Your Ad Here

Poll - Shreshtha or Mauli? Your opinion on Chakravyuh Round…

Written on June 23, 2007 – 3:40 am | by admin |

In Friday’s episode (22nd June) Mauli Dave has got green card and entered in final Round of Agnipariksha while Shreshtha who sang very well and was apprecialted by all Mentors got eliminated from saregamapa Challenge 2007. What is your opinion on chakravyuh Round? Who was better singer amongst girl? Shreshtha or Mauli?

Here are few comments after first round performances -

Vishal – Shreshta was the best today. Mauli is great performer but for singing she needs to figure it out.
Shekhar – Mauli, the aalap was great but after that sur was flat and pitching was not perfect…Shreshtha was awesome
ID – Shreshtha sang first time really well but Mauli is performing consistently well so we need singers who perform consistently …
BL – Shreshtha sang really well but Mauli also performed well. BL says Mauli is Shakira of India …and he will prove it…

Overall everyone likes Shreshtha’s performance

Here are comments after second round performances -

Vishal – Being a Sindhi I was feeling lonely but you sang a Sindhi song and made me proud. Shreshtha it was wonderful performance. Mauli you need to work hard on your lower notes.
Shekhar – Shreshtha you have powerful voice, Mauli you could have done better than this
BL – The Dama Dum song is very common and has been sung many times at the stage.. So, nothing new.. (what does that mean?) Mauli follows the record a lot and copies too much…
HR – Shreshtha you have done a fantastic job..outstanding..Mauli is one of superior and star contestants of this show. Mauli is performing very well consistently and she has huge fan following…If suddenly Mauli is out of the show then it’s a big JHATKa…I would say Mauli shouldn’t be out today…

Is there any justification for such comments from Himesh? How can he says Mauli shouldn’t be out today as she has huge fan following? So ‘Fan following is more important than singing’?

What is your opinion on chakravyuh Round? Who was better singer amongst girl? Shreshtha or Mauli?

Technorati: , ,

71 Comments

  • At 2007.06.23 07:03, Anonymous said:

    I think along with Mauli you should also throw Himmesh and Mr. Lahiri out of the show.

    • At 2007.06.23 07:33, Deepak said:

      Judgment should be on the basis of that day singing performance not on the basis of no. of fans or look or older performances.And on the basis of 22nd june perfomance,Shrestha was much better than Mauli.

      • At 2007.06.23 08:46, Anonymous said:

        Mauli sang a bit better than shrestha - ITS A FACT and admit it u all haters out dere….
        deepak dont know what he is talkin bout - dont b payin no attention to him… once again hez a hater !! You keep doin yo thing baby…WE LOVE U !

        • At 2007.06.23 08:55, Anonymous said:

          I don’t like Mauli’s singing too. But the way it’s looking right now it will go like this. Mauli will go very far in the top 10 because all the horny people will vote for her. LOL And Believe me there are a lot of those #*#%%*#F+uck_ers… :@!!!

          This show’s name of good singers in the top 10 will be ruined by the likes of Mauli. It’s very sad that a thing like this could happen. In the worst case Mauli Could Win Saregamapa. If that’s so than it’s the end of saregama’s reputation :D

          But I wish good luck to everyone in the top 10. Even to Mauli beacause she’s only a human too and she’s the one being trapped in the middle of all this. People shoudn’t hate her but te people who made this possible.

          (example of horny one is the one above me… Just look at his writing ” keep doin yo thing BABY!!” See, just what I meant :D)

          That all for now…

          • At 2007.06.23 09:06, Anonymous said:

            Its called CHEERING for your fav. contestant from ur hometown…not being horny u IDIOT indian !

            • At 2007.06.23 09:07, Anonymous said:

              Shreshtha really deserves to stay in top 10. Mauli’s performance was not up to the mark. This is fact and the people who think that she sings really good, are their crazy supporters who dont know about singing. All the contraversy is based on her first performance and yes this show is taking wrong track because of wrong judgement and it started when Asha ji eliminated Sarika, then Sikandar’s turn then Wasi and now Shreshtha. We cant sacrifice talented singers because of a particular ghetto based singer. Mauli being a ghetto which is effecting on shows popularity into non reality show. So this will let down all the people who watch a reality show.

              • At 2007.06.23 09:44, Anonymous said:

                wellllllllllllllllll…
                ewwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww….
                mauli u singed really really badddddddd…like a goat… i only like ur maiya maiya song…thats it and you can’t even sing slowwwwww songs too…but the other girl shes better than u shreshtha…this judge budda is soo stupid…haha sorry

                • At 2007.06.23 11:32, Jason G. said:

                  Admin:
                  There should be a censor on this website. People are turning it into a vulgar site. This is a family show. Would you want children reading such comments? Or the relatives of the contestants to see these things? You people should be ashamed of yourselves!

                  • At 2007.06.23 12:35, Rishikesh said:

                    the decision given by the mahaguru was totally wrong.the particular day’s perfomance is taken in to consideration,so in that case shrestha should have entered the agnipariksha round &not mauli dave.the mentors comment on mauli’s previous good performance definately were made to influence the decision of the mahaguru.Mauli Dave can be good performer but when it comes to singing she is yet to prove her versatility.the performer thing should be left to programmes like INDIAN IDOL because they give that extra importance to performance & not to the singing talent of the contestant.SAREGAMAPA is the original & the first talent show & they have always maintained high standards of singing.the elimination of shrestha was indeed shocking…it was sheer partiality on the part of mentors & mahaguru.if they want to prove that they r impartial then they should bring back shrestha immediately without waiting for the public voting.

                    • At 2007.06.23 12:57, Anonymous said:

                      Pls start respecting the talent of Mauli Dave. As Bappi Da says she is “Shakira of India”…so give some weightage to this line.
                      Also she is performing continously well…I’m sure she will emerge as the winner of the challenge.

                      Start Supporting MAULI DAVE….

                      • At 2007.06.23 13:03, Anonymous said:

                        Mauli - What did you do to Anandji? You should have been a sportman and given up your position. I am a Gujarati too and ashamed to see all Gujarati’s there making a mockery of music.

                        http://gujjuweb.com/20070623/saregamapa-a-fake-entertainer-wrong-judgements

                        Shrestha must be brought back in the competition because today she did not have to go at all.

                        • At 2007.06.23 14:45, Anonymous said:

                          this is not fair with the girl shersta, i think her singing was much better then this sexy looking girl,
                          but guy you also should know that they have to run ther show too so they need some sexy faces too singing is not enough.

                          • At 2007.06.23 14:55, Anonymous said:

                            A good singer + performer is definately better than a good singer.
                            Both Mauli and Shresta are good singers, but I enjoy watching Mauli more than Shresta and that’s what counts.
                            It was a right decision to keep Mauli in the show. After every cut, there are always people who dont like the decision and accuse the judges. I personally didt thing any wrong decision has been made till now in challenge 2007.

                            • At 2007.06.23 15:34, Anonymous said:

                              Either people do not understand music or there is some kind of favour going on. Yesterday was once again a wrong judgment day. Shresta is a better singer. If we are correct you might see Mauli moving forward and maybe winning and reson is not singing. There are some other worng judgment too in Saragamapa. Of course who ever is going to get closer or in the final will Win. The key is not to let wrong person get there.

                              • At 2007.06.23 15:59, Anonymous said:

                                Channels make money of phone companies based on number of votes cast and business they generate for phone companies.
                                If they keep Mauli until show is open for public opinion, they can definately increase number of sms, first as Mauli has a lot of fan following and next as people against Mauli, will work harder for their favourite to stay, so Mauli will not go so soon.
                                Very highly possible she will be at the top.
                                This is not a talent show, it is just a show generating rokda for channel. As far as the talent goes, these kids do get a chance to show their talent to todays music directors and the good ones will get work.

                                • At 2007.06.23 16:32, Anonymous said:

                                  I totally agree with you guys. MAULI doesnt fit this contest. Hey man this is a contest for talent not tits and ass show. Mauli can sing only a few songs. Shreshta was 100 times better than Mauli. But guys do you know a term called MONEY TALKS. Thats exactly what happens. Its a TRP game guys, and Mauli does generate a lot of TRP for Zee T V to add to its down trend to TRP Mr. Gajendra Singh quit the show and joined star t v so they had to survive. Anyways dont be fooled by the judgement the channel influenced ANANDJIBHAI to favour Mauli instead of Shreshta. Totally commercial nothing personal.

                                  • At 2007.06.23 17:26, Anonymous said:

                                    mauli sings the same kinds of songs with the same kind of voice - but if that works for her then whatever. however, it was clear in the chakravuye round that shresta was a more competent singer… and just cuz mauli speaks gujurati or has a big fan following does not trump the fact that shresta sang better.

                                    • At 2007.06.23 18:16, Anuradha said:

                                      Shashi,

                                      It was said that there was a performance by Mauli and Srestha together to find who is the best and that it was shown in Hungama of Zee Music.. Could you please get the video for that episode?? This will solve most of the problems

                                      • At 2007.06.23 19:04, Jason G. said:

                                        Attention administrator:
                                        Please address the abusive language used in blogs. A complaint will follow if this website allows such comments to be made.

                                        • At 2007.06.23 21:35, Anonymous said:

                                          Dear Administrator and show coordinator:
                                          You have to stop posting the abusive comments. This degrade the image of the show. Also you should filter the comments prior to posting. You should stop this kind poll which provoke the crazy people and ruin the purpose of the show. Even the opinion poll’s results reflect the fake and unrealistic numbers.

                                          Also you should publish the video with your clear comments that was not seen by the audience in US, UK etc, outside the India. In which the issue was resolved by giving one extra chance to Mauli and Shreshta to sing the same song. Please POST THIS IMMEDIATELY.

                                          Please post your clarification and withdrow all abusive comments including the fake results of this proking poll.

                                          Thanks.

                                          BP

                                          • At 2007.06.23 22:08, Anonymous said:

                                            Mauli can only sing Maiya maiya…she didn’t sing other songs very well. I don’t know how she is there ,just bcoz of her looks and performance.She can not sing song in pure Hindi, surely she has accent problem.

                                            • At 2007.06.23 22:53, Anonymous said:

                                              YEAH SHRESHTA YOU WERE THE BEST ON CHAKRAVYU ROUND DUNNO WHY THEY ELIMINATED YOU AND EVEN DONT GET NERVOUS OR BE SAD BECOZ I AM SURE THAT YOU WILL BE BACK WITH THE HELP OF BRAHMASTRA SO KEEP ALWAYS SMILING -BY YOUR #1 FAN

                                              • At 2007.06.23 23:38, Anonymous said:

                                                hi

                                                I think Shresta deserves to be in final reound 1000% , she is far more better than Mauli i wonder whether that MAULI CAN ONLY SING MAIYA SONG if you are considering a persons talent on 1 song its not a constest as vishal ji said so my opinion is Mauli DOESNT deserve to be in the Final ROUND and i wish Shresta will come to the show in Bhramashastra

                                                • At 2007.06.24 00:52, Vimal said:

                                                  shreshta was much much better today. no comparison. i think judges were in pressure as mauli is so famous and has a HUGE fan following. im one of them. BUT, it was a wrong decision. mauli will be a star no matter what, but shreshta deserved to be in much much more than mauli. its a clear case of favouritism, prejudice or in layman terms cheating. dear judges….U SUCK

                                                  • At 2007.06.24 03:43, Anonymous said:

                                                    This is a stupid decision. Anandji should not given decision like that, this is frustrating.

                                                    • At 2007.06.24 03:48, Anonymous said:

                                                      This is a stupid decision. Shrestha is much more better than Mouli. Anandji should not have given decision like that.

                                                      • At 2007.06.24 04:04, ravi said:

                                                        mauli didnt sing as expected but she is awesome performer with full of energy and confidence shrestha sang too good but as per the rule one has to go so mauli was always a first choice becuase in the later part of the show she will rock and will certainly stay till the vary end and will win mauli our best wishes are with you come back in fullflow and take josh back in the show
                                                        i am very very big of urs so just sake of your fans give your best

                                                        • At 2007.06.24 05:17, piu said:

                                                          What HImesh did it is surprissing.When it was the question of MUSSARAT he shouted like a hero so what went wrong for SHRESTYA.It realy hearts me

                                                          • At 2007.06.24 09:00, Anonymous said:

                                                            hiii
                                                            In the starting of SAREGAMAPA…..Mauli had gave gud performance…bt…after dat i dont think she had given gud performance….In 22june SHRESTA done very good….there z a wrong judgement by Maha Guru…..Himesh have 2put question…on this…
                                                            Plz vote 4 SHRESTA nd get her back…nd put Mauli out…. she can only sing One song MAYYA MAYYA song ….Himesh it was surprisng why u hve nt put any question on Maha Guru wrong judgement…when u can Fight 4 MUSSARAT..y nt 4 SHRESTYA….u hve really heart ur fan………
                                                            PLZ VOTE 4 SHRESTYA ND GET HER BACK……….SHE IS MUCH BETTER THAN MAULI…….

                                                            • At 2007.06.24 12:46, Anonymous said:

                                                              i think the reason himesh commented like he did is because having a huge fan following is what will keep the show “alive” if muali was out MANY people would be upset.

                                                              I don’t think mauli will win the competition (and i think the judges know that) but they want to keep her because it will bring more viewers to watch the show. that is how the entertainment industry runs.

                                                              Personally i think mauli should have been out because she is a performer and not a singer. Shesta can sing realllyyyyyyy well! Hopefully she will be back.

                                                              Also, I dont think anyone really argued for Shesta because nothing would have come out of it. The decision was final and so there was no reason to really argue. Other times people argue its about how the person sang or their performance or why they should be versatile and things like that…I think that the last times the gurus have challenged the mahagurus decisions many of the mahagurus were insulted…so the gurus were probably asked not to do that kind of stuff

                                                              • At 2007.06.24 18:12, Anonymous said:

                                                                I hereby rename the Gurus and MahaGurus to
                                                                Tattus and MahaTattus

                                                                CheSs

                                                                • At 2007.06.24 21:58, Anonymous said:

                                                                  Shrestha was much better than Mauli

                                                                  • At 2007.06.25 00:02, Anonymous said:

                                                                    hi every1. i think shrista was better than mauli she didn’t deserve to leave if judged on that day’s performance.

                                                                    • At 2007.06.25 02:15, Shaubhik said:

                                                                      Hi Mauli , You are a star . I saw you in the last episode when RAJA was out . What i like most is your simplicity & down to earth nature. I also saw you cooking & having some masti with the participents. Be like what you are . You have a long way to go. This is just the begining. All the very best for everything you do in your life.

                                                                      • At 2007.06.25 06:04, Anonymous said:

                                                                        No Doubt Mouli is great performer but only performer she is not a real singer. She is just trying to copy Shakeera…………

                                                                        She should learn music as Vishal-Shekhar said. A singer must be all rounder/versatile but Mouli always choose the same kind of songs.

                                                                        And Shrestha is much much better than her. I think Anandji’s decision is wrong.

                                                                        • At 2007.06.25 09:49, ravi said:

                                                                          mauli you are best you are best performer just put some hard work on singing no doubt you will win saregamapa 2007 and plz comeback with wow performence and give a strong reply to your critics and i knw u will do it for the sake of your fans and that also very soon
                                                                          i am a very very big fan of you
                                                                          you have to give your best for the sake of your fans
                                                                          if its possible plz reply on ravi.cancerian@gmail.com

                                                                          • At 2007.06.25 09:50, Anonymous said:

                                                                            It was a total biased descision. I really feel pity on himesh as inspite of being a guru of such a talented singer he could not support shreshtha. If a student have passed all the preliminary exams but could not perform in board exams then does board passes him based on the past performance? If a F-16 polot was good in practice and hit targets with accuracy but misses in real war then he gets killed by the enimy, thats what the vishwa-yudh is !! You must perform at that moment and if you can not then go back home, practice it and come again in next year, everyone will welcome you with same enthusiasm and love. The point I want to make is every participants shud be judged on that day’s performanance and not past and thats why I think we keep on bringing new maha gurus so that they havnt seen past performances of the candidates and will surely judge them on that day’s performance, then only we can get unbiased judgement.

                                                                            One very bad thing was noticable was ismail darbar is always trying to influence mahagurus judgement by making some comments before maha guru’s desicion. If this continues then we r sorry Mr. Ismail darbar but you should be thrown out of your position, we have many talented music directors who can replace you easily and become guru for yalgar gharana.

                                                                            I dont hate mauli or like shreshtha but i really hate bad descition and would like to have unbiased judgement. Otherwise just dont held such compititions and give award to ur favourite cadidate directly, why to waste huge money and everybody’s time..

                                                                            • At 2007.06.25 10:26, Anonymous said:

                                                                              WELL SAID… CHEERS!! HOPEFULLY NOW THE MAULI FANS WILL BE ABLE TO SEE CLEAR THAT ITS HIGH TIME SHE MUST GO.

                                                                              • At 2007.06.25 10:42, Anonymous said:

                                                                                well friends Mauli isnt a bad singer …its just that she is not a versatile singer …n yesterday definitely Sreshtha deserved the greenlight…but we musnt not blame her bcoz the poor girl herself admitted that Shreshtha was better than her…she knows what she lacks and hopefully she will work hard on those aspects in further competition

                                                                                • At 2007.06.25 11:15, Anonymous said:

                                                                                  whatever….it’s not about how much the person will improve eventually.
                                                                                  It was about what the person sang at that particular moment.
                                                                                  That budha judge is having some hearing problems and he should be thrown out of the show with all due respect.
                                                                                  Mauli does not know that ABC of sur and taal. All she does is scream. Whether it is a slow song or a fast track, she kills it.
                                                                                  Bottom line, she does not deserve a show like SAREGAMAPA.

                                                                                  • At 2007.06.25 11:18, Anonymous said:

                                                                                    I totally Agree. Mauli is a good singer. Her singing is noticable and makes an impact, even though it may not be techinically perfect.
                                                                                    Sreshtha’s singing was not even noticable until the only one duma dum. Stop thinking Sreshtha is God and learn to appritiate Mauli.

                                                                                    • At 2007.06.25 11:50, Anonymous said:

                                                                                      Mauli is a good singer. No question. But this show is losing reputation. Number of bad judgements can lose a lot of fans. Let’s face it. Mauli even got to this show cuz she sung Maiya Maiya AGAIN. SHE HAD TWO CHANCES! and then this. Mauli is a good singer but TODAY, Shrestha was much better. Judgement should be on THAT DAY’s singing not on reputation

                                                                                      • At 2007.06.25 13:41, frank said:

                                                                                        Yes, all shows are about TRP ratings. So, based on that, Mauli has better performer value which will keep the viewers interest going. If anybody wants unbiased judgement on singing alone, they shouldn’t watch this show. The only way that’s possible is when singers sing behind a curtain and judges select the best voice they hear, not see. This happens in selecting sopranos etc. for operas. All these TV shows should be watched for their controversies, not talent.

                                                                                        • At 2007.06.25 15:34, Ironhide said:

                                                                                          Mauli Dave is Saragamapa’s answer to American Idol’s Sanjaya Malakar - kept in the running because of the controversy (which equals higher TRP’s)

                                                                                          Anandjibhai’s judgement was so unjust, even he couldn’t provide Shreshta a proper explanation at the end when Shreshta was asking him what she did wrong.

                                                                                          This show seems to be taking the Indian Idol path of lameness.

                                                                                          • At 2007.06.25 22:08, Anonymous said:

                                                                                            i agree completely wid u…

                                                                                            This show seems to be taking the Indian Idol path of lameness.”

                                                                                            • At 2007.06.25 22:27, Anonymous said:

                                                                                              As someone posted above, Mauli did sound like a goat on primetime and with her one style of screams , it is becoming unbearable as a viewer and the show is losing the charm. With two more shows with her baaaa I will definitely tune out of zee. And where is the public voting , that should tell these super judges that even their compositions success and now the judgements depends on us viewers. Their opinion means didly squat when we can hear for ourselves what is good.

                                                                                              ZEE telefilms, please spare the viewers of such poor judgement display and the resulting anguish.

                                                                                              • At 2007.06.26 01:36, Anonymous said:

                                                                                                Shrestha was no doubt better than Mauli (on any day) and deserved to be in. There have been many wrong judgements in challenge 2007 and this is one of them.

                                                                                                • At 2007.06.26 16:58, Vimal said:

                                                                                                  very true…all mauli does is scream…and did u notice ..she can sing only item songs…and not any classical based songs or love songs..i have a lot to say but im too frustrated to say anything…
                                                                                                  WHAT I DONT UNDERSTAND IS….IF YOU NOTICE, MOST OF THE PPL ARE WRITING BAD ABOUT MAULI HERE, THEN HOW COME SHE HAS SO MANY VOTES ON THE POLL….I THINK THERE IS SOME BOGUS VOTING GOING ON….WHAT DO U THINK GUYS

                                                                                                  • At 2007.06.26 19:53, Anonymous said:

                                                                                                    What more should I say after all these folks. She is the only one who can think of singing such a wonderful composition(of Shubha Mudgal) like a cabaret song. And she gets more marks than Shrestha for that. Kudos to the mentors and Judges. With such a kind of biased judgement, I do not think there is anything in her way(to becoming the ultimate winner)

                                                                                                    • At 2007.06.26 20:30, Anonymous said:

                                                                                                      okay to the person above…that shubha mudgal song WAS NOT CABARET! i sing and i know what cabaret is. it was her “mayya mayya” twist of the song (like all others) don’t get me wrong she is talented and sometimes she pulls it off really well…and other times its sorta annoying and i wish she would just sing the song without so many alterations.

                                                                                                      Also, when she can’t hit high notes…she screams them…FOR EXAMPLE, in K Sera Sera she screams the high noted “jo bhi ho so ho….” and that really hurt my ears…because it would be okay if she hit the note and screamed it (because lots of artists do that and its cool sometimes)…but it she sang it flat and she screamed it (which is not a good combination.)

                                                                                                      She is not a technically good singer (because things like the example above happen alot)…and i dont know how much she can really improve.

                                                                                                      Even the judges told her that “she needs to figure her singing out, but that she is a great performer” and I 100% agree!

                                                                                                      I personally don’t like any of the girls besides sumedha, she has good voice quality.

                                                                                                      ALL OF THE GUYS ROCK!!! I think one of them will win! Hopefully! :o)

                                                                                                      • At 2007.06.27 01:59, Raju said:

                                                                                                        Honestly, most (not all) of the female contestants are not up to standards, and if the show would have agreed that men and women are equal, then more men would have been in the next rounds.Probably Sumedha is the best challenger against Mussarat, Amanat, Apurva and Junaid.
                                                                                                        And I am not biased towards the men, its just what I see in the show. In “another famous” singing show I think the best singer is outright a girl, so there!

                                                                                                        • At 2007.06.27 06:40, Anonymous said:

                                                                                                          This is in response to ironhide’s comments. I think atleast Sanjaya showed a variety in his hairstyles..forget the siniging. But what is so unique about Mauli that she’s still on this show?
                                                                                                          She’s just like those local dandiya singers, who do not care about any sur or taal, all they do is scream and shout and even if they make mistakes the musicians cover it up..

                                                                                                          • At 2007.06.27 11:31, Parveen said:

                                                                                                            Well I completely agrre that based on that single performance of mast kalandar shreshta should have gone through instead of mauli. she was much better in that performance.

                                                                                                            but those of you who shreshta is much better than mauli, i have my doubts. before that particular episode i didnt even notice shestha on the show. so based on one single performance we cannot say that she is way better than mauli. but yes she should have been in the top 10 based on mast kalandar performance

                                                                                                            • At 2007.06.27 17:15, Anonymous said:

                                                                                                              your supposed to base it off that days you cant bring into account her last weeks show or anything else shresta sang beautifully and shouldve gone to the next round.. besides maya maya. wat can mauli sing? nothing.. Apurva is first to go out of junaid amanat and mussarat.. then junaid goes.. and at the end mussarat will win becasue mussarat has sang beautfiully in every round and earned the bye.. its a joke why joy is stil in sikander or wasi were better contenders for that spot or even raja..

                                                                                                              • At 2007.06.28 11:03, Vikram said:

                                                                                                                Based on the performance, Shreshta should have won. It is very unfortunate that popularity is getting in the way of judgment. Mauli has been spectacular in one song that she has already done twice. Mayya mayya is just her song, that’s it. Apart from that song, she’s been good , no doubt, but not outstanding. Shreshta that day was very good. We don’t get to see the unedited version of the program so I don’t know what exactly transpired there but that decision was flat out wrong.

                                                                                                                • At 2007.06.28 13:34, Lazni said:

                                                                                                                  U know wht was the most funniest thing. When shreshta asks Anandji ” Wht i did wrong? What was my fault?. HE said Confidence. This is a show abut singing or abut confidence. What a joke.If they wanted ppl only to perform without any sur or taal, they shud hav said so before. There r plenty of ppl out there, who might not be good singers, but are great performers with their expressions and long legs. N tht Himesh is not even worth being a GURU, since he didnt even support Shreshta in any way. He was too busy praising Mauli for her screaming tunes. ANother thing, Ismail n Himesh kept on repeating tht Mauli has performed good consistently, when did that happen? Is it only me, coz i only remember her Mayya Mayya song where she was praised n in other songs of hers were terrbile. still she went through. HOW?

                                                                                                                  Shrestha deserves to be in the TOP 10. N thts a fact that 90% of the ppl with a conscious agree, n the remaining might be only looking at her Mauli’s long legs and forget whts actually music

                                                                                                                  • At 2007.06.28 14:29, Anonymous said:

                                                                                                                    What rubbish. Sreshta sang only one song upto mark that is duma dum. None of her other performance was even close to Mauli’s any other performance. Mauli got not so great comments from judges in other rounds just because they expect much more from her.

                                                                                                                    • At 2007.06.28 22:41, Anonymous said:

                                                                                                                      who cares how shresta sang b4 or how mauli sang b4. they wer ejuding them on THAT SPECIFIC DAY. how they sang that very day, why cant people understand that. you cant include maulis maya maya when they were judging her. i dont think she should be in the competition because she is simply not a diverse singer. and fine she is a good singer in SOME genres, but there were SO many other female singers that sang variety of songs in diff genres and still were good…if mauli is in the final, so should alot of other people thats all i have to say. in the end, most competitions become a popularity contest, u cant really help it….but i truly hope the best singer wins not without popularity but by fairness!

                                                                                                                      • At 2007.06.29 20:02, Anonymous said:

                                                                                                                        I personally believe that many of the people in the top 10 are not all that great and this year the show is reallly boring, but with performers and fast song singers like Mauli, the show is more interesting. If you think this decision is wrong, what about the one where asha-ji kicked sharika out of the show and kept the other girl who does not even sing all that great. I also believe there was a wrong decision when rimi was allowed to go to the finals because i find her singing high pitched. The results of this show do not really matter, as many of these contestants will probably never be heard again, unless some music director finds them capable.

                                                                                                                        So stop bugging Mauli about not being able to sing!

                                                                                                                        • At 2007.07.03 04:05, Anonymous said:

                                                                                                                          himesh made mauli sing maiya maiya again in front of anandji coz he himself is a typed singer as mauli is .These type of promotions may kill the morale of hardworking singers like shrestha.

                                                                                                                          • At 2007.07.05 14:33, Anonymous said:

                                                                                                                            shreshtha was really much better than mauli …

                                                                                                                            • At 2007.07.08 07:33, Anonymous said:

                                                                                                                              try to ignore the use of lipstick bappi da

                                                                                                                              • At 2007.07.08 07:36, Anonymous said:

                                                                                                                                ii accept that shreshtha was a better singer but it is more anjoyable to see mauli performance,not just ‘coz of her lookings but’coz of her attitude also n while her performance we dont get bored.

                                                                                                                                • At 2007.07.16 05:38, Anonymous said:

                                                                                                                                  mauli dave u such a stupid person n u cnt even sing properly. so i think u need to watch out ok
                                                                                                                                  n f… urselves up ok

                                                                                                                                  • At 2007.07.16 05:41, Anonymous said:

                                                                                                                                    mauli u dnt even knw hw to sing n dnt think u r such a beautful gurl becoz u look like the same as a donkey so go n f… urselves up
                                                                                                                                    t care
                                                                                                                                    n best of luck
                                                                                                                                    hope u cn sing properly
                                                                                                                                    see ya

                                                                                                                                    • At 2007.07.16 12:43, Anonymous said:

                                                                                                                                      Mauli,
                                                                                                                                      Once again this is your aunt’s friend.Do not give up from all dirty comments.Just ignore them and keep it up.You will be on the top later or sooner.
                                                                                                                                      Love from
                                                                                                                                      Pushpa S. Patel(Bristol,PA.19007)
                                                                                                                                      Ami Raval& Indirakaki

                                                                                                                                      • At 2007.07.26 22:37, Anonymous said:

                                                                                                                                        Mauli everyone will have different opinions about who is better than other.

                                                                                                                                        Whatever it is don’t loose your confident, do your very best.with all comments post here and past during the show, you can see people have *generously* criticize your performance.Just take them in a positive manner, as it will help you to built your inner strength and improvise your singing talent in the areas needed and become a versatile singer. Believe in GOD as Aishwarya Rai Bachchan always does. She is one good example for you! Poeple can say whatever they want but she is going places.So Shakira of India take us to a different platform. !!! cheers

                                                                                                                                        simmyrai
                                                                                                                                        malaysia

                                                                                                                                        • At 2007.07.28 14:54, Anonymous said:

                                                                                                                                          Mauli, may be a late performer but definately the girl is back with a bang.
                                                                                                                                          She had two consecutive gr8 week and this it was nt alone the look but her voice too that was giving her performance and tough battle, n definately this time her voice won over her performance. Well done girl, keep it up but haan haan no more hugs.. Ok! Gr8 going.. Dnt forget the show is about Singing and u really can do it!

                                                                                                                                          • At 2007.07.28 16:10, Anonymous said:

                                                                                                                                            mauli should be out now now it is enough to tolerate her coz she is a typed singer. other singers are much much better than her . i do not know why all judges are voteing her 10 as she deseve only 5
                                                                                                                                            pleaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaase eliminate her as soon as u can

                                                                                                                                            • At 2007.08.04 20:55, Anonymous said:

                                                                                                                                              Guys!!!
                                                                                                                                              After looking at some of the previous comments of fans of mauli let me tell u one thing that this is not the contest for finding “indian shakira “, its the “SA RE GA MA PA”
                                                                                                                                              King/queen of sur n taal who can sing any type of songs. Not just “mayya mayya”. So voters please vote for the real talent.
                                                                                                                                              And I’m sure mauli is NOT. Also
                                                                                                                                              Judgment should be on the basis of that day singing performance not on the basis of no. of fans or look or older performances.And on the basis of 22nd june(15th episode) perfomance,Shrestha was much better than Mauli.

                                                                                                                                              • At 2007.08.30 15:07, Mani said:

                                                                                                                                                THIS SHOW IS FOR SINGERS not performers, the only reason MAULI gets votes is cause of her looks and the way she dresses, ya she can sing MAYYA MAYYA well but nothing else, its pure bull! MAULI get off the show, just quit you know SHRESHTHA sang better, why are you being so ignorant? You should know by now that the only reason you are getting votes is cause of your looks, or you’re bribing the Zee tv team! Just get off the show and give the better singers wat they deserve!

                                                                                                                                                (Required)
                                                                                                                                                (Required, will not be published)

                                                                                                                                                Want to subscribe?

                                                                                                                                                  Or, subscribe via email: