Comments on: Videos of 27th July Episode of Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenge 2007

By: Pradeep

Pradeep — Thu, 02 Aug 2007 08:46:00 +0000

The judges have been very lenient. They have been giving marks lavishly. For god sake, judge the singers properly. A perfect 10 should be the rarest of rare score. Bappida, in the very first elimination round, had been judging correctly and giving marks appropriately based on the singing. But the other judges particularly Ismail Darbar and Himesh Reshamiya were lavishing marks to the participants and even prompting other judges to give high marks thereby bringing down the standard of judging. For God Sake, please judge them based on their singing.

By: Guru of surs

Guru of surs — Wed, 01 Aug 2007 19:53:00 +0000

Today amanat aneek and musharrat sang good.

By: Anonymous

Anonymous — Tue, 31 Jul 2007 04:10:00 +0000

To the guy above -
Jai Hindustan !!

By: Anonymous

Anonymous — Sun, 29 Jul 2007 19:38:00 +0000

There is no over seas or world competition. Every one knows that no country can beat india’s population when they vote. So there is no way that anyone else can win beside some one form India or Indian back ground. This is the truth. This is good that others are given a chance. But india is ahead in music and every one knows that too.

By: Preity36

Preity36 — Sun, 29 Jul 2007 09:23:00 +0000

@ comment above.

I think it is naive to say there is no racism but I believe that voting is not just a result of that. People are biased, let's face that! If it's not the patriotism, it's regional preference an kinmanship, if not that it's for the looks and entertainment rather than talent or it's simply for guys rather than girls.. so you see voting unfortunately it's not only happening as a result of peoples that day performance - I wish it would.

If voting was just based on the performance we would have a different group by now [i.e. more girls, did you forget Reecha?] and I don't think that Mussarat deserved to be in the bottom three. I think Nirupama deserved to be out, but I am afraid Poonam might follow, not because she deserves to get the lowest votes but because she is not sexy and maybe doesn't have as big a fan base..

I agree on Amanat, Aneek and Poonam and would add Raja to be the leading singers, and yes Mussarat isn't consistent but apart from Amanat and Aneek no one really is.

I am just hoping for a more honest voting on what people truly think was the best performance, not whom they want to be the winner for other reasons... and of course more great performances!! Thanks: )

By: Anonymous

Anonymous — Sun, 29 Jul 2007 06:17:00 +0000

Strange enough for me.. I guess the public is voting perfectly.. For all those people who thought Mussarat didnt deserve to be in bottom 3.. his performance last week wasnt good at all.. nirumpama did deserve to move out.. for me the best singers would be.. Aneek, Amanat and Poonam.. These 3 should make it to top 3… for all those people crying out racism.. I just feel sad that they are missing the point.. you have perform consistenyly to stay!!!

By: Tapan

Tapan — Sun, 29 Jul 2007 05:40:00 +0000

mussarrat sucks……raja or amanat should win the challenge

By: Anonymous

Anonymous — Sun, 29 Jul 2007 05:38:00 +0000

ohhhh now tell me everybody about mussarat abbas i read all those comments above me saying mussarat this and that. For me peoples i think should be in show is Amanat. Mussarat and poonam . i have request to everybody stop giving advertisment about mauli. can anybody tell if she deserve more than 5 or 6 . why everybody not supporting the right person.
i feel shame seeing mussarat in yellow room why ? i think mauli should be out for long time . u guys tell is there anybody who can sing like mussarat or amanat.
the song mussarat sang NFAK nobody can sing like him except amanat.
so plz plz plz support right person..

my name is
(supporter for right singers )

By: shifali

shifali — Sun, 29 Jul 2007 05:33:00 +0000

helllo people

one things for sure if i see mussarat in danger zone another time i will definetely stop watching saregamapa........
Hw can people do this yaar,hw can they put muzzrath in danger zone

n finally if i dont see Raja muzarrat n amanath in fianl i would enter sets of saregama n break my head....just jokin :0

plzzz vote properly..keep u rivalries aside n treat evryone equally

By: Anonymous

Anonymous — Sun, 29 Jul 2007 05:28:00 +0000

Ofcourse Sumedha is nasal. I am happy someone said that. Also she sings very easy songs all the time. Poonam always sings tough songs and does it well.

I am a weirdo.. I think Lataji is a perfect singer as far as sur tall etc is concerned. But no “bhav” or feelings in her voice. Ashaji has all of that. I rate Ashaji above Lataji.

Same way Sumedha is good, but no feelings… wonder why the “maha gurus” say Sumedha has “ada”, and she is the perfect singer etc.