Review of 17th August Episode of Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenge 2007
Today is going to be elimination episode and as you know three Pakistani contestants Amanat Ali, Mussarat and Junaid are in the bottom three. This episode is going to be very interesting as this has created lots of controversy and arguments amongst the mentors and contestants as well…so lets start the review of this magical show..
Group Performance:
The show commences with Mauli, Sumedha and Poonam singing Aaj ki raat from Don.. They are standing among the crowd and singing.. The boys enter the stage and they too sing the same song.. The girls join the boys in the stage.. Aditya is there in the yellow room and there is a photo frame where there is a question mark.. That is who will be eliminated next? The nine participants faces are displayed one by one on the frame.. Harpreet is holding two cards – Congrats and Hard Work.. It coincides with the lyrics of the song – Aaaj ki raat hona hain kyaa..
Todays theme –
Aditya says today the theme is dance numbers and calls the Josh gharana to know the results first..
Before the results were announced, Ismailji says – Let them first perform and then we can know the results.. Lets first enjoy them singing as because of the tension the performance is getting affected..
So, its decided that first there will be performance..
Results for Josh Gharana –
Mauli sings Aisa jadoo daala re from Khakee
Sumedha sings Its time to disco from Kal Ho na ho
Bappida – This dance numbers is my favorite and I bought the Disco songs which is going on now also.. Mauli – I am thankful to you.. I am not commenting more.. You are popular and leave it to public to decide.. Sumedha – the way you sang it was mindblowing.. It was like listening to the recorded one.. You did a great job..
Himesh – The way Sumedha sang today was excellent.. Her voice will suit all the leading actress.. If someone sings like this – they will go very far and have bright future..
Results for Josh Gharana:
Mauli - Last week performance is shown in the AV and also the comments from the mentors for her is shown.. She is shown green signal.. She then does the vote appeal and thanks everyone who voted her..
Sumedha - Before the result, an AV is shown.. Aditya says she got the opportunity to go to her home town Rajnadh Gao.. She comes out of the airport and there is huge welcome for her.. there are people who have crowded her and put Mala for her and welcome her.. She travels in car to her house.. There too she has a huge welcome.. There is dance and music.. Her parents says till she was 2.5 years, she did not talk.. Only few words she used to talk but then she became good singer.. There are lot of prizes she has got, that is also shown.. Her childhood pics are also shown.. She goes to her school, goes to her class.. On blackboard words praising her and welcoming her is written.. She says she used to be a back bencher but never did masti.. Teachers used to take class and they used to sleep.. She then rides her bike and goes to the temple.. She says she had prayed a lot and asked for wishes here.. She believes she will win and only then come back.. She is going back home after seven months..
Sumedha also gets the green light
Results of Hit-It Gharana:
Harpreet sings Soni pe nakhre from Partner
Junaid sings Kaal title song..
Raja sings Chinamma Chikamma from Meenaxi.. The female voice is given in background by Sumedha and Mauli
Comments from VS:
Shekhar to Harpreet – You have become a rockstar.. You are performing as well as singing well..
Junaid – Anthra was good.. But the Mukhda was not that great.. You need to look Harpreet for inspiration..
Raja – the lyrics you write in hand so you can read it when you forget – Avoid doing it.. You have a powerful voice.. Just now was saying Bappida that this industry has got one new voice today..
Vishal to Junaid – It was looking as if you are depressed.. Think this also as your own home and put in the energy.. Im concentrating on you because you are a great singer..
To Raja – We were the one to bring the versatility issue everytime.. Now even you have to come out of Kailash and Sukhwinder songs and sing other songs to become a mainstream singer
Results:
Raja also got the opportunity to go to his hometown.. He is also taken from the airport to his place Bikaner.. He says he wants to fly and reach home soon.. His dad comes in car to meet him as he was unable to wait for him at home.. He receives a grand welcome.. There is lot of lighting and fireworks.. His performance is shown in large screen.. The whole crowd gathers his house and he is unable to come out of his house.. He says his Grandfather was Raj Gavaiya in Rajasthan and his father was a Ghazal singer. He meets his sister who is a spastic child and says he had to climb from his neighbour’s top floor to come and meet her as the fans were not allowing him to come out..
He says I have struggled a lot.. Please pray that I should not make any mistake.. I am a bhulakkad no,. 1.. Vishal says we all are musicians and we can also forget things.. Dont worry, just leave it to god..
Raja gets Green..
Harpreet - Aditya says he took the mud from Jalian wala bagh for his previosu performance.. The AV of his performance is shown He also gets green..
Junaid - Aditya says Junaid spread the word of peace and friendship last week.. He is shown Yellow signal..
Vishal – You have been singing so well.. We are anyway going to record an album with you.. Dont worry about it..
Aditya announes that this time Raja has got the highest votes and gives him the watch.. Mauli is the first in international votes..
Results of Rock Gharana:
Mussarat sings chakna chakna from Namaste London
Aneek sings Shakalaka Boom Boom title song
Comments from Himesh:
These two songs are sung by me and it is very difficult to sing songs that are made for a particular singer and particular style.. But they both have done a great job.. So, request public to keep supporting them..
Result:
Aneek – Gets Green
Mussarat – Gets Yellow
Aneek’s previous performance is shown.. Aditya also announces that he is no.2 this week and also that he is only 500 votes behind from Raja.. Himesh says Raja has a big fan following him and competing with such fentabulous singer is very tough.. You also try to make your fan base strong.. Learn his good qualities from him.. Aneek says he not only learns from Raja bhaiyah, but also Amanat and Mussarat.. He says today is Mussarat’s birthday..
Lets all wish him Happy Birthday – Happy Birthday Mussarat
Himesh then asks what do you learn from Amanat?? only music or something else also? Then he asks what is happening with that person? He asks who? Himesh says – dont act too innocent.. Then Aneek says my love is music and i am here to concentrate on that.. Promise that there is no other issue.. They show Sumedha for a moment though
Mussarat’s previous performance is shown.. He gets yellow.. He says whatever public has decided I will accept.. They have given lot of love and affection.. I am so happy.. Vishal says – You have good spirit..
Results of Yalgaar Gharana:
Poonam sings Khallas from Company
Amanat sings Bhijuria from Sonu Nigam album..
Ismailji – Poonam is a very good singer who tries to sing all genre songs.. But you have to improve a lot to win this competition.. Amanat is not a performer because he is very shy.. Dont know for what reason you are afraid.. Dont be and sing without fear.. There is something to say, which I will say later on..
Results:
Poonam – gets green
Amanat – gets yellow..
All the contestant in yellow room are called on stage.. Aditya asks Ismailji to comment on this.. He asks if they had refused to sing Indian Patriotic song.. All the three refuse that they have never said this.. Always they wanted to only spread peace all over the country and never felt they are there in some other country as they have got so much love and affection..
Amanat says – they will never think of saying something like this
Mussarat – we have come hear to sing and we thought we will sing for other people..
Junaid – There is so much in the media, in the news channel – in the newspapers that we refused to sing.. But it is not like this.. We got so much love that we never missed the hometown but for the past two days we are missing them..
Aditya says – this news was spread only by some Indian or Pakistani who does not want that there be any friendship between the countries..
Junaid says – If someone feels that because of them some kind of hatred is being spread – then we will go back now itself..
All the contestants are crying a lot.. Everyone are sad.. The whole set is standstill..
Then a message comes – To Be Continued……….
So, the results will be out only tomorrow
Written by Anu
Technorati: saregamapa, Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenge 2007, saregamapa challenge 2007
WOW…someone went overboard…
i just read all of the comments, and i am pretty agree with it, zee tv shouldn’t let that girl stay in, i don’t think so she is glamorizing the show or something… anyways its not about paki or Indian,its all about music. I am a paki from Lahore now in usa, i know paki dudes r good but all of other contestants have a great talent ….like Anek he is damn good, i dont think so he did even one mistake in any performance he is like a born singer and Raja he got some thing divine in his voice, basically i am a fan of Mussrat but to be honest he is doin big mistakes by choosing wrong song or by performing bad on stage or by losing confidence on stage or whatever is it… i wish he stay in competition till end but he have to work hard for it cuz all of 9 singers r like 9 wonders of the world “eik say bar kay eik….all the best to all of u contestant of sa ra ga ma pa, keep singing….love u all
IQBAL
We all knew it already, but still it was heartbreaking to see Junaid, Amanat and Musarrat in trishanku.
Junaid looked very depressed in his performance too. I hope he gets some counselling and jumps back on track by the next show. I missed his usual energy. It was heartbreaking when he said he misses his home.
Harpreet was good today. He made me laugh. Very nice work
I hope the public will vote for him.
Raja – More air time he gets, more chances he will be our next Pradhan mantri
It was funny when Vishal cut him off during his speech. Kind of rudely too. Raja does come off as a cheezy vote seeker. But hey he is singing amazingly well too. So whats my problem !
Aneek – he was really cute the way he put his foot in mouth today
when he asked for votes. But that shows the simple and genuine nature of a person. I like him better than Raja just for this reason. Flawless singing as always.
Amanat was super again today. Bless him. He is my fav in this show. Very happy to know he, Junaid and Poonam are already recording songs for movies.
Sumedha was good today as well. Again not mindblowing. Again, she got away in this Mouli/Pak controversy.
Mouli – Everyone knows Mouli was below standard last week, even KAPIL DEV said so. Kapil who admitted not having any great knowledge of music, said she sang very badly. Mouli herself admitted she was bad. The judges gave her 7s and an all time low of 5 even. What more proof do we want that it was bad show by her. And she got voted No.1 in intl. votes !!
Somehow I have lost interest in this show in the past week. More than singing talent show, this is more like PR talent show.
Whats the use of watching and voting if there is no corelation between performances and votes. I am sure the contestants are feeling the same way too. Why should they sing their lungs out to impress anyone??? There is no guarantee that if they sing well they’ll get votes. Instead they all should practice public speeking.
All you need to win this show is to have been born in a strategic geographical area !!
- Senty
Wow what a show, isn’t this show suppose to be about peace, love, togetherness, and friendship, but look at the turns its taken. Now mauli seriously has to go. how many times does it have to be repeated here on the site that people will understand that she has to leave, i mean it kinda gets tiring of repeating the fact that cause of mauli other good singers have to leave the show.don’t tell me people jus want her in the show because she is from the U.S. as for today’s episode that is sad, but all you three(amanat,junaid,and mussarat)know that you are very good singers and you don’t have anything to worry about, jus chill and relax, and im sure no one is getting eliminated, its just a twist in the show. so all of you just smile, cause god is with you and so are the people that know what true musicians are, unlike mauli voters.
mussarat ur excellent i hope u remain in saregamapa!!!
This is the first time when saregamapa has introduced such a third class siger like mauli. i know that one by one all will get eliminated and ultimately the winner would be one.but this is an injustice to all the contestants who are being discouraged. she is shown better than ather contestants. this time i would suggest all the mentors and gajendra to decide not to eliminate anyone. i am sure that this would create differences amongst us as it is the time when we got independence. this is not acorrect time. this will create a wrong feeling amongst the pakistanis.even i know that the winner will be an indian, but pakistani’s elimination should not be due to their independence song, but due their weak performances. pls take a good decision today.
I am very sad seeing these abuses. To all who are writing bad things about these singers, my humble request is to sing even 10% closer to what they are singing and show it to the world. let me see how much abuse you get for your singing.
…..dude srsly…. Mauli is by far the worst singer ever on sa re ga ma pa. such good singers have left and yet she gets all the votes….its bs. stupid voters…
I am from the U.S. and me and my family think that Mauli has no talent! She sucks! We are very sad that all the partictpants from Pakistan got a yellow signal
- Paki Pride!!
gosh ppl are saying how the pakis should be out just like mauli well ya need to open up ur head and think outside the box!!! stop bringing politics in the show!!
well amanat,mussarat and junaid are the best singers out there along with aneek and raja and they didnt deserve to be in the bottom 3……and all of them at once?? like come on that was soooooooo scripted just to make a bigger scene and make the show just more viewed. ZEE has given these great singers soooo much and i think now is NOT the time to start all these controversies between pakistanis and indians….thats just SOOOO narrow minded and stupid! well its sooo obvious zee not gonna let any pakistani win cuz all though pakistanis want to make peace some ppl just still dont wanna be one….whatev so what u ppl gotta say about this?
yes i agree with the above statement. even i hate mauli and her mentor bappi. but using such abusive languages…we people don’t worth saying all this.i would pray that mauli should be out asap, before the top 5 series begins.
thats true dude. Sach hamesha kadwa hota hai. Mauli’s mom & dad were shown in some previous episode. C for urself.
You sick minded person!!!!
Ew, I can’t believe how you even THINK of posting this sort of crap.
How would you like it if someone said that about YOU???
And to the person that replied to the sick-minded person’s post:
OMG CAN’T YOU SEE THAT THAT PERSON HATES MAULI AND IS MAKING UP TRASH ABOUT HER???
And:
“Mauli looks like a man”
The above statement proves that you are blind.
Get a life, people!
My humble request to the site owner ($hashi): take down this sort of trash. Thanks! =] This site is getting defaced by such gross people.
And for the record, I am NOT a random Mauli lover, neither am I related to her in any way. The point I am trying to make is “Please don’t say such crap stuff!”
Mauli voters reacting…. oooooohhhhh they arrrrr sooooo pisseddddd
oh pls ppl having the best singers amanat junaid nad mussarat in the bottom three n giving singers like mauli and sumedha green is an insult to this show i wonder what are the voters doing-i mean if u ppl think that mauli sings well sorry she screams and about somebody saying to sing 10% closer to these singers so my answer to that is that we are the public we dont sing we decide whether they sing well or not and mauli is the worst singer on the show some1 go tell that bappida he needs to clean up his ears cuz he cannot hear wat crap mauli sings-compare mauli with amanat mussarat and junaid n then tell me who deserves to be in the competition mauli should have been out way b4 but shes just in the show to get more viewers when i think its happening the other way round they are loosing veiwers becuz of mauli-mauli get out of the show you do not deserve to be here pls some1 get her out-shes spoiling the show-u guys remember how awful mauli sang for the independence day episode yet she gets a green signal-i never felt so much hatred for mauli but now since the three best singers are in the bottom three i really hate her-ehhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh all i can guess out from this decision is that the pakistani contestants voting is very high and so the saregamapa crew feels afraid that what if a pakistani singer wins the competition, its going to be a black spot(dhaba) on INDIA and trust me whoever wrote that “the winner will be an indian” its not necessary, the winner will be the one with the best voice and it could be a pakistani,indian or someone from overseas so stop assuming stuff from the begining u never know what can happen so keep ur idiotic ideas to urself rather than saying them out n proving urself as an idiot…..i m really irritated by fridays episode trust me if it wasnt my loss i would have crashed my tv screen….
Please correct me if I am wrong, But I think the song Junaid sang for independence day was from indian film.
Mussrat, Amanat,Junaid all are having offers from bollywood. Its saregama’s loss if these 3 best singers go out. By keepin Mauli saregama is loosin all my respect. I for one would not watch saregama if Mauli survives and better singers are kicked out.
Request to Saregama management: Bring back the old system of having expert neutral judges picking the winner. Damn with the public voting. Paki singers despite being better have a disadvantage in this system.
Dear Admin,
Please stop this website. The purpose of the website is totally lost. Cycos have found this site and are writing rubbissh.
Please please stop this website.
even i like all the three, no wonder they sing any song. i just appreciate their singing but i know a lot of injustice is being done to them in this show. that’s the reason why i say that our expectation is of no use unless all of them support them.
any guess on the typical characteristics of mauli voters
Hey GUYS,
If you are still wondering why Mouli is still there even after so much of BAD singing.. I would say the FULL credit should go to ZEE TV. Its a business stratergy to keep MOULI IN the contest so that ZEE TV will start doing GOOD BUSINESS in USA. The worst thing that can happen to Singing, Where so much talent is there and maestros are there. So you guys pls stop scolding MOULI. Even She is prepared to go.. BUT ZEE TV is not ready to allow her to leave. Come on GUYs.. its really SAD if you have not undersyood this cheap stunt till Now.
Well done ZEE TV.. keep it.. TRY earing Money in that name of MUSIC.. GOOD Stunt.
Aneek,Raja,Mussarat,Amanat,Junaid and Poonam are the best singers in saregama. They will find their roti eventually.
So true music lovers: Just Chill out.
hey all…
yeah I am too a BIG fan of this show… i dnt have any personal enimty with mauli.. but i guess merely judging her from performance skills would be inappropriate when there are competitors who are FAR better…
Raja u r gr8… but the most versatile singer is Aneek..and amongst the girls Poonam.. she is most wonderful female singer i hv heard in last soo many yrs who is sooo perfect.. it almost feels v r hearing a recorded version than a stage show performance..u r my favourite.. I am amazed with peoples judgement who r not considering singing abilities while voting..
I think the weakest singers in the link are mussarat, sumedha and punjab the puttar..
my votes for poonam, aneek n raja…
amanat n junaid u r very gud.. junaid u remind me of some`1 very special to my heart whom i have lost for ever.. so every time i see u.. i get the moments of bliss..
my gud luck to all of u..best of luck
hey guys…
i am so amazed that y such an underrated singer like mauli is given soo much importance in this forum.. by praises or abuses.. we are still r thinking about her… why not talk abt blessed singer like poonam.. who sings flwalessly.. 1 of the most powerful singer i hv heard in in last so many yrs.. n believe me tell her to sing all the shitt songs that mauli sings.. n I am sure she will rock it harder than her…
this comepition has become more of publicity ground than singing talent.. with mouli competiting with singers of such standards…
annek n raja are so flawless… no1 can say they are ametuers… so perfect.. it feels when raja, aneek n poonam sings.. u r hearing a recording than a live performance…
junaid n amanat u rocks.. n my hearty wishes with u…amanat u a such a neat singer.. i just wish.. u put in more efforts in ur performance along with singing.. u will rock..
junaid.. i lov u… as it u remind me of some1 very special to my heart.. i alwaz feel in bliss when i see u perform..
my appeal to every1 who watches this show.. just kick this mauli crap out and stop giving her any importance, instead,,, concentrate on real talent like poonam, aneek, raja, amanat n junaid…
STOP VOTING FOR MAULIIII
SHE IS THE WORST SINGER IN THE HISTORY OF THIS WORLD….IT IS PURE EVIL KEEPING HER IN THIS SHOW…DEVILISH I TELL U
I FEEL FOR THE 3 PAKI SINGERS…THEY DON’T DESERVE TO GO…ZEETV SHOULD PREVENT THEM FROM LEAVING…OTHERWISE SGMP IS HISTORY
ITS TOO BAD POLITICS HAD TO GET INTO A MUSIC TV SHOW…SAD
if any of the three..mussarat junaid or amanat have to leave this show 2morrow..its gunna be a very unfair decision…i personally do not HATE mauli..because she DOES show some talent in her genre of singing..but come on guyz..its obvious dat after last weeks performance she shudve been outtttt!!..i think they’re jes keepin her in the show to make ppl talk abt sumthin and create controversy…JUNAID i lovee uu..and if u have to leave..im gunna stop watchin this show…i really feel bad for the 3 pakistani singers because all of them seem so nice and they keep nothing in their hearts against India..as a matter of fact..Junaid DID SING AN INDIAN SONG!!..so y r ppl talkin shit abt them n creatin unnecessary problems?..so wut if the other 2 sang songs from their country..i thought this show was supposed to bring peace..guess not…
yeah you guys befor i write anything, i’d like to say stop using abusive and inapropriate language. many respectful people and familes like me read these comments to see whats going on. I saw some very nasty things and i thought that was awful.
and by the way, zee tv requested the three pkai guys to sing songe from their countries because they wanted to celebrate independence. and the media made up the story of the paki guys refusing to sing indian songs. that was a lie because junaid did sing an indian song. so please dont get mixed up in this complication and just continue voting for them. thank you.
~much love from me
Hello everyone….
OK…I actualy watched Friday’s episode on http://www.muft.tv…and let me just say the whole show looked so damn fake. I mean you can tell the whole thing was totally scripted. Junaid,Musarrat,and Amant did not act surprised at all when they went into trishanku…they acted like they were expecting it and it is obvious that they knew and even the mentors knew what was going on…When they were looking at the signals you could tell they were just waiting for that yellow light…and none of them sang truly with their heart…They were all in a bad mood…Junaid was depressed…Amanat seemed pissed offf…and Musarrat seened like he just did not care anymore…They half-heartedly gave their performances and then took their seats in the yellow room in a ver dignified manner…They already knew what was goin on because usually when contestants are in the yellow room…they are holdong their head,not talking,just looking at the screen…Amanat and Musarrat talked the whole time and acted very casual as if nothing bad was happenin because THEY JUST DID NOT CARE ANYMORE…However…in the end when all three guys were called on satge all threee made ver nice comments and the way they spoje truly touched ppl’s heart…especially Junaid…his last line(we’ll leave if indo-pak relations are suffering b/c of us)was just great…Kudos to these guys for the way they handled themselves…Obviiously they were all expecting to go into the yellow room and had time to think it over that’s why they didn’t seem at all surprised or aanxious…Anyway…I realize that a pakistani singer will not win this show..although Amanat should b/c Raja is a lot of hype…Aneek is better than him…anyway good luck to Amanat,Junaid,and Musarrat and Aneek and Poonam…these ppl are truly deservong…and even if Amant,Junaid,and Musarrat don;t win they have represented their country ver well…and Pakistan is proud to bring up fine intelligent young men like them….See the link at the bottom of the page and watch the show…then you will truly know what I mean…
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SUoXx4sVj7U
sorry wrong link guys…her is the real link for the august 17th episode…and btw…my top 5
Amant
Aneek
Junaid
Musarrat
Poonam
I just hope Mauli doesnt win…Raja Harpreet and Sumedha are all tremendous singers but Raja lacks versatility while the top 5 I listed above just have better voice quality(just my opinion)…anyway…let’s hope that his whole drama does not create too many Indo-Pak controversies…may the most deserving win…Pakistani or Indian
ha damn it im havin technichal difficulties with the link…her it is though
http://www.muft.tv/index.php?option=com_content&task=category§ionid=15&id=1730&Itemid=119
Dear friends, i read all the comments you guys gave and i think almost all of them were aainst Mouli. believe me, i am a quite good singer and will try to go and sing in India. That is why i am a huge fan of all singing shows like SAREGAMAPA, VOI, and Indian Idol. But Saregamapa is the best but when i saw those three outstanding singers in bottom three, my eyes were open for like a minute. And when i heard that Mouli got the highest international votes, that was another biggest shcok of all time. I am a very kind person that is why i won’t say anything bad about Maoli, i would just ask her that how would she feel if she would sing like those three singers and someone else like you have gotton the highest vote. I was happy that both countries are becoming friends but to see that, tears just came in my eyes when i saw those three angels standing in the bottom three so lonely… this is the world guys rafi saab, kishoreda, nusrat saab must be crying in their graves. shame on all the voters who are voting by seeing their look, nationality and their religion. very very disppointed. i had planing to go india and try in saregamapa but after seeing this all, i am just speechless. Mussarat, junaid, ammanat, raja, poonam and aneek don’t worry my friends, jiska koi nahin uska to khuda hai yarooo
ah harpreet changed his music style and type of songs.. and thats why he receives good comments from the guru’s
stop this challenge.. its not cool to see this challenge, it made me even cry after those words of pakistani’s
Mauli should IMMEDIATELY be thrown out of the show….
I think Aneek and Amanat are the best in the lot…both are versatile…But Aneek gets an edge due to his flawless and effortless singing in all the episodes…He is so consistent, it just amazing….
Raja Hasan is good in his genre but seems more like a politician than a singer…He knows how to get sympathy votes…:)
Going by the trend of voting, Raja seems to be the eventual winner…Because when it comes to vote, the Indian people seem to always choose the wrong one, be it in music or politics or whatever…
http://www.saregamapa.rediff.com/
Top 5 video’s and mauli’s performance is at the 3rd place.. how is that possible..
The treatment given to pakistani singers was too shamefull they were hurt and more than them their fellow indian contestant were hurt who watch them being mistreated helplessly which resulted in them bursting into tears. Raja, Poonam, Harpreet, Aneek, Mauli and Sumedha they all were looking like most helpless people in the world who wanted their pakistani freind to feel like home here but were unable to stop fanatic’s who wanted them to feel like away from home. Amanat, Junaid, Mussarat I am sorry for what you have gone throuh but Raja, Poonam, Harpreet, Aneek, Mauli and Sumedha I feel more sorry for You as these bloody idiot fanatic’s lets you down. Junaid and sumedha I loved you guy’s in saregamapa hungama when you were saying jaihind and pakistan zindabad please keep up the good spirit and never let these people win over love.
Indian people are good but Zee TV are bound to obey the top finincer and every one should understand that at this level performance are being judge on regional basis and many other factors( I don’t want to disclose) not only singing. You have an example of Mauli When Ashaji rate gave her negativly then she sang same previous song(Mayya-mayya)..
So don’t worry.. If you out today, they you all(3) should not perform at all. It’s a diplomatic game not show.
Do not disregard….i respect Sa Re Ga Ma Pa the effort of Indo-Pak Friendship; But the long term root of biases …it will take time. Zee TV should stop this melodramas of let all participant cry ,,just watch if you recorded the show. Or watch DVD when this melodrama was going on producer made all participants crying like they lost their life (It was exaggerated) and three “Trishanku’s facial gestures …look again care fully …any one can say (Not a drop of tears) not melodrama purely drama to speak words …all were crying heartfelty and three were speaking the word of emotional blackmailing as it was clearly seen by gestures like …”How they make others cry …and making FOOL with innocent face and innocent voice..…watch it again with minute observation.
It is history see the following link …..how many Indian Actors ban in Pakistan ….even Pakistan Ban to show Indian Film till last year. Why this?
http://www.apunkachoice.com/happenings/20060125-0.html
http://www.apunkachoice.com/happenings/20060519-0.html
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/4784819.stm
If you are talking about Patriotism to India be patriotic please. I do not know whether they REFUSED to sing Indian Patriotic Song or not ….but as this issue aroused……Come on and let all three participants to sing Indian Patriotic song and let them show some friendship for India and give them a Chance to WIN Indian Patriotic People. OR STOP this MELODRAMA and I know it will never happen. AND let Result …and eliminate the one who got less Vote. Many time all three Indian were in Trishanku right? And all judges agreed my God it was wrong elimination. On the name of Independence Day or elimination Kisiko Bhikh deneki jaroorat nahi hey.
And for your information all sing patriotic song of the other country when they go to function in other country…that’s the protocol.
Agar judges are Patriotic and TAKAT Hey to …..Make friendship like this …let all Indian Participant Sing Pakistan Patriotic song and all Pakistani Participant sing Indian Patriotic song ….make friendship like this. But Indian’s are emotional and Bevkuff.
Hey guyz…
could someone please divert everybody’s attention towards a more serious matter than jus unleashing the big HATORADE on that poor girl Mauli….C’mon I dont like her singing either..NO DOUBT that she is weakest of all crowd – BUT I dont hate her. She is ONLY there caz u guyz voted for her. If u dont want her..here is tip..DONT VOTE FOR HER ! ez.
Imoportant matter is that SRGMP has become more ova political venue than a Tru Talent competition. Pakistani – Indian…what the hell is that-Isnt it an International show ???
Mussarat Amanat and Junaid… Stop being apologetic about something that u guyz dint even do. If We are proud to be Indians – U should be proud of ur own country. I dont think u should ve even changed the words of the songs that u sang and take PAKISTAN outta all of ur songs. THis is exactly what happens when u dont take pride in urself- people walk all over you.
Be good and hold ur head up high. U R representing ur country – U should be proud of that.
I think someone above made a valid point and i would just like to dwelve on it further.
a. Mauli’s winning,staying in the show is not her fault,she is there because Zee wants her. Zee is aiming at gaining viewership internationally.
b. Every person who has heard Indian music will agree on how weak Mauli is in comparison to others, the reason to get upset is that the “Guru’s” specially Bappi and Shekhar seem very partial towards her.
c. The 18th August episode everyone sang well, but Poonams “performance” was said to be “lacking” something as per Bappi. Hey Bappi this is a Singing competion and not a ” Dance and Performance” competion. Maybe he thought he was on Indian Idol. While Mauli sang her song, did anyone check when she started the song she was totally “besur”, she did pick up and sing well later. But also check how the chorus supported her during the Alaap’s.
d. For me Raja, Aneek, Sumedha, Poonam, Amanat are very good. Junaid and Musarat are ok, Mauli is Bad.
For all Mauli supporters, If you think She sang Mayya Mayya so beautifully, check Sumitra Iyers performance on Star Voice.
I think Saregama is a farce, watch Star Voice, the Singing quality is much better.
Because of Mauli and wrongly supporting her from the judgement side,every week the good singers are voting out. I was quite astonished even the audience sent to Amanat two times to TRISHANKU. I would like to request the Indian & USA Audience that they should listen the music from their ear/heart not from their eyes. Its very important to show respect to the appropriate singers.
amanat is the best
mussarat is the best singer, maybe
There is absolute no doubts that Amanat is the best. Because he is only the great versatile singer and the heart of SAREGAMAPA. Among the singers he has only the great unique voice. His voice reminds nobody except himself. On the other hand if you carefully look at another singers like Aneek, Musaarrat, Raja their voice reminds you the singer like Sonu Nigam, Nusrat Fateh Sahab, Shukvinder. Yes Junaid, Poonam has also their own voice but they are not up to the level of Amanat. Truth is always bitter.
Hey all..I just created a poll site whereby you(public) can vote online for which contestant will be eliminated each Friday night.
Please go to
http://saregamapa2007vote.blogspot.com/
to cast your votes.
This poll will provide a brief analysis whether the results are similiar on Saregampa show.
So come on and vote for the singer who you think must be eliminated next Friday.
HaMMeR
Please vote for Poonam, Raja, Sumedha, Amanat, Don’t vote to mouli
Hi mauli
You are realy sakira dear…..u have to win the final……..I love to watch u,, so please vote for her……….
Amrit
Hi Mauli is very good singer no doubt but since I heard about Poonam’s story I thought If Poonam is so good without any family support than how fantastic she would be if she would have the family environment like Mauli all parent and grand parents are singer. Mauli got that talent from her family but Poonam born with that talent.We should tell our poor people that if you have talent no body can stop you.My vote for Poonam
SUMEDHA IS GOOD SIGNER WITH POTENTIAL… SHE DESERVE TO BE IN FINAL.
SUMEDHA U R THE BEST AND U DESERVE TO BE WIN..
I MUST TELL YOU LOOK VERY GOOD.RAJA, AMANAT, MUSSARAT AND ANEEK ARE GOOD SINGERS AS WELL. POONAM IS OKAY BUT NOT THAT GOOD.
MAULI SHOULD LIVE NOW.. THERE ARE BETTER SINGERS THAN HER..
SUMEDHAAAAAAAAAA SHUD STAY TO VOTE FOR HER.
SUMEDHA LOOK GOOD WITH ADITYA NARAYAN…
MAULI KE GANE KA EK HEE STYLE… EVERYTIME SHE CHOOSE SAME SONG.. WE R GETTING BORED..
RAJA, AMANAT, SUMEDHA , ANEEK ARE GOOD.. KEEP IT UP GUYS..
MAULI SHUD LEAVE NOW.. WE SHUD GIVE CHANCE TO BETTER SINGERS..