*** This Week Spoiler ***
Here are the spoiler results for this week…
Sumedha Karmahe is Out
Also, today I have received reply from Zee Telifilm Ltd. regarding the petition and sentiments of viewers on ‘Love Drama’. If Sumedha is voted out, then we can pretty assume that Zee TV has stopped Vote Rigging. And also hope that this love dram will stop …
This week’s themes
Friday – Stage Songs
Saturday – Solo songs and Duet songs (Kareena Kapoor and Randhir Kapoor are the guest of honors )
This Saturday, there will be only 4 challengers remaining, every contestant is going to sing two songs each..
Those who support Mussarat.
Nothing is there only in discussion.
Some ppl feel he is out as he is pakisthani. That’s wrong.
First thing if that wud hav been the case why so many Indian singers voted out before him.
Second thing still Amanat is there being a pakisthani. About him I can say he deserves to in top two. I wnt mind if he wins.
Third thing where u ppl were then when they were in Pakistan. Zee find out the talent. You sud thank to them as Mussarat did by himself.
Fourth thing the singers like NAFK,Bhimsen Joshi,Gulam Ali,Jagjit Singh(No doubt they are gem) is not so pplr as our main stream playback singer. So chance of Mussarat success is also less.
At last Mussarat got enough exposure through Zee Saregamapa. Let him be pplr in Pakistan then India comes later. No need to forcefully make someone to buy his songs. Specially criticizing others without any musical reason.
If then also someone dnt understand the simple reason then I m sorry. It’s my mistake trying to make understand some biased orthodox public.
@michael
I m frm Pakistan. I think Aneek is the best singer then Poonam. He better than Amanat. He is more versatile than Amanat. He is not immature Sonu. He sang different singers song also like Manna Dey, Kishore, Rafi, Zubeen, Rabbi Shergill and many more. He sang three punjabi songs “Bawa mein payar karke”, “Bulla ki jana mein kaun” and “mast kalander” of different singers. No doubt in his versatility. And dnt forget some day Sonu was immature Rafi sahaab.
So first u dnt be biased then suggest others.
Get a life. Get well soon.
HI,
IF U R HR FANS AND IF U WANT TO LISTEN TO HIS CRAP COMMENTS THEN U’LL VOTE FOR ANEEK, IF U LOOK AT SINGING THEN U WILL VOTE FOR EITHER AMANAT OR RAJA B’COUSE THEY ARE THE BEST SINGERS & THESE DESERVED TO BE IN FINAL TWO. AND WE CAN HEAR SOME GOOD MUSIC AND SONGS IN FINALS THEN LISTENING TO HR STORIES , SO PLS GUYS VOTE FOR AMANAT AND RAJA THIS WEEK AND MAKE ANEEK ELIMINATED.
@rajan,
i must say that of all your 5 “things”, the fourth one took the cake. The third was a bit on the rude side as well (shouldn’t we be polite to our neighbors?), but hey the fourth one…that’s a gem. To quote you, ” Fourth thing the singers like NAFK,Bhimsen Joshi,Gulam Ali,Jagjit Singh(No doubt they are gem) is not so pplr as our main stream playback singer. So chance of Mussarat success is also less.”
To say that the likes of Bhimsen Joshi, Ghulam Ali, NFAK etc. are not popular…hmmm…maybe i’ll take that with a pinch of salt assuming that you mean being popular with the “aam janta”, the mass without a refined musical taste, and nothing against that. Dude, I’m sure you’ll have only remix cds to back up your musical taste. Anyways, but to say that they are not successful is so ridiculous it’s actually funny, you know it’s like you’re comparing Archies with Shakespeare.
But one thing I will thank you for if putting Mussarat into the league of these singers, and not your so called popular and successful playback singers.
@shamimur,
This might be totally out of context here but I just wanted to mention something that might help you get over naughtysq’s baseless and hilarious comments…he must be a ghoti! sorry, others won’t get this, but i’m sure you will. I wouldn’t have brought it up on a musical forum as this one, but some people really know how to make you!
@senty
i agree with you, senty, that given all the drama and circus, the singing talent here on this show is by far the best. the others look like a joke in front of it.
@aish
Me also don’t like HR comments. But as far as singing concern Aneek is best to me. Amanat and Raja is ur personal choice. I have no complain with that. But u have problem with Aneek’s supporter. I also like Amanat after Aneek. But I will never say eliminate Amanat or Raja. It’s like one may believe in Hinduism but can’t say muslims are wrong or vise versa. I m ready to say India jindabad but will never say Pakistan murdabad. Hope u got the point.
@aish
One more thing. Don’t think only you understand music. Others are fool. Don’t give excuse of musical reason.
You are die hard fan of Raja. It’s natural you will fear Aneek. But I don’t mind. If Raja wins and Aneek loose. Vote him out. Winning this title is not only way to prove himself good singer. If Aneek is not really talented what the use of winning this title. I believe he is talented most. So some biased vote can’t spoil his carrier. I will see what Raja can do in future.
@but that’s me(I guess …….)
In my previous post I said abt the singers like Mukesh,Manna dey,Rafi,Kishore,Sonu,Sunidhi etc. They are great singer,they learnt classical song also and pplr among every kind of pple. So, u dnt need to guess I only listen to the remix songs. You just tell me how many so called classical singer sang for film industry and able to reach to the common pple. Now dnt tell me it is music competition for core classical singers and only they can vote for it one who have great musical taste. It is not. It is for common pple. Before that also this program has produced so called playback singers like Kunal Ganjawala, Shreya Ghosal etc. In that particular point Mussarat was lagging behind. If he can change own style he will be pplr among common pple. Otherwise not possible. Simply everybody can’t learn classical music(Also particularly Sufiana gnre) to make Mussarat pplr.
Abt the fourth point, it was not rude at all. Probably u missed the first line. It was for the pple those who think Mussarat is out due to Indian public. I wanted to said thats not the reason. It is abt popularity and success based on that.
One thing you tell me how many Indian singers got chance in Pak film industry and how many Pak singers got chance in Indian film industry? Statistics is known to all. As so mentality also. So why some pple blame us for Mussarat elimination. Any relation can’t carry way by single side.
Some one has commented that Amanat couln’t sing the Pop song. Then my question to them what he sang the last couple of episodes. Amanat sang the toughest pop as well as classical songs. These type of songs are quite impossible to sing for other singers like Aneek, Raja, sumedha or poonam. i can give u guys very simple examples. Every one knows very well that Aneek is still this contest show because of copying Sonu Nigam and his mentor Himesh. Amanat sang two toughest songs of sonu nigam which were ”Tera Jadu Chal Gaya” and ”Bijuriya”. Tell Aneek to sing these type of Sonu Nigam’s song as he is copying him. I am not a fan of Amanat but the truth is he is a God gifted singer and he needs the support of Indian Audience.
@Shahrukh
I am Indian and big fan of Mussarat. Now that he is gone, the best singer left is certainly Amanat, followed by Poonam.
Aneek & Raja are all-hype, little-substance singers. The judging on this show has been so much biased that it really doesn’t make much difference what the jokers(i mean judges) say abt a contestant)
@wahidur
Only two words for you.
F… off
I totally agree with Rahul and Sharukh. I do not understand why people are misjudging the versatility of aneek’s voice even after listening to “ek Chatur naar”, “Bulla ki jana”, ” mast kalandar”, “Ya Ali”, “In Dino” all these songs sung by him in different styles with full control over his voice pitch and modulation.
no doubt amanat, poonam, raja are also very good singers but aneek has been consistent in all his performances. Its wrong to accuse him becoz he is HR’s chela and sonu’s clone. All the above mentioned songs have not been sung by sonu nigam but by different genre of singers
@ $ H A S H I
CAN u Post the Zee reply ??
plssss
@Anon and @Senty (and all others)-
The guy who created that piece about Himesh’s missing brain has come up with another gem. Read about it here:
http://www.aspisdrift.com/2007/09/exclusive-preview-of-himeshs-new-sequel.html#comment-4155075108450134072
-Harsh&Raw
Amanat & Poonam deserve to win this title. Oink & Raja were over hyped by the crappy judges. They shd have been kicked out long b4.
Brain dead was funny but this ‘suroor’ eating ‘pig’ has gone over board. Look, Mussarat may have disagreed a lot with him-ass but he didn’t portray his discomfort ever on the screen. Aneek is a kid, his mentor made him fall in love, so that doesn’t mean we rag Aneek for the faults of his mentor.
Raja being number one this week is all proof of people voting against Besharmiya. I think that’s enough of people’s sentiments.
@Harsh&Raw
I cant believe it.. ROFL ! This guy is a genius… !
I kinda feel bad for Aneek though. Aneek’s journey in this show was achha khaasa chal raha tha.. until “Diyaji…” (Kneel down, put one hand out, one hand to heart) “I love u !!”
and followed later by “Sir.. kya woh mujhe milegi ??”
And he still maintains in the Hungama shows that he loves Diya. Dude.. make up your mind.. apna luvv eeesh!shtoreee yeh hai ki woh hai.
But seriously, Aneek needs to smarten up (kinda too late now) and make sure the current Hee-mess doesnt kill his fan base. Anymore.
For all Aneek supporters .. Dunno doncare if he is from Bangladesh or Batinda.. but Aneek is certainly more versatile than Raja. He has covered a wide range of songs with good to great performances.
Amanat, Poonam & Aneek .. My ek do teen.
- Senty
BTW, I Watched the Hungama episode of Musarrat’s elimination day.
M-bhai said something that bothers me.. something like – after whats been going on the past few days he didnt want to stay anymore and so he’d started packing and was ready to leave this show … Wonder what might that be.. I-day? Himesh? something else ?
I dont remember the exact words, but if anyone has a better interpretation, that will help. I’m @ work, cant watch it now !
- Senty
Where’s the link to hungama show? It’s not here.
can u plz post the reply from zeetv that u have received.we r eager to read that
Here’s my take: From what i’ve been reviewing so far, Mussarat was eliminated because he wasn’t a versatile singer, good, but not versatile. Now, keeping with this same criteria, RAja should be eliminated. He is a good singer, but not versatile. On occasion when he tried singing songs that weren’t his style, he didn’t do so well. I think Amanat is most versatile of the lot. Aneek sings sonu’s songs and poonam also to some extent has a set style.
My request to the public is, please don’t let your votes be biased because of religion, region, caste, or favouritism. Please vote for the person who is the best! Thanks for reading my note.
Where can i get Mussarat’s songs in mp3 format? Can someone upload please?
@ divya
mussarat mp3′s
http://www.esnips.com/web/Mussaratabbas
Hey Divya,
I totally disagree with you on your comment “I think Amanat is most versatile of the lot. Aneek sings sonu’s songs and poonam also to some extent has a set style. “
as Aneek has sang “ek Chatur naar”, “Bulla ki jana”, ” mast kalandar”, “Ya Ali”, “In Dino” all these songs sung by him in different styles sung by different singers with full control over his voice pitch and modulation. I suggest you look back at the previous performances of Aneek, Amanat, Raja and Poonam then post comment.
@ senty
where did u see humgama with mussarat, i am dying to see it
thanks
@harsh and raw
http://www.aspisdrift.com/2007/09/exclusive-preview-of-himeshs-new-sequel.html#comment-4155075108450134072
LMAO ROFL..
this is what happens when you drive people up the wall with your nonsense him-ass ji
this manish is too good!
@i48998 / @anon
http://www.saregamapachallenge2007.com/watch-14th-september-saregamapa-hungama-episode.html
http://www.saregamapachallenge2007.com/watch-15th-september-saregamapa-hungama-episode.html
I will continue to stay loyal to $hashi’s website coz its still the BEST !
- Senty
WARNING: THIS POST IS NOT FOR THOSE WHO HATE TO BE SELF-CRITICAL, THEY MIGHT FIND IT PRIM.
People who like Aneek’s singing seem to sincerely admire and appreciate the talent and singing of other deserving contestants also.
On the other hand, the fans(?) of others seem to not only dislike his singing but also use choicest words of vilification to vent their anger and frustration about his very existence in this competition.
I would love to believe it was not a telltale sign of something non-musical.
If anyone is going to argue that the non-musical reason Aneek himself brought by referring to the love story, I would politely nullify that and remind him/her when he said “Sir, kya woh mujhe milegi?” he never ever even remotely hinted that the “woh” was Sumedha. It was ever-silly big-mouthed Himesh who suggested that.
So, if there is some non-musical reasons, it must be else, which I hate to accept.
I also spoke for Mauli when she was subjected to similar kind of filth (involving her personally with Bappi Lahiri) in this forum and was soon overwhelmed by the power of blind hatred.
Before being self-righteously judgmental about others and pretending concern for women’s dignity etc., we need to look at ourselves first and introspect, if we claim we are true music lovers.
@Sumitro
I don’t remember you spoke for Sumedha. Why???
@ senty
i seem to be having prob uploading from my mac to esnips
they are not showing up as mp3 but as NULL or something”
i am assuming you were not able to d/l any NN songs right?
any ideas to fix this
i uploaded a song from a pc as a test, that shows up as mp3
@ anonymous
Because I didn’t need to, as there were thousands others for that.
I had done my bit all the same to sign my petition silently.
I am only for those who, I think, are cornered wrongly with no one or very few to defend them.
BTW, you (people like you, I mean) don’t need to think so much of Sumedha, as you are celebrating her departure. You always failed to appraise and praise her singing with an open heart.
@anon
Oh .. so that was the reason. I was going to post a comment to you on that, but forgot. Im so sorry.
I did download the faiz gaane from there, renamed it as .mp3 and it worked just fine.
Maybe mac is the reason, your songs dont play online? There is only download / save as link in your songs.
- Senty
What a shame!! What a shame!! India cannot appreciate its singers, talent, woman etc. Both Poonam and Sumedha are great performers , great singers and we found Amanat Ali. Why can’t Mush help talent in his country. It is like the illegals in the US. I as a tax payer pay for those folks . It is time we took pride in Indian Cuture, people and helped them succeed. It seems we have more gays in India than straights otherwise we won’t have women put on the line every time and all the time. We can get Adcitya from Nepal and make him a star but we cannot make our own people stars. In the US, when Indian guy Sanjaya was doing ok on American Idol, he was freaked out on every channel
So guys you freaks, you no organs, respect and vote for our ladies
A fan from the USA…American in location Indian at Heart
Also stays awake to see this show and bear with Besharmiya
Mohan
I don’t understand why people are not voting ladies. Sumedha is such a good singer and she shouldn’t be voted out. I request all Indians to vote ladies. Don’t let Poonam vote out next week.
What an idiot HR is?? No one is saying anything positive about him.
he seriously talk nothing but rubbish.
I really hope that Aneek is out next week. then HR will reliaze what a shame he has done in his nonsense love drama. It seems like he is kissing ass to the audience. But I hope he knows that kissing ass won’t work.
Can’t wait to see next week result!
I hgink its time for HR and is only favourate one to leave.
HEY GUYS I HAVE FOUND THE RESULTS.
RAJA IS NO.1
ANEEK IS NO.2[F..K]
AMANAT IS NO.3
POONAM is NO.4
SUMI IS OUT.
YOU CAN SEE ALL THE VEDIOS ON http://www.deshidhmaka.com
this himesh is thinking as god after a fluk success of his film. whenever he is commenting on amanat he is not commenting on him but on aneek someone show hr what he is suppose to do. he is targeting raja as if raja is his competeter. ismail is chamcha of hr. hr thiks what i dont know in the end he removed aditya from beside kareena just for aneek . what is this yaar . we watch show for entertainment not for head ache . this he is just giving head ache whenaever he he get chance he starts barking.plaes vote against hr as zee has no guts to remove hime it has to be done by us audiance so lets do it it by voting out aneek
what a performance by ANEEK on Saturday!!! KAREENA was surprized. and Visal ji said ANEEK is technically most perfect singer. He is great. He is just amazing!!!. It seems to me the Singing is in his BLOOD. Keep it up ANEEK . AMANAT was good too today. The final result should be :
1) ANEEK
2) AMANAT
3) POONAM/RAJA
How is Zee TV bearing idiot HR. Does he think he is god. Amaanat has to be voted out this week. Vote for Poonam. She should not be voted out. Please vote for her people.
ANEEK SHUD BE OUT NEXT WEEK AFTER WHAT STUPID HIMESH DID TO RAJA!! THAT WASNT FAIR
ANEEK SHOULD BE OUT NEXT WEEK
HIMESH is wrongly bashing on Raja just to keep ANEEK in the show.
Thats unethical and wrong; lets stop that HYPOCRITE from doing this.
RAJA is a great singer; please vote for RAJA; he needs us more than anytime due to HIMESH’s prejudice.
Please do not vote for Amaanat as pakistanis are never going to appreciate even though he got so much fame here. Please vote for Poonam. She should not be voted out this week. Raja, you are a great singer and dont listen to that idiot HR.
The finals should have been between Raja, Poonam and Sumedha. Aneek and Amaanat should have been voted out last week. Please vote for Raja and Poonam. These two should be there in grand finale.
the only thing which looks cheap on this high trp show is himesh ki bakwaas.he talks rubbish n i think he needs to control over his agitating comments.god knows who made his movie a gr8 success coz i cant even bear him for even a fraction of second.i think people like rikshwawalas must hv gone 2 watch dat piece of junk.moreover the way he slough over raja jus for his selfish reasons is ruthless n tell him dat the more he’ll try 2 put him down,the more steps raja is goin 2 take towatds the pinnacle.
himesh u r goin 2 be a gr8 looser
n i m sure the same is goin 2 happen with ur upcoming film
@ mohan
In ur words Quote
“what a shame “.
You live here in this diverse society where everybody is given chance for their hardwork pity pyare Mohan that you have learnt nothing from that.
depends on who is gay now.
from usa
aneek should be voted out bcz he n himesh both played game so dat they can go to finals
this msg only for poonam
poonam is the best singer in saregamapa challenge 2007.she is a role model for this world,so plz keep voting for poonam.
what ever himesh said to raja when Musarat voted out was completely wrong.that was the first time when raja got lowest votes in sa re ga ma 2007, When musarat voted out only his last performance was better than raja and in previous performances, after ever performance himesh himself was saying, i hav fear u will be voted out after this.
The performance ‘Payar Ka Signal’ too bad. I m nt against Musarat, but himesh doesnot hav any right to speak like this, Himesh s frustrating, he try to hype his people by making their love affairs and flase stories nothing else.
Every time he Main acha insaan banne ki koshish kar raha hoon.. saying this everytime s of no use.
We know what himesh is..
WHO IS OUT OF SAREGAMAPA THIS WEEK..PLZ TELL??????
Hi All,
This is my fist comment here.
According to my sources, Poonam is out. Aneek was no 1, followed by Raja and then Amanat. Poonam came last and hence she is the one who got out.