Comments on: Review of 15th September Episode of Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenge 2007

By: TJ

TJ — Wed, 19 Sep 2007 11:24:00 +0000

I appreciate your comment, but I dont feel it irrelevent, because all I talked about is show, and I love this show, and I really do appreciate ZEE TV to come-up with this kind of talent hunt, and open approach.

I'm a fan of Saregamapa, that is why, I've a right to question my concerns, they did gr8 job... in promoting these singers and has given quality entertaintment to us.

These r just my questions and they all r related to the show, I discussed nothing but the incidents happend at the show, and I deserve some explanation.

I watch this show only in my mind having thoughts, that this should be 100% fare, bcoz you have done good job to bring people all around the world, then treat them equally please.

thats all I want to say, just go through again my comments, give me example where it is irrelevent?

By: Sitwat

Sitwat — Tue, 18 Sep 2007 21:12:00 +0000

@TJ

TJ although I believe that everyone's allowed to have their own view and opinion and therefore so do you, but I feel I must say something here. I really don't think that we need to now stoop to the age old Indian vs Pakistani routine. Don't you think all of us have had enough of that kind of divisive attitude? I think the world has had too much of it already.

I am from Pakistani origin and feel that this is the most irrelevant thing to bring in here.

Just my view on it.

By: TJ

TJ — Tue, 18 Sep 2007 08:21:00 +0000

do u want to give answer, why there was wild card enteries only from india why u didn’t included sikandar and guy from South Africa, and other good singers from Pak. who got eliminated at very early, u have masterly included Aneek and one other champion just to make sure, that india should win…. I want to laught at this so much……….

By: TJ

TJ — Tue, 18 Sep 2007 08:17:00 +0000

U r really willing to talk abt junk things, like Sumedha Affair or her intensions or feeling, but u dont want to discuss abt real singing, ask Aneek or Raja to sing something like Saware, they cannot, but u dont want to discuss this injustice, bcoz He’s Pakistani guy.

all u will discuss is junk, not productive.

By: TJ

TJ — Tue, 18 Sep 2007 08:12:00 +0000

This is simple, that u cannot see any non-indian winner from this show, like u have all close your mouths whenever we have seen Mussarat fan saying something, u all close your ears and eyes, just bcoz he’s pakistani, Junaid became 2 times top ranker in international community, and suddenly he gots eliminated, also we have seen that many good Pakistani singers like Sikandar and the guy from South Africa, got eliminated as they came, I dont why, just bcoz they had the fear that they might loose the show, bhai if u have this thing in your mind, that must must win! then why ur making Start Plus like Drama at the reality show, if u have opened doors, then u should open up your mind as well, I know the next one that might be excluded from the show will be Amanat somehow.

By: KLCC Boy KL

KLCC Boy KL — Tue, 18 Sep 2007 06:09:00 +0000

the way i see… i have guess that poonam will be in bottom though i do not want this because she is from my hometown and afterall a very powerful good singer.

i think votes for women are relatively lesser and marks from mentors this time were her’s lower.

I guess Raja (my favourite) too can be again on the bottom 2 due to the stupid comments of HR, i think it may affect Raja’s votes.

I guess no 1 will be Aneek and No 2 will be Amanat. Sumi 3rd for next week…

I hope I am wrong…

I hope RAJA WINS, WINS and WINS... Stupid Himesh Besharmiyan should be stopped from continuing his besharmiyans on the Show!

Cheers from KL.

By: KLCC Boy KL

KLCC Boy KL — Tue, 18 Sep 2007 06:07:00 +0000

testing….

By: cruz

cruz — Tue, 18 Sep 2007 05:58:00 +0000

Hi all,

As I join my opinion with the comments made by all the genuine music lovers, I completely agree with them. Promoting aneek by his guru is not done in the right way as it should(poor guy(aneek) what can he do). There are limits to everything and those should be obeyed by everyone who participate to keep up the decency of the show. All the 6 contestants have loads of singing talent and have great future. I whole heartedly wish that to happen and my best wishes to all of them.

For me personally, I became ardent admirer of Amanat Ali from day one.

As I see, the only way out to have good musical show is to edit HR's faltoo baat for the welfare and well being of singers as well as the audience.

ONCE AGAIN MY VERY VERY BEST WISHES TO ALL THE SINGERS...................

By: riya

riya — Tue, 18 Sep 2007 03:26:00 +0000

This show was so boring because the most beautiful,unique,mesmerizing,heart touching,soul catching voice was missing, and that was of mussarat abbas.The show has lost it's touch, and all the singers seem like they have the same voice and are signing the same song.

I MISS MUSSARAT.THEY SHOULD BRING HIM BACK.I CANT WAIT FOR HIS ALBUM. I"M DEFINETLY BUYING IT.AND I STILL SAY LIKE I HAVE FROM THE BEGINING MUSSARAT YOU ROCK, AND ALWAYS WILL.

IF MUSSARAT WAS HERE AND HE SANG DULHE KA SEHRA SUHANA LAGTHA HAI BY NFAK , IT WOULD HAVE ROCKED THE SHOW.

as far as the other contestants amanat and poonam did a really good job, and aneek screwed up sonu's song, and sumehda just sucks. himesh keeps saying her voice is to fit the leading ladies of bollywood because he wants to continue using her for that stupid love story crap, and so he is sucking up to her, too bad she doesn't realize that. Raja has to keep working on his signing.

Himesh i was a fan of yours before you started to favor one of your student more than the other, and before you put mussarat down for everything when he had the song perfect, you suck.

JUST BECAUSE HIMESH GOT HIS STUPID MOVIE AAP KA SUROOR OUT, AND HE THOUGHT HE DID SUCH A FANTABOULOUS JOB, HE THINKS HE IS THE LOVE GURU NOW, SO HE IS TRYING TO PATCH UP THE CONTESTANTS, YOU ARE SO PATHETIC AND NOT RIGHT FOR PLAYING AROUND WITH THEIR FEELINGS, WHEN YOU SUPPOSE TO HELP THEM IMPROVE THERE PROFESSIONAL LIFE, NOT THEIR PERSONAL.

By: prabhat

prabhat — Tue, 18 Sep 2007 03:06:00 +0000

Hi All,
Contrary to what you all people are talking about…Check the Poll results on this website which shows Poonam has only 13% of the votes for the most favourite singer. I request you all people to vote for poonam before you start doing anything on this blog.
The results of the poll contradict the statements made in the discussions.