Review of 25th August Episode of Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenge 2007 - Akshay Kumar Special
Yesterday was the elimination episode and Junaid got eliminated from this vishwayudh.. Now we have the top 8, who will be performing in this agnipariksha round to impress the viewers and get the maximum votes.. so, sit back and enjoy the update
Group Performance:
Aditya and Sumedha are singing Churake dil mera.. Raja and Mauli singing Fanaa, Poonam joins them.. - fanaa fanaa, yeh dil hua fana.. Aneek and amanat singing hum dono hain alag alag.. Sumedha standing in between them.. Mussarat and Harpreet singing Hum hain seedhe saadhe Akshay.. Aditya asks everyone to welcome most beloved star of bollywood industry.. the most hot - Akshay Kumar.. He enters the stage with some kids.. Every kid says - Hey Baby.. Akshay says these kids are the heroines and thats why they are here.. Aditya says - Yesterday Hey Baby was released and had great opening.. The promo of the movie is shown on the screen..
Akshay says - Hey baby is one of the important film and this depicts the transformation of a man from a bachelor to a father.. He says there are two things important in life - happiness and peace.. A man is happy when he is a bachelor and is peaceful when he hugs his child..
Aditya asks the mentors how they feel as Akshay is here;;
Vishal - blows whistle..
HR - Biggest opening.. Rocking film.. this is the 10th biggest hit in the row.. He had also made many films of mine and I am thankful that he did and all became a hit.. Akshay says the previous one was also yours - Namaste London.. Himesh says Thank u for being here..
Shekhar - There is a picture of YashRaj movies which they are doing and Akshay is the hero of the film.. Akshay says he just now finished a song shoot before coming here.. They are doing shooting in Ladakh and Jaisalmer.. for the movie
Bappida - welcomes him to the sets.. Akshay - Bappida got me khiladi and said he will become a super star.. Bappida - He comes on stage and says - he will sustain in bollywood and we will always go and watch the movie..
ID - Ek hi jigar waala actor hain - woh hain Akshay.. I will copy your simplicity.. If you become the director, I will become the hero.. Akshay says he wants to be happy and dont want to become director or producer.. Ismailji says - nor will I become the actor..
Akshay will himself appeal to the viewers for voting to the contestant who impresses him the most..
Performance:
Mussarat Abbas from Rock Gharana:
HR says he is an Unconventional singer dont compare him to original song.. He is going to sing in his own voice and style..
Mussarat to Akshay You are my idol.. I have seen many movies of yours in Pakistan and I am going to sing my favorite song..
He sings Ae meri zoharajabeen from Phir hera OPheri.. Contestants, Ismailji all are dancing..
Comments:
Akshay - I feel like telling to my producer to picturize this again and make you sing.. you have done it very differently..
VS - The whole set is filled with energy.. There was little fault in singing but you filled the whole stage with lot of energy and was very good.. gives 9
Shekhar - Himesh has given you a correct advice to sing in your own voice.. full marks to you Himeshji..
Aditya asks Himesh to sing 2 lines.. I give the whole credit to this song.. Akshay has always been there in the whole picture and has done great job..
Ismailji - I danced when I listened to this - 10
Bappida - the magic you brought to the song was great. but not like Himesh.. Himesh is Himesh.. But will give you 10.. Himesh says - You are the fatherinlaw of this gharana.. give 10..
Asks public to vote.. Its a treat to watching akshay in this show..
Aneek Dhar from Rock Gharana:
Himesh - This song is composed by SEL.. And he is in love and this song is also composed with so much love.. He has worked hard.. He sings - Mast Kalender from Hey Baby..
The studio audience shout - once more.. Himesh says - you must not disappoint the public.. so, once more.. Aneek says - I want Aditya to be one stage with me.. Aditya says, I want Akshay to be on stage..
They all perform together.. Even VS join them while singing..
Akshay - I see lot of programmes and everyone blows the whistle and I will do it for you also.. Aneek says there is a laughing style of Akshay which he loves a lot and he does that for Akshay.. Akshay says this is not my style.. Its different.. And again gives that laugh for Aneek..
Comments:
Ismailji - Where Akshay has blowed the whistle, where can I reduce the pointsd.. gives 10
Bappida - Akshay has given you so much of appreciation.. Himesh cuts him and says - here you are the direct father-in-law, so you cannot reduce his points.. Bappida gives 10..
VS - Aneek has performed in this level because you have throat infection and not telling this, you did a great job.. If you had sung without infection, you would have done even more better.. Gives 10..
Shekhar- have you ever seen sonu perform live? Aneek says No.. He always jumps and sings, but then too he never looses the sur and you performed just like that today..
Himesh - you are a true lover and that is why you are singing like this..
Next to perform Josh Gharna:
Sumedha Karmahe
She sings Gela Gela Gela from Aitraaz..
Comments:
Akshay - Hey Baby, your performance is as sexy as you are..
Himesh - very good performance.. your voice quality suites all the leading ladies.. gives 9
Shekhar - for yesterday’s operformance, I will give you 200.. today’s could have been better.. gives 7
ID - I am not concentrating on the faults, but I am concentrating on the positive side.. gives 10
Bappida - Sumedha is chattsigargh ki shaan.. Just keep singing well.. that is more than enough..
Mauli Dave -
She sings ghustaakhiyaan hain from Aankhein..
Comments:
Bappida asks her to sing more 23 lines.. He gfoes to Akshay and asks him to go on stage.. Akshay - I am a total besura aadmi.. You have given her a test to sing such a difficult song.. Just give her blessings.. Bappida praises Aditya.. He is very talented and there are very few like him..
VS - Its a tough song to sing.. Higher notes, you picked up well.. this is 3rd good performance in a row.. gives 9
Himesh - this is not the best, but very tough.. gives 9
ID - I was about to give you 9, but for public I will give you 10..
Next to perform Yalgaar:
Amanat Ali-
sing Tu cheez badi hai mast mast from Mohra..
Comments:
Welcimes Akshay on stage.. He says, he wants to give a gift as 9th september is Akshay’s birthday.. This is nanchakku.. And I will use it in next film.. This is sangeeth ka nanchakku.. He performs an act with that.. Everyone on the sets sing Happy Birthday to Akshay..
himesh - Need not say anything.. 10 straight.. I cannot reduce because people will say because of Aneek I have reduced..
Shekhar - 9 for singing and 1 for performance.. 10 total..
Vishal - Be careful with low notes.
Bappida - Tu cheez badi badi hai mast.. gives 10
Ismailji - Everyone has praised you and said - “tu cheez badi hai mast”.. I will say the samething..
Poonam Yadav
sings Dil toh pagal hain title song..
Comments:
Akshay - I will give you 10 marks.. My button is not there.. Give me also a button.. Aditya says - your button is in everyone’s heart
VS - You deserve 10.. Vishal says - you deserve 10 qawalli round too.
Bappida - You sang very sweetly.. gives 10
himesh - pocket size power house - Poonam, you are one of the best singers here.. People have not forgotten your mom and that issue.. Request public to vote..
Ismailji - nothing to say.. She must be number 1 next week.. You have sung from heart..
To Akshay - I have learnt many things today.. Your simplicity - I adore.. Ismailji says - this is the common point that, even I said I will follow your simplicity and she too said the samething.. Akshay says - I will definitely maintain it..
Next to perform Hit Squad:
Harpreet deol:
shekhar - Last week Harpreet called me and asked what to sing as Akshay is coming.. He gave him one of his favorite song to sing..
Harpreet says yu are one of the actors who has sung punjabi shabad.. so, please sing it for me.. Akshay says - you sing well - I will sing for you..
He sings Vaada raha sanam from Khiladi..
Comments:
Akshay - Aditya says - this is his favorite song from his childhood and for this reply Akshay says In childhood, this song was my favorite.. Your diction was good and I really enjoyed this song.. He sings the shabad and asks do I get 10? Shekhar says - yes we all give 10..
Ismailji has played violin in this song.. Gives 10
Bappida - Akshay says - give him 10, you have given this film for me.. Bappida says - Akshay is my favorite - I will give 10 for you..
Himesh - You sang with lot of feelings and you totally got involved.. gives 10
Shekhar - when someone sings with heart, everyone forgets the sur and taal.. thanks everyone for giving 10..
Vishal - You have constantly improved in your performance.. keep it up..
Aditya asks all the kids to send the recording for the little champs..
Raja Hasan:
He sings Kiss me baby from Garam Masala.. bappida brings Akshay on stage.. VS join them.. Himesh shouts 10 marks.. All the mentors shout 10 marks.. himesh calls Aneek on stage.. Vishal says Aneek is number 1 today.. Public shouts Raja.. Himesh says - this is what public’s verdict is - please do something for Aneek too.. Ismailji says - I have Amanat and Bappida say - I have Mauli.. They all sing together Kiss me Baby song..
Then Hey Baby song is played in the background and every one dance and sing together..
Akshay says this is a great platform and most importantly I have seen lot of love here and also India and Pakistan flag is there together and this can be seen in very few stages.. I would say - it should be India with Pakistan and not India Vs Pakistan.. Thank Zee Tv for inviting him and wishes everyone luck.
Written by Anu

THEY ARE HYPING ANEEK TOO MUCH! ANEEK MADE MISTAKES BUT NO1 MENTIONED. ANEEKS PICKS EASY SONGS! I WOULD LIKE ANEEK TO PERFORM WHAT AMANAT DID TODAY. HE COULD NEVER PULL SOMETHING LIKE THIS. WHAT A SETUP! MUSARRAT, AMANAT, AND SUMEDHA NEVER GET THE HYPE THEY DESERVE. HERPREET, ANEEK, AND MAULI TOO HYPED!
Miss JUNAID on the show…..the show is not the same anymore.
This is utter crap tht a singer like JUNAID is eliminted
Next who shd b eliminted shd b MAULI……..had enough of her…….cnt bear her anymore
I think they have already decided whom they wanna b the winner on the show….pls dnt fool the audiance.
Its unbelievable tht JUNAID who is so talented and popular can b voted out….and MAULI is still there. cnt figure out y the judges always praize her and when she is pathetic….then defend her…but this strategy is not for other singers.
JUNAID WILL B MISSED ON THE SHOW.
IF not for AMANAT wld not bother to watch the show.
overall all the performances were good
MUSSARAT sang quite well.
ANEEK was rocking. ill give him extra credit bcoz akshay was also singing sum parts of the song in between ( which was not too much in sur) inspite of which he did not go off key.he deserved full 30.
SUMEDHA sang very well according to me. i felt VS shud have given her more than 7. i liked her performance.
MAULI was good. but i again felt she was screaming in sum parts. though the song demands that kind of a voice it didn’t sound tht good.
AMANAT was also very good.
POONAM too sang very well.
HARPREET was very good.he sure is improving on his singing but i personally feel that he cannot sing classical songs. till date all of harpreet’s songs mostly have straight notes.
RAJA was good but again i felt he did not deserve all that hype. he definately is over-rated.
i found Aneek the best yesterday.
Rokr
ROKR- YOU ARE ONE OF THOSE PEOPLE WHO BELIEVE WHAT JUDGES SAY. ANEEK SANG THE BEST? LOL AND YOU KNOW THIS HOW BECAUSE YOU ARE THE MUSIC DIRECTOR AND HAVE THE EARS FOR IT? YOU ARE JUST WHAT JUDGES SAY. HAVE YOUR BRAINS!
Wow,Kudo’s to Akhaykumar! mauli tried to pull him to be on the set & he refused! that shows what is Mauli’s power! I really loved it! Bhappi, stooped so low to promote his singers by pulling Akhay to the stage by force! poonam was amazing! even Akhay said where r 10 buttons,i would like to vote her! but as usual Raja got it away,bcse of Shekhsr’s cheap politics & hype! i hate Shekhar & apreciate Vishal as he acknowledged Poonam’s performance in his absence! And what to tell about Ismail,he is the worst Guru! When all guru’s are promoting their contestants,he keeps on promoting other’s contestants.,ID is so cool, as if he has just finished a huge plate of Biryani & had no motivation left in life! So stupid! HR has stooped so low to promote Aneek that now i like only Poonam,Amanat(as they have no backing & they r so talented) & then Harpreet!
I had to put the cotton earplug when bhappida;s socalled shakira was yelling ,i hope public is not that stupid to vote for her! She was the worst today!!
Aneek & Raja, the two superstars according to judges, should be given the tast of singing the same song that Amanat sung. I am pretty sure they will never be able to pull it off(atleast Aneek would never be able to pull it off given his past performances)
One of my misconceptions was cleared in todays episode , i had developed a prejudice that Bappida is a selfish man is just concerned about his own gharana etc.
But when Akshay said that Bappida got him the role of khiladi when he was stuggling my Point of view for bappida took a 180 degree turn..
Hats off bappida ..we are proud that you are in the show..we love you..
Some notes on the show of today:
- Nice to see that Akshay refused to Mauli’s request to come on the stage.
- Besuri Mauli tried to sing with Raja and Aneek, but this again shows that she can only “sing” off key (LOL)
- Stop overhyping Raja… He is not a quality singer like Amanat or Aneek.
- When Mauli started to sing, I felt the urge to directly go to the toilet !!!!! (I wasn’t missing anything)
- The ass-kissing must stop… Judges and contestants start being honest !!! (Mauli is WORST ever on SRGMP, actually come to think of it: It’s a total insult on the Indian Music Industry !!!!)
- The editors of the program are really focussed on the masala of the show (like the “love” triangle). Just count how often Sumedha is filmed (I like her singing BTW) from head to toe….
Last but not least: STOP voting for Mauli
My TV is cracking when she starts singing. There was almost a burst on my TV screen…. I had to turn it off….
I feel Mussarat is the most under rated and under appreciated singer. He does not get the attention that he deserves from judges where as other gets lot of attention.
My ranking for attention from judges goes like this.
Raja from VS
Aneek/Mauli from HR/BH respectively
Harpeeth from VS
I really felt bad at the end of the show when the judges called only 1 contestant from each gharana and they are Raja,Aneek,Mauli and Amanath.
what about 4 other contestants?
sheesh what a bakwas episode..
major issue being akki doesnt have great songs he has lip synced to in movie.. unlike someone like sallu or ARK
so basically the contestants sang mostly crappy songs
best of the worst being- amanat( cuz frankly thats the only akki song i am familiar with he he
)
the music from garam masala and hay baby - unadulterated garbage pure and simple
this episode sucked musically
the HR kissing Akki’s ass act was getting nauseating
the continuing Aneek and Raja lovefest on the part of judges is as vomit inducing as before
and junaid-baby you are missed.. muuaaahh. come out with that new CD already!
yeah i do feel badly for mussarat, poonam and amanat- they are everyone’s step child
the blue eyed girls and boys being of course aneek/raja/mauli
uuurgh just typing those names makes me wanna gag!
No Doubt quality of Singers in this show is much much better than Indian Idol or VOI. But it really hurts when justice is not done on such a great show. I think everybody missed Junaid more than any other contestant who were eliminated before.
Moreover after this episode i think that its becoming quite obvious that who the final 4 will be in order to keep just one singer from each gharana they will do injustice with other singers and its looking like they have planned who the final four will be
Hit It: Raja
Rock: Aneek
Yalghar: Amanat
Josh: Mauli
And most surprising thing would be if Mauli makes to final four. I think it will be a suicide for saregamapa. Also Sumedha is 1000 times better than Mauli, Sumedha got comments on “Bahoon Ke Darmiyan” and “Chupke Se” that she sang better than Original. Its obvious that Sumedha is far more consistant than any other singer. And only Bappi Da has promised to give work to Mauli because he is stupid enough.
Talking about the fact that Aneek and Raja are promoted too much than required. I really dont think now that Raja can sing better than Amanat. Amanat has shown that he is the most versatile singer on the show, he has sung songs of almost all type of singers, which nobody else has managed to pull out.
And i can feel now that there will be another surprised elimination next week and that will be of SUMEDHA, but we cant do any thing because its all been decided by the gr8 mentors. Mauli should have been out when she was competing with Sreshtha.
“And i can feel now that there will be another surprised elimination next week and that will be of SUMEDHA, but we cant do any thing because its all been decided by the gr8 mentors. Mauli should have been out when she was competing with Sreshtha.”
I would like to humbly SPIT on Bappi Lahiri for forcing a very honest Akshay to stage for his manly Mauli thing. Hats off to Akshay who had more musical sense than all the “composers” and didn’t sing any false praise for the screaming Mauli thing.
I would also like to polietly SCREAM in the ears of all the judges so that they stop their ugly Mauli thing hearing loss.
Finally, I want to SHUT Aditiya Narayan up from speaking, as he drools on the same lines again and again.
@Raj & Anon
Totally agree with u guys! The most favored ones on this show r
Mauli,Raja,Aneek & now Amanat.Sumedha too is being hyped by her love affair & HR calling Bhappida as Sasur,disgusting!
I like Raja & Amanat but the hype for them & totally understating Poonam,who has such a superb voice & who doesn’t flaunt herself infront of celebrities like Mauli does—
For example On salman show—Mauli demanded,salman,pls hug me & the brat immediately went to the stage calling her sweetheart!
On Fardeen show—-Mauli asked fardeen to dance & Bhhappi pulled him to the stage
On Akki’s show—mauli literally went to akki’s seat & tried to pull him for a dance with her,but guess what-AKKI REFUSED!
Oh,Akki,i love u,u have strength in u! Finally,Bhappi used his influence (about his obligation over Akki for his filmbreak)& pulled him to the stage but Akki said very clearly,i do not know much of sur taal—-it doesn’t take 2 cents to understand what he was trying to say!
Atleast for god’s sake let us have some good music at the end of the show.
Or may be Zee is keeping Mauli on the show like a Kala Tikka so, show ko Nazar Na Lage!
All praise to Akki for refusing to falsely praise Mauli’s horrible performance.
He was like ‘What the f**K!!!!! You want me to praise this stupid performance, man…. she didn’t even sing like bathroom singers”
Atleast he has the sense of appreciating good music. He is not besura, all judges are besuras.
I also like the way Akki said that it would be unfair if he suggests that one singer is better than other and refusing to appeal for a particular contestants.
Message 4 BappiDa: Learn something from Akshay. You can make ur useless life little bit useful.
The recent reviews on this blog, have assured me that I too have a keen music sense, else I could not understand how the Gurus make decisions on the performances.
I have never commented on anyone’s look. But the way Mauli was made to dress in the last episode she looked more like a Wh*r*. Maybe she feels dressing like this will make the Indian Audience vote for her more.
On Comparison to the Singers. I feel Amanat is the best amongst the Male singers. He has sung with so much variety, which Raja, Aneek haven’t shown.
Amongst the girls, Poonam is a class apart from Sumedha. While Sumedha has a sweet voice and has given some excellent performances recently, Poonam could have equally done good justice to the songs.
Comparing Sumedha’s Chup Ke se performance with her “Gela Gela”, I feel while the Chupke se is a much better Song, her diction wasn’t very clear. I don’t understand how Shekhar could say ” Better than original”. Sadhana Sargam who originally sang the song has the most clear diction after Kavita ( LATA & Asha Aside).
On Gela Gela, I found her performance much better to a song which offered nothing. She put a good feel into her singing. She atleast Sang 100 times better than Mauli.
Mauli,
Seriously Consider leaving the show with whatever honour you have remaining. You really suck and the worst singer on the show. We all know you cannot sing on the low scale, so shouting in the high scales so that you can raise the low scales, is not singing. It is butchering of a song. If you really think you are a singer, please attempt Lata’s song ” Kuch Dil ne Kaha, Kuch bhi nahi”.
Also I didn’t understand, Vishal saying your voice is “Tired”. What exactly were you doing?
Vijay@
on mauli-Also I didn’t understand, Vishal saying your voice is “Tired”. What exactly were you doing?
very well said!
Do u want to know,what mauli was doing?her favorite hobby,shouting or yelling whatever u say on the pretext of singing!
I have lost all the respect for Himesh Reshamya for shamelessly promoting Aneek when Raja was still performing. He is such a “Plug Whore”. I hat Aneek because of Himesh. I wish, Himesh and Aneek both get kicked out of the show.
The way Himesh is putting down Mussarat and shamelessly promoting Aneek, I have lost all respect for Himesh. He is supposed to be a guru to these two guys. Guju is like a father & father doesn’t differenciates b/w two sons.
Himesh just wants to boost his ego. He has some differences with Sonu,thats the reason Aneek is being promoted as junior Sonu blah blah blah. Himesh tried to root Vinit as Sonu earlier. Moron thinks by naming someone as Sonu, he will be able to hurt Sonu.
Both Aneek and Raja were my favourites earlier, but bcoz of the unfair support they recieve from judges, I have stopped voting for them completely.
You are so right Anonymous. Himesh is promoting Aneek like none other and then comparing him to Sonu. Has Himesh Sonu sing? Himesh is an idiot and by Promoting Aneek like that he is insulting Sonu. Aneek can’t hit hight notes at all. he can’t sing what Mussarat or Amanat can pull. I stopped voting for Aneek when I saw that he picks easy songs.
I agree with you anonymous and eric.Himesh has to start treating both of his students equally, he is being very unfair. Before aneek came into the show he was all about mussarat and having him hit big, and when aneek came in he started ignoring mussarat and started to promote aneek.He believes that aneek can go far, but like i have said before voices like aneeks come around evryday but voices like mussarats are unique and and hard to find, so once found you cherish them, not put them down and ignore it. Aneek does pick easy songs, and anyone can sing them. Himesh purposly gives mussarats his own songs so he can critique and say you could’ve done better. What i hate is that he starts to sing it and tell them their mistakes when they sound much better then his, and im not hating.Amanat,poonam,mussarat are the best and should be in the finals. Raja is alittle too hype and alittle up in the clouds because he has a nice voice. Also why is himesh telling aneek to be like raja, i mean raja messed up his songs so many times, and aneek is gonna follow his footsteps. Te stupid love jokes have to go they are boring. OH JUST REMEBERED WHEN MUSSARAT SANG A SONG THE LAST TIME AND BAPPI DA SAID ITS NOT BETTER THAN HIMESH THAT PISSED ME OFF, THAT IS VERY RUDE, HOW CAN YOU SAY YOU HAVE MAULI AS SHAKIRA WHEN SHE HAS NO SENSE OF MUSIC AND SHAKIRA THE REAL ONE, DEFINITELY KNOWS HER TUNES.
ONE LAST THING, SO FAR THE SHOW HAD LOVE SONG DAYS,PATRIOTIC,DANCE,OLDIES,QAWWALI,AND WHATEVER ELSE THEY HAD BUT IT IS TIME FOR THEM TO MAKE A SHOW FOR CLASSICAL SONGS ONLY.I KNOW AMMANAT,POONAM,AND MUSSARAT,MAYBE RAJA CAN PULL THOSE OFF EASILY, BUT I WANT TO SEE HIMESH FAVORITE ANEEK SING A CLASSICAL SONG. AND ESPECIALLY THAT BESURI MAULI SING A CLASSICAL, ALL SHE CAN SING IS ITEM SONGS.
SO ALL YOPU FELLOW PEOPLE THAT POST COMMENTS WHAT YOU SAY ABOUT MY OPINION ON HAVING A CLASSICAL SHOW.
I dont know how many of you have been following SVOI. There are couple of guys who are just too good. There is one guy called Toshi, by far the most talented and polished like Amanat Ali in that show. He has attemted ‘Lagan lagi’ song which was earlier sung by Mussarat in Saregama.
Go to youtube and see what ppl have written abt Mussarat. Toshi, no matter how good and how well trained he is, just could not sing that song like Mussarat.
I still believe Mussarat has a unique voice and a different kind of singer and he could offer a lot to Indian music. Not that Mussarat is not versatile(he has sung all kinds of songs previously) but when it comes to sufi singing(his speciality), Mussarat is unmatched.
By ignoring Mussarat and putting him down, HR is not only doing injustice to Mussarat, but he is doing a great disservice to Indian music.
Hi Guys,
I have seen all the comments.
I just wanted to share my thoughts.
I feel that both aneek and raja are being hyped.
Aneek cannot sing any songs other than sonu nigam’s.
Raja can sing only kailesh kher, sukhvinder singh and AR rahman songs.
Yes raja has got edge in this as he can sing songs of 3 singers where as aneek only one.
But the most versatile personality here is Amanat. He is a guy who deserve to be in the top spot.
Also poonam is very good and it is very true that himesh is not even encouraging musarrat and not giving him the right songs.
Himesh is playing a cheap game by only hyping Aneek.
And Bappida again promoting the worst of all “Mauli” i donno y.
Now when we talk of the top 3.
It should be in the following order.
1.Amanat
2.Poonam
3.Raja
Please do not vote for Mauli…
PLease
PLease
GUYS I CAN UNDERSTAND ALL YOUR FEELINGS …PLEASE EXCUSE ME IF I M WRONG BUT HERE IS MY ANALYSIS REGARDING THE ELIMINATIONS HAPPENED IN AGNIPARIKSHA AND EVENTS THT MIGHT TAKE PLACE FURTHER:
looking at the elimination trend b4 and no.of challengers in each gharana after every elimination its clearly seen tht ZEE is tryin to balance the gharanas..
1.Rimi(yalgaar)……..Yalgaar- 2,Hit-it-4,Rock-4,josh-3
2.Apurva(Hit-it)…….Yalgaar -2,Hit-it-3,Rock-4,josh-3
3.Nirupama(rock)….Yalgaar 2,Hit-it-3,Rock-3,josh-3
4.Abhijit(Josh)…….Yalgaar 2,Hit-it-3,Rock-3,josh-2
5.Joy(rock)………..Yalgaar 2,Hit-it-3,Rock-2,josh-2…………
6.Junaid.(Hit it) ……Yalgaar -2,Hit-it-2,Rock-2,josh-2
..and if the trnd continues then 1 challenger from each ghrana wud be thr in top 4 and obviously those wud be the one whom zee tv is giving more hype…dats Amanat(Yalgaar),mauli(josh),Aneek(Rock) and Raja(Hit it)…hence rest 4 wud get eliminated in cmin 4 weeks
Plus if Zee tv is really planing like this it wud fil their one more criteria for”Vishwayudh” in real manner….bcoz if the things i mentioned above are preplanned then thr wud be challengers throughout India,pakistan and overseas…i.e.Raja & Aneek from India,Amanat from pakistan and mauli from overseas…I hate to rite Mauli’s name in top 4 but i have started geting this feeling after looking at results every week
Even I am with the sentiments being echoed - there are some candidates who are overtly hyped by the Mentors themselves - really cant comprehend how ethical it is for a Mentor to overtly campaign for 1 particular candidate when there are others in that same Gharana…so funny. Mauli is the most glaring example of this - she is so typed and yet sooo hyped. Aneek is good - but Himesh is playing the same politics as he did with Vineet. That is making Aneek corrupt - he jumps on the stage and has started resorting to more of dramatics than music. Needs to be brought on track. Raja of course remains the BEST. May the Best Win.
Hello All
I really agree with you Rahul. I wrote it previously and i am writing it again that the only thing which is really awful is what Himesh is doing. A teacher instead of uniting the students started to discriminate. Mussarat is equally good as aneeq but why Himesh is passing wrong comments for mussarat. Its not fair. But these comments are not going across the mentors so what can we do.
Of course there are discussions, debates and differences of opinion. This does not, according to me, take away from the fact that this year’s Sa Re Ga Ma Pa is perhaps the BEST EVER musical talent show on TV in our country. Well done to all those involved - especially to an exceptionally gifted bunch of contestants! It will be a sad day when this series gets over!
Kets..you seem to have a valid point. It looks as if they are balancing the garanas. I cannot even imagine Mouli in top 4 if that what’s planned. GOD ! Please save us from this misery of listening more of Mouli’s screams.
Aneek has sung shakalaka bhoom better than HR. His kawali was also good. I don’t know why HR always has to say that his voice suites these songs better.
I too felt bad when only 4 of the contestants were called upon stage at the end of the show. These judges should GROW UP! They should also stop promoting individual singers. Raja and Annek are good singers but definitely over hyped.
Amanat is a very talented.
Sumedha is by far a better singer than Mouli.
I would like to see MOULI go in the next episode. I haven’t seen a single person praising Mouli. Wonder who is voting for her!!!
Dear All,
I would like to appreciate all the comments on saregamapa & the contestants….
Also i request all people to vote for singers depending on their performance & not on judges comment & all other stories…this is are done only to raise trp’s for show. All contestants are innocent & have to follow the format…..
Dear All,
According to me I have classified & ranked top 8 contestants.
1)Amanat - Versatile singer: can sing any type of songs.
2) Poonam - Best voice range: can sing in any note.
3) sumeeda - smooth singer: has the best voice.
4) Aneek - Talented singer: has song rock, english & romantic songs of rabbi shergil,lab januja, rahet fateh ali khan…
5)Raja - soulful singer: best classical & soulful voice..needs to more often sing soft songs..
6)mussarat - No 1 suffi singer: can sing high notes easily…needs to improve on slow songs…
7)Harpreet - Most improving singer: The most improved singer…but hasn’t sing any difficult track..
please post ur comments…
Rohan
I think you are right. We should vote on individual singers performance. I saw few people saying that they have stopped voting for Raja and Aneek because of the hype. But its not the singers fault and i too think they should not suffer from the Judges’s hype.
And as far as ranking goesi would move sumedha after mussarat.
Rohan:
We can find plenty of singers like Aneek in India and all over the world. I personally would not rank Aneek in top 5 because of that. Mussarat on the other hand can not be found all over the world. I agree with you on Amanat, who I personally believe should win the SRGMP. Aneek really needs to prove that he can sing classical songs and can pull what Mussarat can pull. You are right about Sumedha, Poonam (I like her too), and for Mauli I have no comments. Seriously, I don’t call that a singer. I can gran someone from the street and I am sure they can pull this off with few lessons. Aneek and Mauli too hyped. Raja is hyped too but sometimes Raja really pulls it off. Sumedha and Mussrat most underappreciated.
ATTENTION - NEWS on Mauli—-
If you thought what kind of people like croakers. Follow this link
http://www.nagar.org/community_news/2007/05/mauli_dave_of_texas_usa_has_be.html
Its hilarious, do these people have any knowledge of what “Singing Talent” is all about.
No wonder, she has been getting votes.
Some these want “Mauli to compete with Sunidhi”, Real idiots, yeah let her compete with Poonam on the same song first.
Everyone, Let me know your thoughts.
Judges have decided to get Sumeedha out. Vishal-Shekhar strategically gives Sumeedha 100 points for previous performance and 7 for the recent one. Dude can you be more obvious in trying to get rid of her. Bappi Da get a back bone man Mauli is playing you. Zee TV trust me if you get rid of Mauli RATINGS will improve,
Hi..first of all its a message 4 everybody dat,though we r posting our comments on the site ,zee tv is nothing to do with it.
i m pretty sure it just enjoys our comments instead of giving value to it.
What zee tv thinks is if they pulled out Mauli from this show den the TRP may go down and people stop watching saregamapa.but i
wld like warn them, whoever posting comments and watching saregamapa is must be a true music lover.we all are here to see that saregama wch always maintained its reputation since a decade.
i m not telling against any individual but if a singer like Mauli will cm on to top 4 overcoming sumedha,mussarat or any of the existing singers ,den it ll definitely hurt a musiclover.by
this may this show will lack goodwills and people move towards other quality progs like VOI.
BAPPI DA: I always remain a gr8 fan of urs and also ve a lot of respects for u.so y do u let urself down by doing so.though i ve a very little knwldg in ur music field bt i m confident dat,
sumedha n poonam r far better then mauli.
another thing i wld like ask u frnds, if raja and anek are being hyped den wat is deir fault in it?dey r innocent.
In my view the top5 rating sld be: RAJA,ANEK,AMANAT,MUSSARAT,SUMEDHA.
so..i realy hope zee tv n al da mentors ll realise deir faults.
lets keep watching SAREGAMAPA.
LETS GO WITH QUALITY VOICE NOT WITH ANY GLAMOUR……
sory if anybody hurts !
“MANOJ”
Vijay
That was hilarious but i am scared if we log on to nagarbhai’s site probably,they have connected to vote bank & may be they will count our visit as one vote for her.so better to be away!
@basumatika
I think these people are better organised than that, either they have already made arrangements with Zee for Mauli or they have paid (outsourced) people in villages in Gujarat to vote for Mauli.
Let’s see what she sings in front of Laloo.
@Vijay
Right+ zee’s creative director & many of them (including)so called guru’s r Gujju! in addition buying votes for M’s family is easy as if u convert $ in rs u get about 39Rs so simple.Now it’s a prestige issue for her family as 50 lac is only little above $1,00,000.Not much!
Gujju lobby is influencing the results in favor of judges.
1st of all i want to tell everyone tat m completely agree wid manoj coz i think raja n aneek r innocent, they deserve to be in finals & amanat,harpreet n mussarat r awsome.recollect aneek’s prev perfomences,,,his selection was no so easy…but he sung flowless..n raja is d best among all coz he sings from his heart ..wid feel…i dont want to talk abt mauli…coz i dont like her singin n her voice bullshit…
so last but not d least vote for good singers n if contestent hyped too much dan wat is deir fault in it….???? so keep votin….for ur fav. singer….[but plz dont vote for mauli...plz...plz....plz....]
I believe tat ztv is manipulating the results…mauli is being hyped for no reason..
when bappi said i have mauli..i almost puked…
“evil be suckyra of india” “evil proof”
i bet she does suck good ..tats y all of them praise her…
n if she goes on further…the judges shld just contemplate suicide….
stop praising music if u wanna praise a besuri nasal screamer like mauli…
saraswati ki puja karte ho..aur aisi besuri ko praise karte ho…doob maro salo!
n if there r so many who dont hate her…howcome she is still there…n more so..no1 in international voting…. *puke*
i went to the nagar community…n everyone is full of praise for her…ive left a nasty comment n i know d blog owner wont put tat up coz they r a biased lot…
n i felt so bad when the judges called only 1 each from their gharana…wat abt the others….mussarat, poonam, sumedha, harpreet r zillion times betta than tat besuri….
n in fact its an insult for the rest of the contestants to be on the same stage as the besuri nasal screamer..
n akki…my respect for u have grown much more….they way u refused mauli….man i luv u for tat…
n wat he said abt not knowing abt sur taal tat was a direct slap on the judges’ faces…
its not rocket science to know wat he actually meant….
i think when vishal said tat mauli’s voice is tired…wat he meant was…stop giving blow jobs…