Comments on: Review of 27th July Episode of Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenge 2007 – Third Elimination http://saregamapashow.com/2007/07/review-of-27th-episode-of-sa-re-ga-ma.html Fan site of Zee TV's Saregamapa show Sat, 31 Dec 2011 10:51:48 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.2 By: Anonymous http://saregamapashow.com/2007/07/review-of-27th-episode-of-sa-re-ga-ma.html/comment-page-1#comment-2518 Anonymous Wed, 01 Aug 2007 22:31:00 +0000 http://saregamapashow.pap-smear.org/?p=137#comment-2518 I think all of the remaining contestants are pretty good. There are a few exceptional ones out of this entire list. They are as follows:<br/><br/>1. Amanat<br/>2. Anik<br/>3. Mussarat<br/>4. Raja<br/>5. Poonam<br/><br/>The ones left out from the above list are good singers and have performed well some of the time, but definitely not all of the time. <br/><br/>Some suggestions to the show producers regarding the upcoming "Maha Gurus":<br/><br/>1. Dev Anand & Dilip Kumar (Songs from 50s and 60s)<br/>2. Lataji - She is so great that she can't share the stage with anyone else. (Obviously all songs from Lataji)<br/>3. Rajesh Khanna & Sharmila Tagore (Songs from their films)<br/><br/>It is already determined that the songs from 50s/60s/70s are the best songs that have been written, composed, and sung in the history of Indian cinema. Why not continue to showcase these songs with the formats suggseted above.<br/><br/>Keep up the great work!!!<br/><br/>Shad Khan - Atlanta, GA (USA) I think all of the remaining contestants are pretty good. There are a few exceptional ones out of this entire list. They are as follows:

1. Amanat
2. Anik
3. Mussarat
4. Raja
5. Poonam

The ones left out from the above list are good singers and have performed well some of the time, but definitely not all of the time.

Some suggestions to the show producers regarding the upcoming “Maha Gurus”:

1. Dev Anand & Dilip Kumar (Songs from 50s and 60s)
2. Lataji – She is so great that she can’t share the stage with anyone else. (Obviously all songs from Lataji)
3. Rajesh Khanna & Sharmila Tagore (Songs from their films)

It is already determined that the songs from 50s/60s/70s are the best songs that have been written, composed, and sung in the history of Indian cinema. Why not continue to showcase these songs with the formats suggseted above.

Keep up the great work!!!

Shad Khan – Atlanta, GA (USA)

]]> By: Anonymous http://saregamapashow.com/2007/07/review-of-27th-episode-of-sa-re-ga-ma.html/comment-page-1#comment-2300 Anonymous Mon, 30 Jul 2007 00:52:00 +0000 http://saregamapashow.pap-smear.org/?p=137#comment-2300 I completely agree with Surili above. The comment made me realize of how the standards have fallen (overall) over the years....to think this is the same show that gave us Sanjeevani and Shreya Ghosal. Even Nihira (my absolute fav) and Hemachandra were SO GOOD. I don't think it's clear to anyone any more what this show is trying to be, or what its winner is going to be -- a performer who does stage shows in New Jersey and San Jose doing cover versions of popular songs, or a playback singer? I completely agree with Surili above. The comment made me realize of how the standards have fallen (overall) over the years….to think this is the same show that gave us Sanjeevani and Shreya Ghosal. Even Nihira (my absolute fav) and Hemachandra were SO GOOD. I don’t think it’s clear to anyone any more what this show is trying to be, or what its winner is going to be — a performer who does stage shows in New Jersey and San Jose doing cover versions of popular songs, or a playback singer?

]]> By: surili http://saregamapashow.com/2007/07/review-of-27th-episode-of-sa-re-ga-ma.html/comment-page-1#comment-2167 surili Sun, 29 Jul 2007 03:37:00 +0000 http://saregamapashow.pap-smear.org/?p=137#comment-2167 "Certainly it [versatility] is needed, but speciality is very very important, just like a bharat natyam dancer can not do kathak and vice versa, and just like a heart surgeon can not perform brain surgery. Perhaps the show should try to find top singers for each type, versus a versatile performer."<br/><br/>I disagree with this. Versatility is so important, because singers who master only one genre die out when their genre falls in demand. If you remember singers like Nihira and Hemachandra from SRGMP's Challenge 2005, the reason they were so amazing was BECAUSE of their versatility. Look at legends like Lataji, Ashaji, Kishore Kumar, etc. and even contemporary singers like Sonu and Shreya...they are all so versatile. It is the defining factor of a good singer. To be good at anything, you have to polish your weaknesses as well as your strengths: it`s how you improve and move forward. “Certainly it [versatility] is needed, but speciality is very very important, just like a bharat natyam dancer can not do kathak and vice versa, and just like a heart surgeon can not perform brain surgery. Perhaps the show should try to find top singers for each type, versus a versatile performer.”

I disagree with this. Versatility is so important, because singers who master only one genre die out when their genre falls in demand. If you remember singers like Nihira and Hemachandra from SRGMP’s Challenge 2005, the reason they were so amazing was BECAUSE of their versatility. Look at legends like Lataji, Ashaji, Kishore Kumar, etc. and even contemporary singers like Sonu and Shreya…they are all so versatile. It is the defining factor of a good singer. To be good at anything, you have to polish your weaknesses as well as your strengths: it`s how you improve and move forward.

]]> By: Anonymous http://saregamapashow.com/2007/07/review-of-27th-episode-of-sa-re-ga-ma.html/comment-page-1#comment-2151 Anonymous Sat, 28 Jul 2007 20:17:00 +0000 http://saregamapashow.pap-smear.org/?p=137#comment-2151 I think voters are influenced more by the looks as far as women singers are concerned, and that is why we have seen women singers trying to be little more glamorous looking, and when they do, they seem to get more votes. Perhaps votes are also influenced by how much noise does the audience makes for a performance (performance, not song), which is bad . I don't really agree with Vishal Shekhar that versatility is required in this show. Certainly it is needed, but speciality is very very important, just like a bharat natyam dancer can not do kathak and vice versa, and just like a heart surgeon can not perform brain surgery. Perhaps the show should try to find top singers for each type, versus a versatile performer. I think voters are influenced more by the looks as far as women singers are concerned, and that is why we have seen women singers trying to be little more glamorous looking, and when they do, they seem to get more votes. Perhaps votes are also influenced by how much noise does the audience makes for a performance (performance, not song), which is bad . I don’t really agree with Vishal Shekhar that versatility is required in this show. Certainly it is needed, but speciality is very very important, just like a bharat natyam dancer can not do kathak and vice versa, and just like a heart surgeon can not perform brain surgery. Perhaps the show should try to find top singers for each type, versus a versatile performer.

]]> By: Anonymous http://saregamapashow.com/2007/07/review-of-27th-episode-of-sa-re-ga-ma.html/comment-page-1#comment-2144 Anonymous Sat, 28 Jul 2007 18:19:00 +0000 http://saregamapashow.pap-smear.org/?p=137#comment-2144 "C'mon guys - Give Mauli a break!! Learn to call a spade a spade."<br/><br/>Totally agree with you. <br/><br/>Lets call a spade a spade. Mauli needs a break from this show. Please give her the break ! “C’mon guys – Give Mauli a break!! Learn to call a spade a spade.”

Totally agree with you.

Lets call a spade a spade. Mauli needs a break from this show. Please give her the break !

]]> By: Anonymous http://saregamapashow.com/2007/07/review-of-27th-episode-of-sa-re-ga-ma.html/comment-page-1#comment-2139 Anonymous Sat, 28 Jul 2007 17:13:00 +0000 http://saregamapashow.pap-smear.org/?p=137#comment-2139 Mauli was bad. She sang the whole song in a lower note. Took the punch out of the sexy song. <br/>The above comment is well said. Mauli screws up each song to her own style. Her voice is nasal and the terrible horny sounds she makes, spoil any good song and make it sound cheap!! Mauli was bad. She sang the whole song in a lower note. Took the punch out of the sexy song.
The above comment is well said. Mauli screws up each song to her own style. Her voice is nasal and the terrible horny sounds she makes, spoil any good song and make it sound cheap!!

]]> By: Anonymous http://saregamapashow.com/2007/07/review-of-27th-episode-of-sa-re-ga-ma.html/comment-page-1#comment-2136 Anonymous Sat, 28 Jul 2007 16:39:00 +0000 http://saregamapashow.pap-smear.org/?p=137#comment-2136 C'mon guys - Give Mauli a break!! Learn to call a spade a spade. I agree, she'd been singing badly, but she seems to have sprung back to her original form. C’mon guys – Give Mauli a break!! Learn to call a spade a spade. I agree, she’d been singing badly, but she seems to have sprung back to her original form.

]]> By: Anonymous http://saregamapashow.com/2007/07/review-of-27th-episode-of-sa-re-ga-ma.html/comment-page-1#comment-2134 Anonymous Sat, 28 Jul 2007 16:23:00 +0000 http://saregamapashow.pap-smear.org/?p=137#comment-2134 Some songs of 60/70 for the girls that would have made a dhamakedaar effect -<br/><br/>Tu jahan jahan chalega mera saaya saath hoga<br/><br/>Lag ja gale se phir yeh haseen raat ho na ho<br/><br/>Chain se humko kabhi aap ne jeene na diya<br/><br/>Raina beeti jaaye shaam na aaye<br/><br/>Honto pe aisi baat main dabake chali aayi<br/><br/>Jaa re jaa re ud ja re panchi<br/><br/><br/>Poonam's song selection was the worst. Next is Joy's. Followed by all others. Except for Amanat and Aneek. Perfect song selection that showcased their vocals and emotions.<br/><br/>Mauli was bad. She sang the whole song in a lower note. Took the punch out of the sexy song. Some songs of 60/70 for the girls that would have made a dhamakedaar effect -

Tu jahan jahan chalega mera saaya saath hoga

Lag ja gale se phir yeh haseen raat ho na ho

Chain se humko kabhi aap ne jeene na diya

Raina beeti jaaye shaam na aaye

Honto pe aisi baat main dabake chali aayi

Jaa re jaa re ud ja re panchi

Poonam’s song selection was the worst. Next is Joy’s. Followed by all others. Except for Amanat and Aneek. Perfect song selection that showcased their vocals and emotions.

Mauli was bad. She sang the whole song in a lower note. Took the punch out of the sexy song.

]]> By: Anonymous http://saregamapashow.com/2007/07/review-of-27th-episode-of-sa-re-ga-ma.html/comment-page-1#comment-2132 Anonymous Sat, 28 Jul 2007 15:26:00 +0000 http://saregamapashow.pap-smear.org/?p=137#comment-2132 mauli ure just awesome..therez absolutely no doubt abt it..uve got a luvly voice, a luvly smile n a very graceful personality.ure not only a mindblasting singer as well as a performer.dun giv a damn to all those craps who keep talking lyke diziraptures bcz they barely knw abt music..GO MAULIIIIIIIIIIIII mauli ure just awesome..therez absolutely no doubt abt it..uve got a luvly voice, a luvly smile n a very graceful personality.ure not only a mindblasting singer as well as a performer.dun giv a damn to all those craps who keep talking lyke diziraptures bcz they barely knw abt music..GO MAULIIIIIIIIIIIII

]]> By: SRGMP SHOW FANS (UK) http://saregamapashow.com/2007/07/review-of-27th-episode-of-sa-re-ga-ma.html/comment-page-1#comment-2127 SRGMP SHOW FANS (UK) Sat, 28 Jul 2007 13:26:00 +0000 http://saregamapashow.pap-smear.org/?p=137#comment-2127 WRITTEN BY: SAREGAMAPA SHOW FANS (UK)<br/><br/>27th Jul. episode was not as good as the previous one but there was another most important thing the elimination of Nirupama Dey. I think that was fair elmination according to her previous episodes performance. In other way if she wont be eliminated then Abhijit could have the chances for elimination according to me. <br/><br/>I'm totally agree with Preity36 who mentioned above in her comments about Mussarat. Yes, infact he's not getting the true and deserving votes from public just because of patriotism bases. This is big flaw of this show which will surely influence badly to overseas contestant specially Junaid, Amanat & Mussarat. We just appeal & request public to vote for a better and deserving singer not for your local favorites. Try to look the whole features of performances and comparison should be made on performance otherwise we wont be able to justify with true and best singers in finals. Your justification is very important so please try to evaluate all the singing talent not your patriotism and racism. People of India should remember that event when Shilpa Shetty (Winner of CBB) had to face the racism challenge from Jade and then public protested all over the India against it and if it is all about Indian people and they believe in NO RACISM then why it always happening in the show that judges and contestant mostly request and appeal for votes from their particular and related areas where they belong and what about those overseas contestants. Why they always talk about Jay Maharashter, Assam, Bengal or UP etc. Isn't this racism?? and isn't this unfair with overseas contestant who have to also appeal vote from Indian people. <br/><br/>Anyway I hope most of the people wouldnt agree with the things shared above but this is fact. Let's have a look at this episode's performance. I think Sumedha, Amanat, Raja, Neelum & Junaid were fantastic. Aneek & Harpreet were also good but not much appreciatable. Did you guys guess that the Mussarat's song tempo of the track was very fast as compare to the song and Mussarat had to struggle with the track. Quite hard to perform unbalanced tempo and I think Mussarat should have to work hard to choose the right songs which can he easily sing and HR should give sometime to polish his gharana member as ID, Bappi & VS are doing. I dont know why HR is only criticise the things always and I'm sure he will spoil his students life to put them in meaningless and worthless things. I'm not impressed again with Mauli's Pardey Mein Rehne Do as she totally spoiled a very beautiful song sung by Asha Ji. Totally very different sur and she was struggling alot with the song and it sounds like she messing up with the surs. Well, let's see Sat. Performances so that we can have good discussion on to contendors. <br/><br/>Thank you for reading. <br/><br/>Date: 28/07/2007<br/>Time posted: 14:21 <br/><br/>SAREGAMAPA SHOW FANS (UK) WRITTEN BY: SAREGAMAPA SHOW FANS (UK)

27th Jul. episode was not as good as the previous one but there was another most important thing the elimination of Nirupama Dey. I think that was fair elmination according to her previous episodes performance. In other way if she wont be eliminated then Abhijit could have the chances for elimination according to me.

I’m totally agree with Preity36 who mentioned above in her comments about Mussarat. Yes, infact he’s not getting the true and deserving votes from public just because of patriotism bases. This is big flaw of this show which will surely influence badly to overseas contestant specially Junaid, Amanat & Mussarat. We just appeal & request public to vote for a better and deserving singer not for your local favorites. Try to look the whole features of performances and comparison should be made on performance otherwise we wont be able to justify with true and best singers in finals. Your justification is very important so please try to evaluate all the singing talent not your patriotism and racism. People of India should remember that event when Shilpa Shetty (Winner of CBB) had to face the racism challenge from Jade and then public protested all over the India against it and if it is all about Indian people and they believe in NO RACISM then why it always happening in the show that judges and contestant mostly request and appeal for votes from their particular and related areas where they belong and what about those overseas contestants. Why they always talk about Jay Maharashter, Assam, Bengal or UP etc. Isn’t this racism?? and isn’t this unfair with overseas contestant who have to also appeal vote from Indian people.

Anyway I hope most of the people wouldnt agree with the things shared above but this is fact. Let’s have a look at this episode’s performance. I think Sumedha, Amanat, Raja, Neelum & Junaid were fantastic. Aneek & Harpreet were also good but not much appreciatable. Did you guys guess that the Mussarat’s song tempo of the track was very fast as compare to the song and Mussarat had to struggle with the track. Quite hard to perform unbalanced tempo and I think Mussarat should have to work hard to choose the right songs which can he easily sing and HR should give sometime to polish his gharana member as ID, Bappi & VS are doing. I dont know why HR is only criticise the things always and I’m sure he will spoil his students life to put them in meaningless and worthless things. I’m not impressed again with Mauli’s Pardey Mein Rehne Do as she totally spoiled a very beautiful song sung by Asha Ji. Totally very different sur and she was struggling alot with the song and it sounds like she messing up with the surs. Well, let’s see Sat. Performances so that we can have good discussion on to contendors.

Thank you for reading.

Date: 28/07/2007
Time posted: 14:21

SAREGAMAPA SHOW FANS (UK)

]]>