor made a hilarious and pathetic statement “Aneek mein tumhe 10/10 nahi balke 100/100 deti hoon”. Miss Kapoor if you remember math from your third grade, you would know that 10/10 is exactly the same as 100/100!!! ROFL.

      • At 2007.09.23 17:31, Avinash said:

        I request all of you to vote for Poonam bearing in mind that she gave a stupendous performance this Friday (kahin aag lage lag jaave), she was the best amongst all the contestants. She was a bit off colour on Saturday but so have other contestants at various other points during this contest. In any case she had a really sore throat. So, we must give her the same latitude that has been offered to other contestants. PLEASE VOTE FOR POONAM.

        • At 2007.09.23 17:41, Rahul said:

          This week belonged to Aneek. I am rooting for Poonam but this was a bad week for her and I will not be surprised if she gets eliminated next week. HR is a Royal Pain but may be Zee TV intentionaly wants to give show controversial for sake of ratings.

          Shashi thanks for posting the show.

          • At 2007.09.23 18:24, Sandip said:

            Among all the contestant Aneek was the best on Saturday. ID and Vishal both agreed on this point. Any body who understands music will agree to it. I feel crowd should not listen to what Himesh is saying. But in few cases his point was supported by others too. For example when Himesh criticised Raja after his first performance, ID supported that. In another instance ID agreed to Himesh on Poonam’s performance — “Beta jab sixer marna chahiye, tune usi samaye bold ho rahi hain..” After Aneek’s first performance Vishal, ID, Kareena all agrred that, it was the BEST PERFORMANCE so far. Amanat sang both the song very good, but he lacked the energy little bit this time. Both Raja and Poonam mesh up in one of their songs. I feel the next week’s result will be as follows. I strongly believe so.

            Aneek,
            Amanat,
            Raja,
            Poonam.

            Again, Zee would love this result too as they would have three contestants from 3 gharanas.. Let us see how it goes..

            • At 2007.09.23 19:08, arezoo_khairi said:

              raja hasan simply the best and deserves to win.

              raja hasan simply the best and deserves to win.

              raja hasan simply the best and deserves to win.

              raja hasan simply the best and deserves to win.

              raja hasan simply the best and deserves to win.

              raja hasan simply the best and deserves to win.

              raja hasan simply the best and deserves to win.

              raja hasan simply the best and deserves to win.

              raja hasan simply the best and deserves to win.

              raja hasan simply the best and deserves to win.

              raja hasan simply the best and deserves to win.

              • At 2007.09.23 19:24, Shafaq said:

                who wants Aneek to be emliminated just so Himesh leaves? He is getting on my nerves, he needs to shush it.

                Amanat all the way! Pakistan Pride! <3

                • At 2007.09.23 19:26, pooja said:

                  I agree with u arezoo….

                  • At 2007.09.23 20:17, zia said:

                    hello everyone..this is my first post on this show…n i m posting this jst becoz of one hurting comment of mr.MURAD….n comment was…”"By chance India may win but everybody knows which is better team. Truth is truth.”"…this type of comments doesn’t make any sense…this show mr murad that allah ne aapko nekki bakshi nahi ab tak….how can u say that pak is better dn india…kya aapki pak team ne india se accha kuch kiya hai…no not at all…n this site is not 4 making such type of thing…people like u alwaz waiting for such chance so u people can write anything anywhere…..n its a humble request to this site honor u shld keep watch on this type of post n stop it to teach a gud lession to people like mr.murad….n india jeete ya na jeete india alwayzzz best 4 us….n if u think that may b india will win dn u hv a fear….n when sumbody weaker dn only fear comes to his or her mind…..so it shows us wat u think abt ur team……
                    n guyz i wish that amanat n raja will go 4 final fight…n wish gudluck to both of dm..

                    • At 2007.09.23 22:35, 0.02Worth said:

                      Dear Dockaul agree with you totally. About Aneek.

                      Dear Senty agree one tends to get blaise, I am jaded too.

                      Dear Harsh and Raw, agreed. Music composers are plagiarists not composers. In fact I doubt whether people know what process to follow for composing :) and to what end as well as the pride one has on one’s own compositions.

                      Music as defined by these gurus is a commodity a stepping stone for material possesions.

                      I guess I better stop before I come across as a raving ranting idealist :) )

                      But, I happen to agree with all of you including Anon and Sumitro who were talking about singing being secondary to casteist and other ego-centric bias. :(

                      What to do ??

                      -$0.02Worth

                      • At 2007.09.23 23:02, Jinan said:

                        WOWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW……….ANEEK……….WHT A BRILLIANT JOB………..

                        WHT A GR8 JOB!!! V HERE…HAVE STARTED BEIN UR FAN AFTER…UR YAA AALI…SONG…

                        DUDE..UR CONFIDENT, HARDWORK, PERSONALITY….U R BLESSED SINGER..AND GONA BE THE CHALLENGE FOR THE BOLLYWOOD’S TOP SINGER…KEEP MY WORD….U GONA ROCK..THIS WORLD…..

                        HR U SUCKS….DON’T ADVERTIZEN ANEEK…HE DOESN’T NEED IT!!!

                        HE IS TRUE ROCKER…LET HIM ROCK ;) …….LOVE U ANEEK..

                        JINAN

                        • At 2007.09.23 23:24, TRUPTI said:

                          Please Saregamapa, it is hearty request to you, Please stop Himesh nonsense and the way he is trying to disappoint Raja. Now, even Ismailji has started doing the same. If this doesnt stop, then truly public will stop watching such kind of shows where mentors themselves are partial. Public is not mad.We can take our own decision, please tell Himesh to keep his advice with himself. We really like throwing eggs & tamatoes on Himesh when he starts speaking. Please convey my message to Himesh to stop cursing Raja oe else it will be very bad for him.

                          • At 2007.09.23 23:26, Jinan said:

                            @DOCKAUL & 0.02worth

                            Totally disagree abt…Aneek….let me count his best performs excepting this rocking Sunday performances…

                            Yaa AAli,
                            jane kya chahe…man…
                            Chand mera dil,
                            Dil se,
                            sandese aate hain (completly sonu voice)
                            kawali: tum se mil ke dil ka jo…..

                            dude..If he wouldn’t have rock…he would not have been stayed in final 4!!!!!!!! He rocked saturday evening….and he doesn’t need ne proof….he rocked many times…

                            and again abt HR…he sucks!!!…Aneek without ne mentor…deserves 2 be in the final!!!

                            let kick HR…but Aneek deserves 2 b in the final..and he will….keep rocking..

                            Jinan

                            • At 2007.09.23 23:36, Gaffar said:

                              @dockaul
                              Thank you very much. I am a very regular person.Just remember me in your prayers.

                              Thank you
                              regards
                              Ghaffar Khan Peshawar/Pakistan

                              • At 2007.09.23 23:44, jesse said:

                                To the Aneek haters.. all i have to say based on sur and voice quality he is the best singer on the show… but dont put him down or say u want him out becasue of himesh.. Himesh is an idiotic person who needs to no wen to shut it… i also hate the way he hogs the mic all the time and acts like hes the worlds greatest.. soo
                                VOTE ANEEK and RAJA!

                                • At 2007.09.23 23:49, ahmed said:

                                  hr is a total asshole he sucks so plz vote out aneek bcz he deserves dat ………his performance was ok but not the best amanat n raja were much much better than him plz vote out aneek i hate hr n his backwaas comments abt raja RAJA ROCKSSSSSSS

                                  • At 2007.09.24 00:33, Sumitro said:

                                    anon said…
                                    ["bhai, aur log kuch bhi kahen, hum to ussi to pasand karen ge jo accha gayega,,, chahe woh teheran se ho ya timbuktooo se ya toronto se( ya texas se!).. sangeet mein koi boundaries nahin!
                                    music is no place to be expressing fake jingoistic patriotism...agar itna hi pyaar hai desh se , to jaaker desh ke gareeb or pichde hue logon ke liye kaam karo.."]

                                    dear anon ji… aapne yeh laakh rupaye ki baat ki… but these priceless words r only useful for those naive ppl frm a part of the hoi polloi (aam jantaa) who regard these musical shows as battlegrounds or sporting grounds.

                                    btw…once u laughed at me… when i called u ‘mate’… y cant u b a ‘mate’?
                                    ‘mate’ is gender-neutral.

                                    thnx

                                    • At 2007.09.24 01:55, Suzie said:

                                      Like most comments made here, I totally agree that Mr HR keeps his mouth shut.

                                      Everyone have a right to their opinion, let them speak instead of HR pulling the mike from them or poking his nose in to say something about his not so talented aneek.

                                      And Zee TV better wake up and end his contract before its too late.

                                      Kudos to Adiya, he’s a wonder to watch.

                                      • At 2007.09.24 02:41, moneymaker said:

                                        It seems like they want Aneek to win. Aneek sucks! He has yet to sing a hard song. True singer of this show is Amanat but we all know he is not gonna win for the obvious reason. I rather have Poonam win any day anytime over Aneek. Aneek is starting to make me sick!

                                        • At 2007.09.24 03:29, shoyeb said:

                                          hey guys cum on yaar
                                          y do treat aneek as his guru.
                                          i accept that himesh is making too much fun of him but yaar his singing is beautiful…….
                                          everybody looks at the negative side but no one looks at his positive side………
                                          dont look at his so called love just look at his singing……….
                                          so cum on cheer up & vote for aneek’s singing.

                                          • At 2007.09.24 03:45, Nitesh said:

                                            Hi guys

                                            I got a real good news for you people. I got it from one of saregamapa’s coordinator.

                                            Right now Raja is leading with 3768543 votes. Which is a record in saregamapa’s history. So he will be no 1 again.

                                            Amanat in second position.

                                            Poonam in third position.

                                            At last Aneek will out of the show as well as his mentor. Right now he is struggling to get third position. He is 143585 votes behind.

                                            Vote for Raja.

                                            Enjoy…..

                                            • At 2007.09.24 06:42, serenity said:

                                              nitesh!!!!

                                              how do you know this???

                                              is this true???

                                              omgomgomg….pleasepleaseplease let this be true… poor aneek but at least we won’t have to see Besharmiya (go to http://www.besharmiya.com – it rocks)
                                              And his horrible cheap antics on the show.
                                              and aditya will also get a chance to speak and wont be treated disrespectfully. did anyone noticed when aneek and kareena were together aditya went up (it’s his job, he’s the host!!) himesh DRAGGED him by his arm away.
                                              maybe he would be worried that ppl would look at aditya instead of aneek.
                                              i mean who wouldn’t???

                                              seriously HR is the worst mentor EVER man. shamelessly promoting aneek. why does aneek always perform last anw?? so that hr and all the guests can start singing/dancing with him on stage like he’s the best thing since sliced bread???

                                              • At 2007.09.24 07:25, noel said:

                                                Thanks to Vishalji always from the beginning his judgment is right and correct. He is no partial for any contestant. Its proud to see him in Zee TV Saregamapa.

                                                • At 2007.09.24 08:15, anon said:

                                                  dear sumitro

                                                  i wasnt laughing AT you but laughing WITH u, big difference :)

                                                  “mate” as used in australia , NZ and england is similar to using ” buddy” in the US

                                                  perhaps in india it is gender neutral..

                                                  hope this helps

                                                  anyhoo, its not a big deal to me me..u can use any form of greeting, it is a free world,cheers

                                                  • At 2007.09.24 13:37, Sheraz said:

                                                    The show was nice because of Kareena and ofcourse Amanat’s performances were absolutely rocking. HR was the bad element in the show and hated when he was trying to prove about ANEEK is best and Raja, this is not your best performance. I think Raja was much better than Aneek.
                                                    1…Amanat
                                                    2…..Raja
                                                    3……Aneek
                                                    4…….Poonam

                                                    • At 2007.09.24 21:16, Amar said:

                                                      To Sandip and Sheraz :

                                                      First of all, you are wrong when you say that Poonam was off color this week, her Friday performance (“kahin aaah lage lag jaave…from Taal) was STUPENDOUS !! Please be honest and let me know if this is wrong.

                                                      She had a very bad sore throat this last Sat., that is why she was a bit off color in both the songs. One could make this out when she was speaking (not singing) on the mike and that is why both of her songs were 99 %, otherwise it is really very rare to see a top 4 finalist and especially a gifted singer like her to be a bit off color in both songs.

                                                      She and Amanat are the ONLY singers who have no style, they can sing any type of song and anyone’s song.

                                                      Just my opinion and I hope you agree. It would be unfortunate and heart breaking that someone who is sick (very sore throat) is eliminated due to his/her sickness. It would be kind of like Sachin Tendulkar or Imran Khan can never play as they had bad muscle ache in one of the matches.

                                                      Regards,
                                                      Amar

                                                      • At 2007.09.24 21:17, Amar said:

                                                        To Shafaq :

                                                        Please keep “Pakistani pride” out of this forum. This is a musical talent show…I am Indian and I am rooting for 1. Poonam and 2. Amanat…and loved Musarrat.

                                                        Amar

                                                        • At 2007.09.24 21:30, Amar said:

                                                          Folks :

                                                          Before I say anything, my apologies to Nitesh if I am wrong. But I think someone may be deliberately saying that he/she has inside information that Aneek is the last in voting just to make sure it spurs his supporters to vote for him.

                                                          I have nothing against Aneek, he should win if he is the best but thought of mentioning this.

                                                          • At 2007.09.24 21:51, chirag_desai said:

                                                            Let me make it clear first; FANTASTIC PROGRAM, FANTASTIC SINGERS, FANTASTIC PERFORMANCES. Its great to know and hard to believe soo many good singers took part in one competition. I have never witnessed anything like it. THOUGH, SHAME about certain judges who have been simply selfish about the whole approach to support their singers. HR has really let this show down lately with his antics. We dont want to see you or hear you, the stars of this show is not you, its the singers! I never comment on these blogs, but it came to a point when I felt a necessity to show my frustration and I know there are plenty more who feel this way. HR is very bullish about the whole approach and his constant behaviour of pointing fingers towards Raja is very unprofessional. Obviously he sees Raja as a major threat, there is no doubt. Its also a shame cuz I do feel amongst this galaxy of fantastic singers Aneek is very special, BUT I declare NOT TO VOTE for him this week because of constant annoyance of HR. Mr Reshamiya if you feel you are helping your singer, who indeed is special, you are WRONG; matter of fact you are ruining his chances to win to a major degree and you just need to read comments of people on here to understand it. Please stop interfering in every single issue, we dont want to hear you, let the real stars of saregamapa show their talent!

                                                            • At 2007.09.25 10:12, V said:

                                                              I really think HR is the worst judge. He has completely forgotten that he is sitting there just to pick out a best singer among all, but not to show some stupid partiality on Aneek. I agree aneek is a very good singer but i dont understand why he doesnt act like a good judge like Vishal. Coz, even Vishal has a ultra cool singer and still he doest show partiality every time. He treats every one the same.
                                                              I think some one should warn HR no to be so stinky in the show as he may spoil Aneeks career.
                                                              Best Singers:
                                                              1. Amanat.
                                                              2. Aneek , RAJA
                                                              3. Poonam.

                                                              Guys u have to agree that Amanat, Aneek and Raja are better singers than poonam. I dont say she is not good. She deserves all good. But, time has come that she is not better than the other guys.

                                                              • At 2007.09.25 11:26, Amar said:

                                                                Dear V,

                                                                I respectfully disagree. Aneek and Raja both have had many bad days and both have a style. Poonam has never had a bad day except last Sat. when her throat was very sore, one could make that out when she was just speaking to ID. She can sing any type of song and any one’s song. I really like raja but he has never shined outside sufi type of songs…..just remember Poonam’s songs from the beginning and you will see what I mean.

                                                                • At 2007.09.25 11:30, Amar said:

                                                                  All :

                                                                  Let’s not forget, if Poonam had a off day Sat. (Sept. 22), BOTH Raja and Aneek had bad days on Friday (Sept. 21). I know public memory is short and usually people just remember last performance, let’s be just and remember Poonam’s Friday performance of “Kahin aag lage lag jaave..from Taal”. If she should be penalized for her Sat. performance, Raja and Aneek have to be penalized for their Fri. performance.

                                                                  Last, and most importantly, Poonam had a very bad sore throat on Sat. Raja and Aneek didn’t have that on Fri. and even they they didn’t perform well.

                                                                  • At 2007.09.25 12:55, roselind said:

                                                                    plzzzzzz ppl plzzzzzz vote 4 POONAM

                                                                    shes such a gud singer….luk at the way she sung “kahin aag lage lag jave” frm taal”

                                                                    if she was off colour in da songs at sat. dat doesnt mean shes a bad singer …shes such a cool singer…itz only bad throat… wat can she do????

                                                                    n yeah if anyone noted in her fridays performance wen ID was praising her(sayin she had sung da high note of the song v well) she said 2 him(nt on mike) “bas kijiye sir” n then she bowed b4 him…
                                                                    dis shows she doent need hype or sympathy …she need 2 b judged as a gud singer…

                                                                    plz vote 4 poonam plzz its a request…don’t let her go away,

                                                                    n yeah HR sucks ..hes too rude..imean he pulled adi away wen he went on stage while aneek was singing! huh

                                                                    i don’t say aneek is a bad singer but i hate HR’s way of promoting him

                                                                    • At 2007.09.25 15:37, V said:

                                                                      Dear Amar,

                                                                      I completely agree with your answer.This was just my personnel opinion. And i am sorry if i have hurted any ones feelings. May be Poonam is not very well on this episode but, i personally feel though she is a fabulous singer, her voice doesnt suit for all the songs.
                                                                      I myself voted for poonam too but, I feel other singers left in this show are fabulous and will be able to perform on any kind of song given.
                                                                      I think the sequence of elimination in this show is just perfect as people are choosing the singers as per their talents. Atleast the voting is not as in indian idol. The worst singers become Indian idol every year.
                                                                      This is a great show and i request each and every one not to show any partiality, listen to the singers with your heart and may the best singer win.

                                                                      • At 2007.09.26 06:30, V said:

                                                                        All:

                                                                        What is the drama going on in SAREGAMAPA? How come suddenly she has a daughter now….. Common, i dont think atleast i can believe this.Even if we say there is adopted daughter why is she on screen today? Only for Votes? This is very very bad. I just lost belief in this show.
                                                                        Too Too bad..

                                                                        • At 2007.09.26 08:07, Tansar said:

                                                                          *****This is for Music Understanders only*****

                                                                          Listen to Rajas performance on 22nd, in the Omkara song, In beginning he lost sur, and no one in the mentors, I mean, no one pointed that out. It was so so obvious. Even, Vishal/Shekhar stood and wistled at the end. I mean, this is too much, this is just favourism and Hypism.

                                                                          Please please, just listen carefully.

                                                                          • At 2007.09.26 09:38, Sahibzadah Khan Ghaffar said:

                                                                            @Tansar
                                                                            It’s prescripted. Everything is written by ZeeTV beforehand. It’s not about music. If it were ,Mussarat and Poonam were there. How many bad performance Aneek and raja gave? Forgot “pardesi”? it’s just one example. There are many for two of them. They eliminate Poonam and Mussarat on much better performances. so if you are trying to establish a relationship between singing talent and the those who qualified, I am sorry there is none. You and I can go and sing and if we can get more SMS’s we can win. Nothing to do with talent whatsoever.
                                                                            Don’t waste your time They will do whatever will bring money to ZeeTv. Rest doesn’t matter.

                                                                            Ghaffar Khan

                                                                            • At 2007.09.26 09:45, Tansar said:

                                                                              ^ I think you are right…

                                                                              Tansar

                                                                              • At 2007.09.26 14:20, Avinash said:

                                                                                Folks, you would be surprised to see that Poonam has an adopted child, Simran, who is 6 years old. Poonam adopted her 4 years ago when she was 22 years old and Simran was 2 years old. Hats off to Poonam, she is a true winner in life irrespective of what happened in saregamapa. She truly has a heart of gold and has truck loads of spirit and guts. She will serve as an inspiration to all of us.

                                                                                After reading this, my hatred towards HR has increased many folds, he is such a cheap and characterless person, just to keep Oink in the competition he shrewdly manipulated the voters to vote out Poonam. HR and Ismail were more bothered about Oink’s staying in the competition than requesting voters to consider Poonam’s past performances while voting. Everyone knew she had a bad throat, so its just not fair to vote her out based on that one day’s performance.

                                                                                My best wishes and prayers will always be with her.

                                                                                • At 2007.09.26 18:01, Soumya said:

                                                                                  If it is true, it is a big-hearted thing of Poonam to do (and I can really believe she would do something sweet like this) BUT
                                                                                  I’m very afraid this is yet another cookup to win votes. How convenient to suddenly have a daughter. And of course adopted otherwise she would be unmarried mother, which would be bad for votes.
                                                                                  But talentwise i LOVE Poonam so nuff said, I don’t mind, she can win

                                                                                  ~~ Soumya

                                                                                  • At 2007.09.26 18:03, Soumya said:

                                                                                    (…and I do mean a cookup thoguht up by the Zee makers, not Poonam herself)

                                                                                    • At 2007.09.26 22:42, Avinash said:

                                                                                      @ Saumya,

                                                                                      Unfortunately Poonam has already been eliminated so there is no question of cooking up stories to seek votes. This information has been disclosed after Poonam’s elimination this week.

                                                                                      • At 2007.09.27 06:26, rashi said:

                                                                                        himesh talks 2222222 much…

                                                                                        • At 2007.09.27 12:59, Soumya said:

                                                                                          @Avinash

                                                                                          Nooooo…are you serious…. I did not know this spoiler….. :( :( grand injustice to throw her out :(

                                                                                          • At 2007.09.27 13:46, ibban said:

                                                                                            RAJA IS BEST ALL WILL B STRUGLING SINGERS ACCEPT RAJA AS HE HAVE A GOOD QUALITY VOICE HATS OF TO RAJA HASSAN

                                                                                            • At 2007.09.27 23:56, nil in circle said:

                                                                                              Dear Saregamapa show Managing committee…

                                                                                              pls stop HR from givin lectures. is he tryin to proof somthing? is he goin to POLITICS ? Is he tryin to get everyonez attention ? MR HIMESH we love your song Man..you hve good quality of singing..But plz stop your IDIOTIC melodrama act on stage. Man In future pplz would know as TALKATIVE beside your singin carrier..which one would u choose A Talaktive Master or the best of HR ?

                                                                                              pls STOP Puting your NOSE on everything…Public dont like this man..c’mon

                                                                                              Truly
                                                                                              Nil
                                                                                              USA

                                                                                              • At 2007.09.28 10:18, Jyothi said:

                                                                                                Jyothi…..seriously i swear dis HR and aneek are really getting into my nerves also….i just cant stand both of them now…i just change wen aneek is performing and wen dis stupid idiotic HR is going to comment on annek’s performance…he is too much…i did not like any of his perfomance on dat day….infact raja was too gud in first round….cant v just put celleotape on dis idiotic HR mouth wen he is going to speak n specially wen he says bad about raja and praises aneek for no reason…did u guys notice wen at d end of d show wen all of them came to stage after aneek’s 2nd performance HR just pulled aditya out of d frame of aneek and kareena…i just felt like slapping him….n he is so cheap he was asking kareena to say gud about aneek praise him n all he really sucks man…..he is too much….i just hope and pray that he shud not win this lets vite for raja and amanat……

                                                                                                • At 2007.09.28 15:46, Nikita said:

                                                                                                  Looks like I accidentally posted this in the wrong episode comment board, so I am reposting it in its proper location:

                                                                                                  Well, what a drastic change. Last week’s posts were all defaming Aneek, saying that he should be out because he plays along with HR’s antics. This week we find the total opposite; everyone is saying not to blame Aneek for his mentor’s behavior. I find this a bit ironic, to be honest. Its not that I disagree; yes, indeed, Aneek is a high-quality singer and HR is the only one to blame for the blabbering. I’m just curious as to where all these Aneek supporters were last week when everyone was bashing him.

                                                                                                  I love, LOVE what Vishal said to HR after Aneek sang; HR reported that Raja was good, but it wasn’t one of his best performances. And what did Vishal do? Shot it right back at him and told him that Aneek sang well, but it wasn’t his best performance either! It takes a lot of guts to do something of that caliber, and instantly I have regained lots of respect for Vishal. Hats off to him for giving HR a much-needed slap in the face.

                                                                                                  Poor Shekhar was ill, I believe. Hope he feels better soon. (Funny how all the Shekhar fangirls have stayed remarkably silent about that ). If only HR was sick and HE left for a few weeks. That would result in a huge party by all SRGMP viewers across the globe.
                                                                                                  (While I was watching this episode with my family, my father turned on the ‘MUTE’ button every time HR opened his trap.)

                                                                                                  HR is clearly insecure (as the very wise people before me have already shrewdly pointed out). He fears Raja the most, due to his initial popularity and the enormous amount of support of Vishal and Shekhar, the REAL ‘gurus’ on the show. He is insecure about Poonam, and rattles on about her family life to prevent people from voting for her (what a disgusting, manipulative git that HR is.) And he is even insecure about Amanat! How? The proof is in this very episode!
                                                                                                  Remember in Amanat’s performance, Vishal (so graciously, even to someone other than his own contestant) said that if Kareena wanted to dance to his ‘You are my Soniya’ she could (and she did). And what exactly did HR do? He TOLD them to replay Aneek’s track so he could sing it AGAIN and he TOLD Kareena that she should go up on the stage with him. If that wasn’t enough, when Aditya went up onto the stage to join them, you can clearly see HR pulling (JERKING) him back!! I don’t know about you, but such crap really makes my blood boil.

                                                                                                  As for their performances:

                                                                                                  Amanat: his first song was very good, I really loved it. Amanat is clearly a singer who can sing a variety of songs, from fast paced to solemn to love songs to patriotic. His second song was good; but it wasn’t spectacular. He could have sung it a lot better I feel. But you have to admit; he radiates some kind of charisma…doesn’t he?

                                                                                                  Poonam: Poor girl was ill, so naturally she didn’t sing very well. Her second song was a poor selection I feel; even if she wasn’t ill, I don’t think she would have sung it all that well because her voice isn’t suited for the song (Sumedha’s voice is, however, as somebody already mentioned above). I certainly hope she isn’t penalized and doesn’t get out…

                                                                                                  Raja: He sang solid performances, I think. Nothing horrendous, but nothing mind-blowing either. His Omkara wasn’t as excellent as everyone said it was…Abbhas sang it in SVO quite a long time back, and his rendition was brilliant. Raja’s attempt pales in comparison to that performance.
                                                                                                  Vishal said that ‘Raja is back’ but I don’t think he’s back in ‘full throttle’ yet. Perhaps nervousness is what is making him more subdued, but I can’t help but miss the old “Vande Mataram” spirit he displayed when he sang that song in the Patriotic episode.

                                                                                                  Aneek: He did so very well today, especially the last song which is one of my favorite songs. I would think so much more highly of him if HR wasn’t hyping him so much. HR is making people hate him as well as Aneek by showing a clear lack of modesty and decency. He is also displaying lack of a central nervous system (read: his brains have gone missing).

                                                                                                  I CAN’T BELIEVE who got out! HR’s antics…they can’t be WORKING, can they!? I certainly hope not! Then we all know that Raja will be the next one to go. That’s probably his plan; eliminate Poonam and Raja, and leave Amanat and Aneek in the finals because he feels that Amanat can’t win anyway.

                                                                                                  In short, HR is an imbecile.

                                                                                                  • At 2007.09.28 15:53, anon said:

                                                                                                    welcome dear nikita to the HR haters club. I am your president .

                                                                                                    We have some v active members like anonymous and rekha ji :)

                                                                                                    lekin, his pulling off Aditya from the stage so that Kareena could dance ALONE with his precious chela, yeh to budtameezi ki had ho gayee..Lekin jab people wanted amanat to encore his “soniya”, this man totally ignored them..

                                                                                                    kuch sharam karo besharmiya! totally classless pathetic individual

                                                                                                    • At 2007.09.28 16:04, anon said:

                                                                                                      mussarat would have killed in this round, i agree

                                                                                                      i leave u with this to savor

                                                                                                      http://www.esnips.com/doc/d1dbff30-81fa-43ee-b56b-438c89bee0ce/Chal-chal-mere-sang

                                                                                                      • 25 old comments are not displayed. Click to display all comments