Controversy over Sarika Singh’s elimination – was it justifiable?

Written on May 28, 2007 – 1:11 am | by admin |

The Saturday’s episode was Ashaji last episode on the saregamapa challenge 2007. In these few episodes she shared her knowledge with contestants but the elimination of Sarika Singh somehow left a bitter feeling amongst many. It is still a question on what basis Sarika was eliminated.

When it comes to the judgement, we all respect Ashaji’s point of view but still there are some facts that need clarifications.

1. All the Mentors liked Sarika’s both performances and she got the most praises from the Gurus and Ashaji herself.

2. When we consider the last episode (26th May), Sarika’s performance is far better than others. While Ashaji gave valuable advices to other contestants, she didn’t bother to correct Sarika Singh.

3. Most of the people think that Jyoti should be eliminated as her first performance (before Ashaji’s coaching) was not good and even Ashaji wasn’t pleased with her performance.

4. Its little strange that Ashaji’s farewell was held before the ‘Girl’s result’. Ashaji should be there to clarify on what basis Sarika was eliminated.

Anyway, still mentors have the Brahmastra where they get to choose one of the contestant who was eliminated, and hope they will bring back Sarika Sing.

Technorati: , ,

Related Posts

4 Comments

  • At 2007.05.28 12:58, Anonymous said:

    Very true. Sarika did not desreve to be eliminated. She is excellent singer as compared to Jyoti.

    Hope to see her back.

    [Reply]
    • At 2007.05.30 17:06, Anonymous said:

      Sarika did not deserve to be eliminated and Ashaji’s judgement is not correct. On what basis she has given her judgement? Bring back Sarika………..

      [Reply]
      • At 2007.05.31 19:36, Anonymous said:

        As far as i know they are searching for an exceptional singer. Sarika wasn’t exceptionally. Jyoti was exceptional when she sang the song again. Anywayz Reecha Tripathi is the best

        [Reply]
        • At 2007.06.03 10:46, Jigyasha said:

          in my opinion jyoti was the one to be eliminated and not Sarika, she was amazing, infact flawless…whereas jyoti had to be corrected again and again…it just looked unfair to be and had a feeling that she was judged on her second performance as her first one was a total trash…

          [Reply]